Good food and service. Generous portions. Very accommodating with offering gluten free options. Server was attentive and friendly.Dietary restrictions: Offered Gluten free: steak, fries (we were the first to order on this day), shrimp cocktail, chocolate mouse
Brian Ginett
Great food, I haven't been here since before the pandemic. The food and service are still very good.
April Rooney
Went there for dinner last night. Walked in and there was a handful of people in the bar area but no one in the dining room. Wait about 5 minutes for someone to come out of the back to seat is. Service was great at first but as soon as we got our food our server never came back. About 15 minutes after we stopped eating our server finally came back. This is after I watched her go into the bar area 7 times. During that time another couple came in and sat themselves because they were not greated by anyone. I also asked a to go container for my food and she took my plate and then walked back with it to ask again if I wanted to take it with me. Never came back to see if we wanted more drinks or even offer is dessert. I would understand if they dinning room was full but there were 2 tables and 2 servers. Will not be returning for awhile.
Marianne Camponeschi-Ogren
Casey's has always been known for their great food. I've been going there for YEARS. However, I don't know what happened from when I was last there in early May (when the food was fantastic) until June, but I can tell you the food was horrible. The fish fry was so dry and overcooked that it didn't even bend when you held it up. The Reuben wasn't even edible. It tasted like pure salt. The appetizers were equally a disappointing. Won't be returning unless things change drastically.
Joan Sheridan
What a great neighborhood tavern! Welcoming staff, super lunch menu, & fresh, well-prepared foods! Can't wait to enjoy dinner there again soon!
David Wilson
The staff was warm, friendly, attentive and accurate. The food was nothing short of outstanding. Can't wait to return! I had the special, "Chicken Dijon".
Albert Pagano
Appetizers were very good - calamari, spinach/ricotta wontons, pork belly sliders. Main courses were hit or miss. Hazelnut chicken was dry and overcooked. Chicken riggies was okay but nothing special. Our server was polite and attentive. Not as a good under the new ownership.
Joe V
Plentiful parking, relaxing atmosphere, attentive and pleasant waitstaff. Warm bread and fresh salads preceded our delicious entrees. Our first dining experience at Casey’s was a 10 out of 10.
Chuckster4
We've visited Casey's several times since their reopening and have been super satisfied with the service and meals! We've always been there with friends so have sampled many different appetizers and entrees and everyone has been pleased! It's always nice to see the owner "supervising" the operations and chatting with his customers. We will be back!!
Jenn K
We had friends who we wanted to treat for dinner. We decided to give the newly owned Caseys a try. We really wanted to have a great experience, but Caseys couldn't deliver. We ordered drinks and then one shared appetizer. The appetizer, calamari, came out and it was good, only problem was that our drinks came 5 min after. Then we put in our orders for food. The orders came out before we even finished our salads. Of the 4 dishes, 3 were less than palatable. The chicken was turning and had a bad taste and there was no lemon flavor, we had to ask for lemons, which the server never brought-we went to the bar. Next, the eggplant rolatini had green onions as garnish, not basil, and had no flavor. The paata was hard, as if they just warmed it up, the 3rd dish was chicken parm and it was over fried and couldn't be cut. We mentioned all of this to the server and she said the manager will look at the bill. We expected that at least one meal was takn off, but they gave us 10% first responder discount. Needless to say, we won't be going back again. The manager never came out to personally apologize or offer to remake our food. $170 later, i was still hungry and extremely disappointed.
This restaurant/bar is historic. There has been a restaurant in that building for over 100 years. It combines white table cloth dinning on one side of the establishment with a traditional bar on the other. The people were nice (both customers and staff). The food was very good. The menu is bigger than you would guess. This is not a line cook place...there is a chef at the helm, who is skilled. I was impressed. I would go back in a heartbeat.
Jossette Vargas Eduarte
It is my first time here, and this place is AMAZING. We ordered for Sambuca ravioli, Thai chicken wings, fried eggplant rigatoni, Philly pasta with chicken, and spicy chicken sandwiches for supper. My new fave is the fried eggplant rigatoni. Overall, each plate was excellent, and taste so good, they all arrived simultaneously and hot. Definitely will return and give more a try.
Jenna Manning
Was very disappointed in the service. We had a 6:30 reservation and did not receive our entrees until 8:30 meanwhile other tables who arrived after us received theirs. We didn't receive one of the appetizers that we ordered. The waitress didn't seem too concerned about our table at all. Most of the time she was among the missing and we had to ask waitresses from other sections for drink refills and our bill. The food was great, but I cant seem to understand what took so long. We didnt even receive an apology for the wait.
Larry Keenan
Stopped for quick lunch, ate at the bar. Friendly, quick service. Burger was very good, cooked to order, hot fries. Ice cold draft beer.
