The donuts were ok. The best was the dulce de leches Bavarian cream and the apple fritter. The rainbow cookie donut was a cake donut and it just had a rainbow cookie on it.
Brittany D.
Highly recommend. The associates are always so pleasant. The donuts are incredible. We live in Westbury and whenever we are near the area we have to stop in. So happy to see Covid didn't have them close!
Ashley K.
This place has the absolute worst hours, if the donuts were amazing and they had to delay open hours in order to keep up with orders then id understand but it seems to be just bad business and lazy owners. They are the same owners as newer restaurant in port Jeff as well call prohibition kitchen so I can only assume that are more focused of that then this and this donut shop is slowly going under. 10am open on sat and sun and 12 open on Friday... for a donut bakery! Just close down and let another shop take over because it's a complete waste. If you in the area, we've found that the other bakery between the the town hall and boat ramp is much better. Has a huge great selection there, friendly staff, amazing products and most of all THEY'RE OPEN!
Mitchell Parker
They're chocolate pudding pie was fantastic. The donuts were amazing
Mariah M.
Mixed reviews from the family today. Ordered two death by chocolates, one brownie, one red velvet and one linzer torte donuts. The death by chocolate made my mom throw up because it was so loaded and my sister said the red velvet was sour. She couldn't finish it. My death by chocolate wasn't the freshest but my chocolate brownie donut was great. A little shocked with the mixed reviews because they're usually very good.
Ryan Washington
Delicious.I think this store is responsible for me gaining a good 5lbs the past year. I can't walk past without getting at least 2 donuts.
Robin J.
Friendly staff and delicious donuts! My kids love this place! My daughter's favorite is the strawberry frosted
Cilia B.
Drove 30 mins east to go here because they said they open as 10am .... get here and it says 11am. Kinda pissed update your hours
Christina Gonzalez
Picked up a mini cake and donuts on Saturday. Nicole had taken my call ealier in the week, had answered ALL of my questions and offered lots of suggestions. She was so friendly, accomodating, understanding and helpful. The cake and donuts were a delicious hit at our house. Thank you so much! So glad to have a local donut shop close to home. Can't wait to order from you for future events!
Danielle P.
I've been to this establishment before but it's been well over a year so I was happy to finally pass this place when they were open. We got a few things but started off with the Apple of My Eye donut, easily my favorite of the bunch, it was a cider donut covered with a caramel glaze/frosting with apple pie filling in the middle, it was really soft and fresh and I loved every aspect of it, we got coffee and enjoyed that, the very nice woman who worked there was kind enough to make a fresh batch which was appreciated, we left with some donuts and now that I've tried a little of the four we brought home I'll try to keep my review of each one simple... as I can, the rainbow cookie donut was good, obviously the cookie was good but the donut tasted very much like a rainbow cookie with its jam drizzle and rainbow sprinkles (I'm aware that sprinkles don't go on a rainbow cookie, but it adds the "rainbow" to the donut) and chocolate donut... not the exact same thing but if you were to taste it without the cookie... you'd know where it got its influence from, I wrote Apple fritter in the description of my pics but... this might just be a cinnamon fritter donut type thing... this was actually my second favorite and easily a good combo with coffee, the cranberry tarte donut was unique and a real treat for those that love cranberry sauce (me) and jelly, visually it was very pretty and I could see this being an all year thing with different types of jelly, the glazed was the last I tried and ya know what?... it was so good and I found myself relieved bc places that do all the fun stuff sometimes don't do the good old fashioned stuff that well. I really want to try their blueberry lemon glaze donut... it's not as dressed up as the others but flavor wise it seems like a winner. The people who work here are great, I like the vibes. They also have a little area in the back with a couch where you can sit and good quality stuff in the fridge, Boylan sodas and Kombucha and homemade bread pudding, an amazing way to use day old donuts/buns etc... made me happy to see. I'm pretty sure they serve lattes and stuff like that too and will be sure to check it out next time. I'm very happy to have a place like this is in Port Jeff and think they make it little more fun and less pretentious.
