Wow...Words cannot express how disappointed I was in this place. A friend told me to check it out, and I was shocked at the low quality and poor options/selection. No chicken broccoli? No vegetarian pizza? What the hell kind of pizza shop serves 3 measly options and then gives you attitude about it too? Answer: the kind of pizza shop that won't be getting my business ever again. Wasn't impressed with the service or behavior of the people working there either. Not very welcoming or friendly, they just kind of stared impatiently and couldn't be bothered to help. "Whatever you see here that's what we have" muttered the girl behind the counter. Charming. The pizza was as dull as she was too - tasteless, uninspired and ultimately forgettable. I've actually had better pizza at 7/11. The whole experience was about as pleasant. I see a couple of folks who commented how bad the pizza here was and I wish I'd listened to them. And what is the deal with some of the positive reviews - Have they ever had good pizza before in their lives?? NYC and especially Queens have tons of great pizza shops, unfortunately Austin Street Pizza is not one of them. Even Gloria Pizza a couple of blocks away next to the Midway theater manages a better slice, not to mention a friendlier environment to enjoy it. Do yourselves a favor and skip this place, not worth it and it definitely doesn't live up to the hype!
Pablo Ex
Good environment pizza is stupid fire and not greasy at all
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hatton Jack
Got slices for three all were 10/10 and best pizza I’ve had this year so far. I normally don’t love pizza sauce but this was 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Victoria S.
Recently discovered this pizzeria and have been there a few times. I usually order the Margherita slice, which is delicious. The sauce is flavorful, the cheese isn't overpowering, and the crust has just the right amount of crunch to it. Though I wish the space was bigger, that won't affect me from returning to try other pizza varieties.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita, Pesto Margherita
Azary Tamarov
Was great time with family
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jared W.
Today the regular slices of pizza were thicker than normal, we were not a fan. What made this place great was the super thin crust pizza. Hoping it was just a mistake or a new hire and they go back to the thin crispy slices. I'll give it another go in a week or two and report back.
Ser Der
Unusual product for NY, much closer to flatbread than to regular pizza. Rather pleasant and not as greasy. Very nice cheeses.P.S. the truffle slice underdelivered - no truffle taste whatsoever
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Upside Down
Alexandria Atyeo
The pizza here is good, not great. We were excited to try it out as it had good reviews, but we were hoping for more authentic NY style pizza, and while delicious, this didn’t quite hit. Still great pizza, just not what we were hoping for.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Patricia I.
One of my favorite places on Austin Street. We live in Rego Park, where there are no real pizza joints, so go ant try the 2.0 pizza it's delicious Calzones are amazing and the vodka slice is great
Andrew G.
Very good pizza. Had their regular slice today. Had a fresh mozzarella before. Staff is really friendly. Great selection of pizza. Very good
Great pizza and great service. Love to see smiles when I walk into a business. Seems to be family run also. I love the truffle square slice and the cup pepperoni slice with hot honey. But I also think you cant go wrong with the other slices either. Highly recommended. Also great seating inside and you can have wine or beer while dining.
