I had a great experience at New York Pizzeria! The pizza 🍕 and dessert were delicious!
Paige was a sweetheart and the food is reasonably priced too! 👏 🇺🇸
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph Burditt
Every meal is amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ed M
Fantastic pizza! Plenty of cheese and sauce. Excellent flavor, probably a top 5 on my all time list at 51 years old.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Cook
I'm a delivery driver and I just noticed this place. I was just about to turn into the Stewart's across the street. Boy am I glad I noticed it. I got 2 slices of pepperoni and mushroom and it is one of the best pizzas I've ever had. Pleasant, fast service too and very reasonably priced. I have a new stop every time I'm here. Fantastic! I highly recommend.
But they should consider real chicken and a white garlic base.
Very let down.
Also found it hard to believe they don’t have a buffalo a white or a ricotta slice available for lunch.
Maureen Dresser
Great Pizza erc.
Shayla Goodspeed
After driving 35 minutes to eat at this establishment with my mother, sister in-law, niece and nephew to celebrate mothers day, it was the worst experience I've ever had. As we arrived around 730, we placed our order at the counter which totaled up to about $65.00 and were told it'd be about 20 minutes. The lights above the dinning tables weren't on but another group was seated, so we turned the light on, took a seat and settled the kids. The man that took our order let us know our food was ready. We got the food, sat back down and began to eat. It was then when a woman from the back came out from the counter and started to complain that we were sitting and eating our food. The guy that took our order then came over and said "we're closed!". The hours that were posted online, as well as on both of their doors were that they were open until 9:30pm. At no time while ordering our food, or waiting for our food, or retrieving our food did anyone say that they were closing or that the dinning area was closed. We were obviously upset at the treatment we were being given, and proceeded to gather our things and sat outside at an outdoor picnic table and ate our food. While we were eating, there were 6 different groups of people that were disappointed to find the doors had been locked far before closing time, it was a total of 19 people that were turned away from this establishment. Pretty lousy way to do business in a small town, and very disappointed as I grew up in this area and wouldn't have expected to be treated in this manner especially from a local business.
Art Cloud
Very nice pizzeria in the beautiful metropolis of Richfield Springs, NY--surprisingly good experience--recommended
Not a Bot
Pizza was “okay”. Not the best but also not the worst I’ve ever had. The chicken wings had really great flavor… they could’ve been a little crispier though. The service was great, the woman taking my order over the phone was very nice and the staff were friendly when I showed up to pickup my order.
I had a great experience at New York Pizzeria! The pizza 🍕 and dessert were delicious!
Paige was a sweetheart and the food is reasonably priced too! 👏 🇺🇸
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Every meal is amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fantastic pizza! Plenty of cheese and sauce. Excellent flavor, probably a top 5 on my all time list at 51 years old.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm a delivery driver and I just noticed this place. I was just about to turn into the Stewart's across the street. Boy am I glad I noticed it. I got 2 slices of pepperoni and mushroom and it is one of the best pizzas I've ever had. Pleasant, fast service too and very reasonably priced. I have a new stop every time I'm here. Fantastic! I highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always love their food !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thank you
Get on Door Dash
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good tasting pizza!
One of the best pizzas I've gotten from here.
Cook was able to customize our meal.
Restaurantji Recommends
Worst honey mustard pizza I’ve ever had.
I’m very sorry.
But they should consider real chicken and a white garlic base.
Very let down.
Also found it hard to believe they don’t have a buffalo a white or a ricotta slice available for lunch.
Great Pizza erc.
After driving 35 minutes to eat at this establishment with my mother, sister in-law, niece and nephew to celebrate mothers day, it was the worst experience I've ever had. As we arrived around 730, we placed our order at the counter which totaled up to about $65.00 and were told it'd be about 20 minutes. The lights above the dinning tables weren't on but another group was seated, so we turned the light on, took a seat and settled the kids. The man that took our order let us know our food was ready. We got the food, sat back down and began to eat. It was then when a woman from the back came out from the counter and started to complain that we were sitting and eating our food. The guy that took our order then came over and said "we're closed!". The hours that were posted online, as well as on both of their doors were that they were open until 9:30pm. At no time while ordering our food, or waiting for our food, or retrieving our food did anyone say that they were closing or that the dinning area was closed. We were obviously upset at the treatment we were being given, and proceeded to gather our things and sat outside at an outdoor picnic table and ate our food. While we were eating, there were 6 different groups of people that were disappointed to find the doors had been locked far before closing time, it was a total of 19 people that were turned away from this establishment. Pretty lousy way to do business in a small town, and very disappointed as I grew up in this area and wouldn't have expected to be treated in this manner especially from a local business.
Very nice pizzeria in the beautiful metropolis of Richfield Springs, NY--surprisingly good experience--recommended
Pizza was “okay”. Not the best but also not the worst I’ve ever had. The chicken wings had really great flavor… they could’ve been a little crispier though. The service was great, the woman taking my order over the phone was very nice and the staff were friendly when I showed up to pickup my order.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...