Even if your aren't a fan of The Simpsons, how can anyone go wrong with a pink frosted donut with rainbow sprinkles. I was here around 4 pm on a Sunday and the donuts were still super fresh. Wandered in while the rest of my party was shopping at boutique shops near by and only finished half the donut before my cover was blown and pink frosting on my face probably didn't help. Highly recommend for kids both big and small
Sasha McIntosh
These donuts are insanely sweet. You have to expect that given the flavor choices, but there just aren’t any moderately sweet options (lemon curds, jams, etc). First thing in the morning and they have no hot coffee... at all. A disappointing experience overall.
Susan C.
Peering into the shop from the front door, the display of donuts looked enticing from afar. Walking in, I was a little disappointed when I saw how much icing and cream was loaded on the majority of the options, they looked positively sugar-laden, more than most donut shops. Seeing this made me a little wary and I should've gone with my gut instinct and left right there. Instead, being very determined to eat a donut, I went with a classic doughnut standard--the powdered jelly donut. And while I don't make a habit of comparing local eateries to chains, this donut was basically on par with my local DD. The dough itself was fluffy but without that slight bounciness of most artisanal donut places (at least the ones in NYC). Additionally the amount of filling in it was really sad--maybe a teaspoon's worth. A jelly donut without jelly is...not a jelly donut! My friend got the Holy Cannoli, but unfortunately no grail found here either. This was more of a frosted cake donut with cannoli filling piped on top. As a cake the texture was ok, moist and fluffy, but as a donut the texture just didn't hold together. After taking the first bite of the donut, the rest of the donut broke apart in my friend's hands. Also the cake + frosting and sweet cream was just really really sweet. This place needs to do some work on their recipes. I did want to add that store itself is very cute and the service was decent, however the donuts that were the main attraction just left a disappointing taste in my mouth.
Neil Boccio
Great donuts and better prices than North Fork Donuts in Mattituck.
Sharyn G.
Got donuts here for my birthday and let me tell you , they were AMAZING. The dough itself is just so moist and yummy. The nutella one is my favorite ! Recommend going here for high quality yummy donuts!!
The donuts were ok. The best was the dulce de leches Bavarian cream and the apple fritter. The rainbow cookie donut was a cake donut and it just had a rainbow cookie on it.
Highly recommend. The associates are always so pleasant. The donuts are incredible. We live in Westbury and whenever we are near the area we have to stop in. So happy to see Covid didn't have them close!
This place has the absolute worst hours, if the donuts were amazing and they had to delay open hours in order to keep up with orders then id understand but it seems to be just bad business and lazy owners. They are the same owners as newer restaurant in port Jeff as well call prohibition kitchen so I can only assume that are more focused of that then this and this donut shop is slowly going under. 10am open on sat and sun and 12 open on Friday... for a donut bakery! Just close down and let another shop take over because it's a complete waste. If you in the area, we've found that the other bakery between the the town hall and boat ramp is much better. Has a huge great selection there, friendly staff, amazing products and most of all THEY'RE OPEN!
They're chocolate pudding pie was fantastic. The donuts were amazing
Mixed reviews from the family today. Ordered two death by chocolates, one brownie, one red velvet and one linzer torte donuts. The death by chocolate made my mom throw up because it was so loaded and my sister said the red velvet was sour. She couldn't finish it. My death by chocolate wasn't the freshest but my chocolate brownie donut was great. A little shocked with the mixed reviews because they're usually very good.
Delicious.I think this store is responsible for me gaining a good 5lbs the past year. I can't walk past without getting at least 2 donuts.
Friendly staff and delicious donuts! My kids love this place! My daughter's favorite is the strawberry frosted
Drove 30 mins east to go here because they said they open as 10am .... get here and it says 11am. Kinda pissed update your hours
Picked up a mini cake and donuts on Saturday. Nicole had taken my call ealier in the week, had answered ALL of my questions and offered lots of suggestions. She was so friendly, accomodating, understanding and helpful. The cake and donuts were a delicious hit at our house. Thank you so much! So glad to have a local donut shop close to home. Can't wait to order from you for future events!