Voki Stankov
Truffle pizza. Nuff said
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
rodney munoz
Great pizza joint. Margarita is the perfect choice here. Enjoy!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Timothy Svagna
Worst Pizza in New York ive ever had! Super dry, and overcooked pizza that had so much flour on it i almost chocked. If i didnt have a bottle of water with me I would have probably chocked and died. So be warned, if you do decide to eat it though, make sure you have a beverage with you, or else you may choke from the dryness. Literally like swallowing sandpaper or cinnamon eating this, not even joking. thought my throat was going to close up or I was having an allergic reaction or soemthing from the dryness. If you dont believe me let the pictures speak for themself. Not only is it dry and possibly deadly , but its over 4$ a slice. On top of that the people working there are as rude and sassy as can be. No matter how hungry you are its not worth buying this. Even if it was free I wouldnt eat it. This pizza is what you give to someone you dont like, and you want them to choke and die. If you have a coworker or family member you hate, then give them this pizza if you want them to have an early death.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Space Dandy
Delicious flavor. Crispy crust and quality toppings. Reasonable prices. No customer bathroom. Cash and credit both accepted. 03/2024
Wow...Words cannot express how disappointed I was in this place. A friend told me to check it out, and I was shocked at the low quality and poor options/selection. No chicken broccoli? No vegetarian pizza? What the hell kind of pizza shop serves 3 measly options and then gives you attitude about it too? Answer: the kind of pizza shop that won't be getting my business ever again. Wasn't impressed with the service or behavior of the people working there either. Not very welcoming or friendly, they just kind of stared impatiently and couldn't be bothered to help. "Whatever you see here that's what we have" muttered the girl behind the counter. Charming. The pizza was as dull as she was too - tasteless, uninspired and ultimately forgettable. I've actually had better pizza at 7/11. The whole experience was about as pleasant. I see a couple of folks who commented how bad the pizza here was and I wish I'd listened to them. And what is the deal with some of the positive reviews - Have they ever had good pizza before in their lives?? NYC and especially Queens have tons of great pizza shops, unfortunately Austin Street Pizza is not one of them. Even Gloria Pizza a couple of blocks away next to the Midway theater manages a better slice, not to mention a friendlier environment to enjoy it. Do yourselves a favor and skip this place, not worth it and it definitely doesn't live up to the hype!
Good environment pizza is stupid fire and not greasy at all
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got slices for three all were 10/10 and best pizza I’ve had this year so far. I normally don’t love pizza sauce but this was 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recently discovered this pizzeria and have been there a few times. I usually order the Margherita slice, which is delicious. The sauce is flavorful, the cheese isn't overpowering, and the crust has just the right amount of crunch to it. Though I wish the space was bigger, that won't affect me from returning to try other pizza varieties.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita, Pesto Margherita
Was great time with family
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Today the regular slices of pizza were thicker than normal, we were not a fan. What made this place great was the super thin crust pizza. Hoping it was just a mistake or a new hire and they go back to the thin crispy slices. I'll give it another go in a week or two and report back.
Unusual product for NY, much closer to flatbread than to regular pizza. Rather pleasant and not as greasy. Very nice cheeses.P.S. the truffle slice underdelivered - no truffle taste whatsoever
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Upside Down
The pizza here is good, not great. We were excited to try it out as it had good reviews, but we were hoping for more authentic NY style pizza, and while delicious, this didn’t quite hit. Still great pizza, just not what we were hoping for.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
One of my favorite places on Austin Street. We live in Rego Park, where there are no real pizza joints, so go ant try the 2.0 pizza it's delicious Calzones are amazing and the vodka slice is great
Very good pizza. Had their regular slice today. Had a fresh mozzarella before. Staff is really friendly. Great selection of pizza. Very good
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza and great service. Love to see smiles when I walk into a business. Seems to be family run also. I love the truffle square slice and the cup pepperoni slice with hot honey. But I also think you cant go wrong with the other slices either. Highly recommended. Also great seating inside and you can have wine or beer while dining.
Truffle pizza. Nuff said
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza joint. Margarita is the perfect choice here. Enjoy!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Worst Pizza in New York ive ever had! Super dry, and overcooked pizza that had so much flour on it i almost chocked. If i didnt have a bottle of water with me I would have probably chocked and died. So be warned, if you do decide to eat it though, make sure you have a beverage with you, or else you may choke from the dryness. Literally like swallowing sandpaper or cinnamon eating this, not even joking. thought my throat was going to close up or I was having an allergic reaction or soemthing from the dryness. If you dont believe me let the pictures speak for themself. Not only is it dry and possibly deadly , but its over 4$ a slice. On top of that the people working there are as rude and sassy as can be. No matter how hungry you are its not worth buying this. Even if it was free I wouldnt eat it. This pizza is what you give to someone you dont like, and you want them to choke and die. If you have a coworker or family member you hate, then give them this pizza if you want them to have an early death.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Delicious flavor. Crispy crust and quality toppings. Reasonable prices. No customer bathroom. Cash and credit both accepted. 03/2024
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Slice