Better On A Bagel Deli

4960 Nesconset Hwy, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 473-5858

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Grace Torgersen

Good food especially the bagels. Everyone is always pleasant. Very nice place to visit before work. Even Uber orders are done very quickly.

James Astea

Best bagels in the area, hands down.

Lori Ann Gibaldi

We go out of our way to come here to get our bagels. They are the best by far. No good bagels in our area that are good. There big fat, Fluffy fresh all the time. Been coming here to get bagels for 20 years.

K

The food is good. Please just try and prepare the way it's ordered. The kids working don't seem to have a care in the world. Staff is very slow. The bathroom is absolutely disgusting, the garbage receptacles are disgusting as you can see never been cleaned. Just get the staff to wake up and try and clean the place.

Justin Dehoyos

Slappin

M.

The place looked very clean. The bagel was fresh, soft on the inside and crunchy on the outside, lots of cream cheese and very tasty. BLT on a roll, perfectly made. Wish I had gotten Cole slaw instead of macaroni thimble, bland. Coffee, well it doesn't taste like coffee. Perhaps because I've gotten used to Colombian coffee with hot milk, which is rich and flavorful. It seemed to lack the aroma and flavor of real coffee, with a slightly bitter aftertaste. I could be wrong, but that's just my opinion. Much like having a plant based burger, close; but no cigar. The prices, although many seem to feel they are fair, I find them too high. Especially on the BLT and coffee as well. Perhaps because there is no other bagel shop in the vicinity, but going a bit further quality and much better prices can be found. Especially much tastier coffee. I love coffee, this one not so much. Early morning, no one in the store and took a long time to get the order done. On the plus side, the young lady was very friendly, polite and got my order done perfectly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Zz Walkup

They spit in the coleslaw! No way coleslaw Is supposed to be slimy! No way! Disgusting ?

Super slimy. I make homemade coleslaw and orders from other restaurants just to be sure!

They spit in the coleslaw. I do not recommend It.

Happy Home

These people know how to BEC

Rachel L

Classic Long Island bagel shop. Really solid bagel sandwiches, and I loved the BEC. A small selection of drinks, and not a lot of different cream cheeses compared to other places. But they absolutely meet expectations for a LI bagel shop. I'll come back often because I'm an absolute sucker for a

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Bacon Egg and Cheese, Bagels

Freddie Cain

Ever since the new owner took over at this place, how ever many years ago, it’s just been going down hill. The old owner was such a great guy, the new one is just a horrible person. The other day I got a bacon egg and cheese and the girl didn’t put bacon on it. I called and Tom told me I would get a free replacement. I went back and was getting it made and they went to charge me and I told them Tom said it would be free. They said well the bacon is free you still have to pay for the egg cheese and bagel. So because they messed up I still have to pay when I told I wasn’t going to need to. They don’t care about their customers in the slightest. You get told one thing and they do another. They raise their prices and then begin to skimp on stuff. Just go some where else that will respect you. It also seems a lot of their 5 star reviews are paid bots too.

Brandon Huss

Mind blowing good. From NC hands down best I've ever had. Thank you this place came recommended to us from family here on the island. Thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lonely Tomato

Food is great, staff is sometimes rude and inattentive.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 2

D Hensley

I just moved to the area and was trying a different bagel place for breakfast every morning. This place makes the best egg everything bagels. I ordered the same thing at every place, which is an egg everything bagel with cream cheese and bacon and not only does this one taste the best but it was the cheapest. Win win

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gaby H

Best bagels at the best price.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ti T

Good bagel store good food not the cleanest kitchen

Loading...