Buttercup's Dairy Store

Name: Buttercup's Dairy Store
Address: 285 Boyle Rd, Port Jefferson Station, New York, 11776, US
Telephone: (631) 928-4607
Price range: $
Rating: 3

$ • Bakery

Hours:
285 Boyle Rd, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 928-4607

About Buttercup's Dairy Store

Buttercup's Dairy Store is a cherished local establishment known for its fresh products and exceptional customer service. The friendly cashiers provide a pleasant experience, often offering to pack up purchases for customers. This store is a staple in the neighborhood, ideal for quick trips and deli items. They feature tasty homemade cookies and breads, making it a favorite spot for many. Recently, customers have praised the store for its 4' hero, which was described as the best party hero ever.

While the store may be small, it presents a convenient alternative to larger supermarkets, saving time and hassle. Customers have enjoyed great lunch specials that are very filling. However, some have noted a decline in the quality of desserts, mentioning that the frosting on cakes seems less, and some items like loaf cakes and crumb cakes have been dry. Despite these concerns, the register staff remains helpful and friendly, contributing to the overall positive atmosphere. Buttercup's Dairy Store continues to be a decent place to grab something quick for lunch or after work.