Raelene Pitt
First time getting dinner here i got it go home but when you walk in the smell alone is delicious the food was amazing favorite thing was the crab stuffing and the wings were delicious they even have fried oreos just didn't get a picture but I will definitely visit again only thing I'd complain about is my steak did have alot of fat on it
Good food and service. Generous portions. Very accommodating with offering gluten free options. Server was attentive and friendly.Dietary restrictions: Offered Gluten free: steak, fries (we were the first to order on this day), shrimp cocktail, chocolate mouse
Great food, I haven't been here since before the pandemic. The food and service are still very good.
Went there for dinner last night. Walked in and there was a handful of people in the bar area but no one in the dining room. Wait about 5 minutes for someone to come out of the back to seat is. Service was great at first but as soon as we got our food our server never came back. About 15 minutes after we stopped eating our server finally came back. This is after I watched her go into the bar area 7 times. During that time another couple came in and sat themselves because they were not greated by anyone. I also asked a to go container for my food and she took my plate and then walked back with it to ask again if I wanted to take it with me. Never came back to see if we wanted more drinks or even offer is dessert. I would understand if they dinning room was full but there were 2 tables and 2 servers. Will not be returning for awhile.
Casey's has always been known for their great food. I've been going there for YEARS. However, I don't know what happened from when I was last there in early May (when the food was fantastic) until June, but I can tell you the food was horrible. The fish fry was so dry and overcooked that it didn't even bend when you held it up. The Reuben wasn't even edible. It tasted like pure salt. The appetizers were equally a disappointing. Won't be returning unless things change drastically.
What a great neighborhood tavern! Welcoming staff, super lunch menu, & fresh, well-prepared foods! Can't wait to enjoy dinner there again soon!
The staff was warm, friendly, attentive and accurate. The food was nothing short of outstanding. Can't wait to return! I had the special, "Chicken Dijon".
Appetizers were very good - calamari, spinach/ricotta wontons, pork belly sliders. Main courses were hit or miss. Hazelnut chicken was dry and overcooked. Chicken riggies was okay but nothing special. Our server was polite and attentive. Not as a good under the new ownership.
Plentiful parking, relaxing atmosphere, attentive and pleasant waitstaff. Warm bread and fresh salads preceded our delicious entrees. Our first dining experience at Casey’s was a 10 out of 10.
We've visited Casey's several times since their reopening and have been super satisfied with the service and meals! We've always been there with friends so have sampled many different appetizers and entrees and everyone has been pleased! It's always nice to see the owner "supervising" the operations and chatting with his customers. We will be back!!
We had friends who we wanted to treat for dinner. We decided to give the newly owned Caseys a try. We really wanted to have a great experience, but Caseys couldn't deliver. We ordered drinks and then one shared appetizer. The appetizer, calamari, came out and it was good, only problem was that our drinks came 5 min after. Then we put in our orders for food. The orders came out before we even finished our salads. Of the 4 dishes, 3 were less than palatable. The chicken was turning and had a bad taste and there was no lemon flavor, we had to ask for lemons, which the server never brought-we went to the bar. Next, the eggplant rolatini had green onions as garnish, not basil, and had no flavor. The paata was hard, as if they just warmed it up, the 3rd dish was chicken parm and it was over fried and couldn't be cut. We mentioned all of this to the server and she said the manager will look at the bill. We expected that at least one meal was takn off, but they gave us 10% first responder discount. Needless to say, we won't be going back again. The manager never came out to personally apologize or offer to remake our food. $170 later, i was still hungry and extremely disappointed.
Restaurantji Recommends
This restaurant/bar is historic. There has been a restaurant in that building for over 100 years. It combines white table cloth dinning on one side of the establishment with a traditional bar on the other. The people were nice (both customers and staff). The food was very good. The menu is bigger than you would guess. This is not a line cook place...there is a chef at the helm, who is skilled. I was impressed. I would go back in a heartbeat.
It is my first time here, and this place is AMAZING. We ordered for Sambuca ravioli, Thai chicken wings, fried eggplant rigatoni, Philly pasta with chicken, and spicy chicken sandwiches for supper. My new fave is the fried eggplant rigatoni. Overall, each plate was excellent, and taste so good, they all arrived simultaneously and hot. Definitely will return and give more a try.
Was very disappointed in the service. We had a 6:30 reservation and did not receive our entrees until 8:30 meanwhile other tables who arrived after us received theirs. We didn't receive one of the appetizers that we ordered. The waitress didn't seem too concerned about our table at all. Most of the time she was among the missing and we had to ask waitresses from other sections for drink refills and our bill. The food was great, but I cant seem to understand what took so long. We didnt even receive an apology for the wait.
Stopped for quick lunch, ate at the bar. Friendly, quick service. Burger was very good, cooked to order, hot fries. Ice cold draft beer.
First time getting dinner here i got it go home but when you walk in the smell alone is delicious the food was amazing favorite thing was the crab stuffing and the wings were delicious they even have fried oreos just didn't get a picture but I will definitely visit again only thing I'd complain about is my steak did have alot of fat on it