Buttercup's Dairy Store
285 Boyle Rd, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 928-4607
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
First off we really like this store anyway but this week we catered a holiday party and decided to order a 4' hero and it was the best party hero I've ever had. Awesome. Forget the other places and consider them next time.
In the past, i would frequent this Lil hidden gem. I would pick the boys up lunch a couple of times a week. They have great lunch specials that are totally worth it. And super yummy n filling. Always run in on wednesdays to grab dessert for my family as well. In the past , we all loved their pies, loaf cakes, and carrot cake. However, lately, the frosting is less, and loaf cakes seem dry. Even the crumb cakes. Ugh I tried the blueberry and the pumpkin crumb.
I...
I...
Normally, I have a good review of this local store but I'd like to take the time to thank Ethan, specially for going beyond anything one usually sees in a younger employee now a-days, thank you for giving me hope that the next generations aren't beyond consideration to others and pride of one's job.
You May Also Like
Old Town Bagels - Old Town Rd
![]()
Bagels, Salad
Old Town Pizza - 691 Old Town Rd
![]()
Pizza, Italian
Wing Wah Kitchen - 695 Old Town Rd
![]()
Chinese, Vegetarian