I've been to this establishment before but it's been well over a year so I was happy to finally pass this place when they were open. We got a few things but started off with the Apple of My Eye donut, easily my favorite of the bunch, it was a cider donut covered with a caramel glaze/frosting with apple pie filling in the middle, it was really soft and fresh and I loved every aspect of it, we got coffee and enjoyed that, the very nice woman who worked there was kind enough to make a fresh batch which was appreciated, we left with some donuts and now that I've tried a little of the four we brought home I'll try to keep my review of each one simple... as I can, the rainbow cookie donut was good, obviously the cookie was good but the donut tasted very much like a rainbow cookie with its jam drizzle and rainbow sprinkles (I'm aware that sprinkles don't go on a rainbow cookie, but it adds the "rainbow" to the donut) and chocolate donut... not the exact same thing but if you were to taste it without the cookie... you'd know where it got its influence from, I wrote Apple fritter in the description of my pics but... this might just be a cinnamon fritter donut type thing... this was actually my second favorite and easily a good combo with coffee, the cranberry tarte donut was unique and a real treat for those that love cranberry sauce (me) and jelly, visually it was very pretty and I could see this being an all year thing with different types of jelly, the glazed was the last I tried and ya know what?... it was so good and I found myself relieved bc places that do all the fun stuff sometimes don't do the good old fashioned stuff that well. I really want to try their blueberry lemon glaze donut... it's not as dressed up as the others but flavor wise it seems like a winner. The people who work here are great, I like the vibes. They also have a little area in the back with a couch where you can sit and good quality stuff in the fridge, Boylan sodas and Kombucha and homemade bread pudding, an amazing way to use day old donuts/buns etc... made me happy to see. I'm pretty sure they serve lattes and stuff like that too and will be sure to check it out next time. I'm very happy to have a place like this is in Port Jeff and think they make it little more fun and less pretentious.
Restaurantji Recommends
Even if your aren't a fan of The Simpsons, how can anyone go wrong with a pink frosted donut with rainbow sprinkles. I was here around 4 pm on a Sunday and the donuts were still super fresh. Wandered in while the rest of my party was shopping at boutique shops near by and only finished half the donut before my cover was blown and pink frosting on my face probably didn't help. Highly recommend for kids both big and small
These donuts are insanely sweet. You have to expect that given the flavor choices, but there just aren’t any moderately sweet options (lemon curds, jams, etc). First thing in the morning and they have no hot coffee... at all. A disappointing experience overall.
Peering into the shop from the front door, the display of donuts looked enticing from afar. Walking in, I was a little disappointed when I saw how much icing and cream was loaded on the majority of the options, they looked positively sugar-laden, more than most donut shops. Seeing this made me a little wary and I should've gone with my gut instinct and left right there. Instead, being very determined to eat a donut, I went with a classic doughnut standard--the powdered jelly donut. And while I don't make a habit of comparing local eateries to chains, this donut was basically on par with my local DD. The dough itself was fluffy but without that slight bounciness of most artisanal donut places (at least the ones in NYC). Additionally the amount of filling in it was really sad--maybe a teaspoon's worth. A jelly donut without jelly is...not a jelly donut! My friend got the Holy Cannoli, but unfortunately no grail found here either. This was more of a frosted cake donut with cannoli filling piped on top. As a cake the texture was ok, moist and fluffy, but as a donut the texture just didn't hold together. After taking the first bite of the donut, the rest of the donut broke apart in my friend's hands. Also the cake + frosting and sweet cream was just really really sweet. This place needs to do some work on their recipes. I did want to add that store itself is very cute and the service was decent, however the donuts that were the main attraction just left a disappointing taste in my mouth.
Great donuts and better prices than North Fork Donuts in Mattituck.
Got donuts here for my birthday and let me tell you , they were AMAZING. The dough itself is just so moist and yummy. The nutella one is my favorite ! Recommend going here for high quality yummy donuts!!