Four Brothers Pizza Inn

3803 NY-9G, Rhinebeck
(845) 876-3131

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Caesar Salad with Chicken Cutlet

Four Brothers Famous Greek Pizza

Garlic Parmesan Wings

Mozzarella Sticks

Chicken Parmesan

Margherita Pizza

Pepperoni Pizza

Chicken Fingers

Pried Calamari

Twister Fries

Photos

+10 photos

+9 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Good pizza and food. I give them 5 starts. The cost / value for the food they put out. I find it consistent and compared to the places we usually go to dinners like “Annarella Ristorante” also 5 stars, they are much lower cost / different category. I also appreciate the old-school feel. This restaurant isn’t trying to be something they are not and I like that about it.

February 2026

I had a great experience here, and a big reason for that was Calvin.

We came in on Friday night, when things are usually busy, and Calvin was absolutely amazing. He was friendly, helpful, and on point from the moment we walked in. Even with the rush, he took the time to make sure everything was right, answered questions without any attitude, and kept things moving smoothly.

You can tell when someone actually cares about doing a good job, and...

December 2025

These guys were amazing. We planned our father’s 80th surprise party here. 40 people. Justina helped the whole way through. Made it very easy going. Service from her and the other gals during was absolutely amazing. Can’t say enough. Food was great. Overall awesome experience the made it a very welcoming 80th for dad. That you all so much!

December 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Rhinebeck, NY

Four Brothers Pizza Inn

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Four Brothers Pizza Inn