Margaritas Cafe

4747-16 NY-347, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 642-8555

Recent Reviews

Tony T

Left my expensive sunglasses there and tried to get them back after a mediocre meal… staff def kept them .. food was way over priced.. and this establishment looks closed all the time anyways ?

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Brian BAtes

Bad food. Not good service and worse drinks. Pricey for such trash.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Cristina Briceno

The store is closed but accept orders online!Anybody answer for refundPlease close your networks and give me my money

Christine Starkey

They're nice and delicious food amazing margarita drinks also the service

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rai

I heard this place is good but no one picks up the phone and there's never availability to reserve online ahead of time. So what's the point. Very unfortunate. Really wanted to see what this place was like. Don't want to go without getting info before so we don't get turned away. Oh well.

Service: 3

P4665HTmm

Service was terrible. Place is definitely overprice considering the poor quality of food and drinks.

Melissa P.

Went with a girlfriend on a random weeknight, The music was festive. Our waitress was amazing, she helped us decide what to get and all of her suggestions were delicious! We will definitely be back!

Edward Masiello Jr

Having not eaten all day decided to try this place for dinner. Got the salmon in sauce dish with rice. Within a few hours got horribly sick and spent three days in and out of the bathroom. Will never eat there again.!!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Yayo22 B.

Hidden Gem!Best frozen drinks around. Pina Coladas are fresh, not pre-made. The fajitas come sizzling and are flavorful, nachos are great, the sides of rice, guac, tomatoes and refried beans are great, too. Best around actually. Outdoor seating, too.

V V

Food was pretty good but the service sucked waited a while to get chips and salsa, waited some more for drinks. Turned off by the

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Chris Castellano

Thought the food was expensive for what we got. I ordered arroz con pollo. Was expecting more. But overall very

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Katie G.

What a wonderful find! Strip mall on Nesconset Hwy and such good food, fun atmosphere and live music to boot! A great spot!!

Trae Will

Just ehhh. The food wasn’t at all bad but it wasn’t spectacular. The place gives old vibes. Like it need updating. I more than likely will NOT be going there again.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

mitchell rakita

06/17/2023 Very nice place. Port Jefferson Station. Seated immediately. Appeared to be lots of staff. Live music. All staff was friendly and warm. Our waiter was extremely knowledgeable of menu. We were party of 4My Jambalaya was terrific. Saturday evening and we were able to relax no rushing. Will definitely return

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Christine Ross

Nice spot. Food was delicious, and house margarita was perfect. Friendly staff.

Load More