Food was ordinary. Our shepard's pies came out 5 minutes after we ordered them, so I think the dishes sit for a while under a warming lamp. New York is expensive, but our pies consisted of hamburger, gravy, and mashed potatoes squeezed through a tube. They cost $23.00. Pretty expensive for what we got. No prices listed for the draft beers. Server wanted us to order our entrees when we ordered our drinks. We felt rushed. We weren't expecting Michelin dining, but this place was disappointing. There are better options in mid-town.
Paddy
Smashing place. Really like the Sheperd's Pie and my friend had a great burger. Bar is friendly and staff led by Noel are super. Welcome and and warm. Good feed and great selection of beers. Like being in Ireland but in MidTown - special place
frank
This was exactly what we were looking for and Connolly's delivered as usual. We wanted a pub near Grand Central Station and on the way to Radio City Music Hall. We wanted good food and fast service. We made a rez on Open Table and were seated right away in a nice booth. Gina, our server was great and accommodating to get us served quickly. The steak and the shepherds pie were both delicious and the draft beer was nice and cold. This is a terrific place!
Theresa
food good - pub food - good for lunch and hanging out - we were put in the back and service was slow - don't ask for 2nds on you soda - they don't do free refills UGH
Julie
My party of 5 all loved the meals we ordered. The salmon was fresh and cooked to order. The corned beef Ruben looked nice and my friend said it was tasty ...not dry at all. But the best was my order ...bangers and mash! Lately I've found some restaurants serving American breakfast sausage and assuming no one will know it's not Irish sausages. I know! Connolly are above that trickery....their sausages are the real thing! They're delicious and so is the onion, mash and gravy. So is the cider! We had a great night and we were treated very well.
Eileen
Great casual restaurant. Huge quiet dining room. Excellent service. Limited but tasty menu. My “go to” place for lunch in midtown.
Fernando
Service was awesome. Menu was limited and ok. But close to Broadway and the shows so good place for pre show dinner. Drinks are great, too.
John
Ten to twelve of us lunch a few times a year here in the Upstairs Room. We're all Apostles of good food and drink, and Connolly's provides all that plus great service. Can't go wrong here!
Danielle
The food here is great, with lots of options for everyone. Can get very busy before events at Radio City though, so keep that in mind if you are planning to go before an event. The servers worked hard to try to keep up with everyone though.
David
Connolly's never disappoints, great food, cold beer and friendly staff, conveniently located next to Grand Central Station!
It's an energetic, loud fun place to work. Our waitress was friendly, fast and attending to our many requests for a party of 8. Food was great.
Jim
Very good pub food. Great value. The Shepards pie and the corned beef burger were very good
Leslie
Enjoyed my dinner very much, waiter was attentive and food was good. I was there early in a weekday and the afternoon work crowd started to come in as I was finishing. Great place to catch a drink and some good food near Grand Central.
Kenneth
The bar was a fun place, but not necessarily a sports bar that we were hoping for. Nothing against them at all I just had unmet expectations. Guinness was fabulous, of course.
Andrew
Lunch is easy and reliable at Connolly's. Service is excellent and food is solid. One of the only really good places to sit down and get a good lunch without breaking the bank in the Grand Central area.
Food was ordinary. Our shepard's pies came out 5 minutes after we ordered them, so I think the dishes sit for a while under a warming lamp. New York is expensive, but our pies consisted of hamburger, gravy, and mashed potatoes squeezed through a tube. They cost $23.00. Pretty expensive for what we got. No prices listed for the draft beers. Server wanted us to order our entrees when we ordered our drinks. We felt rushed. We weren't expecting Michelin dining, but this place was disappointing. There are better options in mid-town.
Smashing place. Really like the Sheperd's Pie and my friend had a great burger. Bar is friendly and staff led by Noel are super. Welcome and and warm. Good feed and great selection of beers. Like being in Ireland but in MidTown - special place
This was exactly what we were looking for and Connolly's delivered as usual. We wanted a pub near Grand Central Station and on the way to Radio City Music Hall. We wanted good food and fast service. We made a rez on Open Table and were seated right away in a nice booth. Gina, our server was great and accommodating to get us served quickly. The steak and the shepherds pie were both delicious and the draft beer was nice and cold. This is a terrific place!
food good - pub food - good for lunch and hanging out - we were put in the back and service was slow - don't ask for 2nds on you soda - they don't do free refills UGH
My party of 5 all loved the meals we ordered. The salmon was fresh and cooked to order. The corned beef Ruben looked nice and my friend said it was tasty ...not dry at all. But the best was my order ...bangers and mash! Lately I've found some restaurants serving American breakfast sausage and assuming no one will know it's not Irish sausages. I know! Connolly are above that trickery....their sausages are the real thing! They're delicious and so is the onion, mash and gravy. So is the cider! We had a great night and we were treated very well.
Great casual restaurant. Huge quiet dining room. Excellent service. Limited but tasty menu. My “go to” place for lunch in midtown.
Service was awesome. Menu was limited and ok. But close to Broadway and the shows so good place for pre show dinner. Drinks are great, too.
Ten to twelve of us lunch a few times a year here in the Upstairs Room. We're all Apostles of good food and drink, and Connolly's provides all that plus great service. Can't go wrong here!
The food here is great, with lots of options for everyone. Can get very busy before events at Radio City though, so keep that in mind if you are planning to go before an event. The servers worked hard to try to keep up with everyone though.
Connolly's never disappoints, great food, cold beer and friendly staff, conveniently located next to Grand Central Station!
Restaurantji Recommends
It's an energetic, loud fun place to work. Our waitress was friendly, fast and attending to our many requests for a party of 8. Food was great.
Very good pub food. Great value. The Shepards pie and the corned beef burger were very good
Enjoyed my dinner very much, waiter was attentive and food was good. I was there early in a weekday and the afternoon work crowd started to come in as I was finishing. Great place to catch a drink and some good food near Grand Central.
The bar was a fun place, but not necessarily a sports bar that we were hoping for. Nothing against them at all I just had unmet expectations. Guinness was fabulous, of course.
Lunch is easy and reliable at Connolly's. Service is excellent and food is solid. One of the only really good places to sit down and get a good lunch without breaking the bank in the Grand Central area.
Loading...