I have been coming for 35 years and it’s maintained its excellence over the years. I feel like a time warp when I come back in because nothing has changed.
Pizza is the best on the island and it’s not close. They offer a premium product with consistency that makes every time I visit bring back the memories of that first bite 35 years ago.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rebekah Leggio
I used to LOVE this place but have to say last night was horrible! I walked in and it took what seemed like FOREVER for some to help me. I called in my order but it wasn't ready and I actually saw the guy throwing the ingredients so quickly make my pizza to put in the oven. I was there for a really long time and the AC was pumping and I jokingly said something to one of the people behind the desk and they were sarcastic and said well let me turn everything off for you. Nasty employee that wasn't sympathetic that I'm standing there for over 10 minutes freezing my butt off waiting for the pizza that should've already been made. We had ordered a Sicilian pie and a Grandma pie and they both looked exactly the same minus thinner crust. The pizza was horrible! It was bland and the cheese tasted like plastic!!!!!! I had a few people over and all the pizza should have been gone but most of it was thrown away.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Diana Dellamere
SO GOOD! Had a cheese Sicilian slice and a side of marinara. DELICIOUS! Crisp, crunchy crust, light fluffy dough, homemade balanced sauce and perfect amount of browned mozzarella. SO GOOD!
I NEVER order Sicilian slices bc when they are bad they are like a brick of bread with a little cheese. But this one was PERFECT!
The people were very cool even when super busy. Molto bene all around. 🤩
Cornell Anthony
They are great but it is time to go on the delivery apps like Uber Eats
Susan Surdow
I can't even believe that after 30+ years of coming here because of the amazing food, I was disappointed. I ordered 2 pies and a salad with cheese and extra dressing last week. One pie was slightly burned on the bottom, the crust was definitely thicker and chewier than usual and the sauce tasted a little different. My whole family agreed. The girl behind the counter couldnt find the order either. They ended up opening every box to check orders, didnt see it and started again before they found it. Dinner was still good, just not Colosseo spectacular.... more like their sister pizzeria Branchinelli's, good but not excellent.
Nicole Cloonan
Unbeatable. Classic NY.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Octo Plqyz
Friendly workers. Good food. No complaints 😎😎
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Schmidt
Best Pizza ever. My wife had the Sicilian and I had a meat slice, EXCELLENT.
Yes great Take Out pizza. But Oh boy my special highlight an Eat in hot out of the oven cheese slice with shared “Extra Dirty” garlic knots. Heaven!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Slice of Pizza
Kevin Stern
Best pizza shop been coming here since I was a kid.
Henry Debonis
Excellent
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Samantha Vogel
Best pizza 🍕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
karissa t
The plain slice was delicious but the sicilian was even better. The staff is very friendly and personable. I've never felt more welcome in any pizza restaurant than this one. Highly recommend Colosseo!
Very basic pizza and salads only menu.
Love it! Best pizza in Long Island!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have been coming for 35 years and it’s maintained its excellence over the years. I feel like a time warp when I come back in because nothing has changed.
Pizza is the best on the island and it’s not close. They offer a premium product with consistency that makes every time I visit bring back the memories of that first bite 35 years ago.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I used to LOVE this place but have to say last night was horrible! I walked in and it took what seemed like FOREVER for some to help me. I called in my order but it wasn't ready and I actually saw the guy throwing the ingredients so quickly make my pizza to put in the oven. I was there for a really long time and the AC was pumping and I jokingly said something to one of the people behind the desk and they were sarcastic and said well let me turn everything off for you. Nasty employee that wasn't sympathetic that I'm standing there for over 10 minutes freezing my butt off waiting for the pizza that should've already been made. We had ordered a Sicilian pie and a Grandma pie and they both looked exactly the same minus thinner crust. The pizza was horrible! It was bland and the cheese tasted like plastic!!!!!! I had a few people over and all the pizza should have been gone but most of it was thrown away.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
SO GOOD! Had a cheese Sicilian slice and a side of marinara. DELICIOUS! Crisp, crunchy crust, light fluffy dough, homemade balanced sauce and perfect amount of browned mozzarella. SO GOOD!
I NEVER order Sicilian slices bc when they are bad they are like a brick of bread with a little cheese. But this one was PERFECT!
The people were very cool even when super busy. Molto bene all around. 🤩
They are great but it is time to go on the delivery apps like Uber Eats
I can't even believe that after 30+ years of coming here because of the amazing food, I was disappointed. I ordered 2 pies and a salad with cheese and extra dressing last week. One pie was slightly burned on the bottom, the crust was definitely thicker and chewier than usual and the sauce tasted a little different. My whole family agreed. The girl behind the counter couldnt find the order either. They ended up opening every box to check orders, didnt see it and started again before they found it. Dinner was still good, just not Colosseo spectacular.... more like their sister pizzeria Branchinelli's, good but not excellent.
Unbeatable. Classic NY.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Friendly workers. Good food. No complaints 😎😎
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Pizza ever. My wife had the Sicilian and I had a meat slice, EXCELLENT.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Yes great Take Out pizza. But Oh boy my special highlight an Eat in hot out of the oven cheese slice with shared “Extra Dirty” garlic knots. Heaven!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Slice of Pizza
Best pizza shop been coming here since I was a kid.
Excellent
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza 🍕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The plain slice was delicious but the sicilian was even better. The staff is very friendly and personable. I've never felt more welcome in any pizza restaurant than this one. Highly recommend Colosseo!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...