Buttercup's Dairy Store
285 Boyle Rd Suite 1, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 928-4607
Menu
Photos
+31 photos
+30 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I just left Buttercup and thought I'd share some thoughts. I've been going here for decades now. Found out about the place from my wife who grew up down the road. This place is one of a vanishing breed. A family owned establishment for generations that you just don't find anymore. It has a certain feel..a familiar charm about it. The employees' range from high school age to seniors, all kind and helpful. I can tell the customers are loyal, many having shopped...
Hidden gem!! Full deli inside with everything for a quick dinner or lunch, a mini grocery store and tons of fresh homemade pies and ice cream. All at a great price too. Will be coming back very soon!
You May Also Like
Old Town Bagels - Old Town Rd
![]()
Bagels, Salad
Old Town Pizza - 691 Old Town Rd
![]()
Pizza, Italian
Wing Wah Kitchen - 695 Old Town Rd
![]()
Chinese, Vegetarian
“The Manhattan” comes loaded with pastrami, corned beef, & turkey. Topped with tomatoes, lettuce, & thousand island dressing.
Comes on a roll or hero. It’s a sandwich you do battle with and one which I devoured. I savored each bite with relish.
This venue is very welcoming. It felt like walking into my Grandma’s home. Everything is delicious and you don’t leave hungry 😊.