Buttah

377 Onderdonk Ave, Ridgewood
(347) 833-7899

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Chocolate Salted Caramel
Coconut Cream Cupcake
Peanut Butter Cookie
8 Tres Leches Cake
Red Velvet Cupcake
Blackout Cupcake
Sprinkle Cookie
8 Funfetti Cake

Featured items
Sticky Toffee Pudding (1 pc)
Traditional British dessert made with dates and soaked in a buttery brown sugar toffee sauce.
Corn Brûlée Bread Pudding (1 slice)
Honey custard with a brûléed top.
Not Hot Chocolate Cupcake (1 pc)
Indulge in the rich warmth of our hot chocolate cupcake – a luscious chocolate chiffon cupcake filled and topped with velvety chocolate pudding. As the finishing touch, enjoy the delightful contrast of torched marshmallow that add a perfectly toasted sweetness! (contains: soy) SERVINGS: 1 cupcake.
Double Chocolate Glazed Bundt Cake (1 sl)
Rich chocolate bundt cake slice glazed with chocolate ganache.
Cinnamon Sugar Muffin (1 pc)
Cinnamon muffin coated in cinnamon sugar.
Corn Muffin (1 pc)
Corn muffin with a honey buttah glaze.
Gluten-Free Banana Bread (1 sl)
Classic banana bread made without wheat flour.

Main Menu
Corn Brûlée Bread Pudding (1 slice)
Honey custard with a brûléed top.
Red Velvet Cupcake (1 pc)
Buttermilk cake enhanced with a dash of cocoa finished with cream cheese frosting rimmed with ground pecans. Contains nuts.
Double Chocolate Glazed Bundt Cake (1 sl)
Rich chocolate bundt cake slice glazed with chocolate ganache.
Raspberry Buttah Swirl Cookie (1 pc)
2 vanilla buttah swirl cookies sandwiched between thick raspberry jam. 1 cookie.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Cookie (1 pc)
Crisp Buttahery cookie loaded with Callebaut chocolate chunks.
Cinnamon Sugar Muffin (1 pc)
Cinnamon muffin coated in cinnamon sugar.
Corn Muffin (1 pc)
Corn muffin with a honey buttah glaze.
Birthday Cake Cookie (1 pc)
2 vanilla butter cookies coated in fun rainbow sprinkles sandwiched between American buttercream.
Par-Tay! Cupcake (vanilla cake/chocolate buttercream)
vanilla cake frosted with whipped chocolate buttercream. 1 cupcake.
Fluffernutter Cookie (1 pc)
Peanut butter cookies sandwiched between homemade marshmallow cream.
Oreoey Cookie (1 pc)
Two dark chocolate cookies sandwiched between vanilla American buttercream.
Sprinkle Cookie (1 pc)
Vanilla Buttah cookie coated in fun rainbow sprinkles.
PB and J Cookie (1 pc)
2 peanut buttah cookies sandwiched between thick strawberry jam. Contains nuts.
Gluten-Free Banana Bread (1 sl)
Classic banana bread made without wheat flour.
Black Sesame Tahini Cookie (1 pc)
Creamy tahini cookie speckled with black sesame seeds.
Chocolate Dipped Coconut Macaroon - gluten-free (1 pc)
A rich coconut treat baked until golden and dipped in dark chocolate. 1 macaroon.
Chocolate Coconut Bundt (vegan)
Individual mini bundt chocolate coconut cake topped with a luscious coconut milk glaze + coconut flakes!
Not Hot Chocolate Cupcake (1 pc)
Indulge in the rich warmth of our hot chocolate cupcake – a luscious chocolate chiffon cupcake filled and topped with velvety chocolate pudding. As the finishing touch, enjoy the delightful contrast of torched marshmallow that add a perfectly toasted sweetness! (contains: soy) SERVINGS: 1 cupcake.
Sticky Toffee Pudding (1 pc)
Traditional British dessert made with dates and soaked in a buttery brown sugar toffee sauce.
Ginger Molasses Cookie (1 pc)
Crisp spiced cookie! 1 cookie.
Walnut Snowball Cookie (1 pc)
Buttahery walnut shortbread cookies! (contains: nuts)
Sausage Stuffing Square (1 slice)
Savory Italian pork sausage with tons of aromatic vegetables packed into the perfect square. 1 square slice.
Chocolate Hazelnut Cookie
Double chocolate cookie with chopped hazlenuts. (contains: soy, nuts) SERVINGS: 1 cookie

Beverages
Iced Coffee

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+75 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+74 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I ordered a Coquito Cake for my co workers birthday and it was made with care and honestly so delicious. Ordered online smooth easy transaction. Ready at the time indicated. Very flavorful cake. We have been to many bakeries and this cake was a 20/10. You can taste the difference from other bakeries. One of my coworkers highly recommended Buttah Bakery. She has eaten many different treats always very fresh she states.

The staff was friendly & efficient.

If...
January 2026
Everything is made with care, and honestly, everything is just delicious—You can taste the difference in every bite.
The staff is friendly and makes you feel at home, and the atmosphere is perfect for a quick treat or a relaxed coffee break.
If you haven’t been yet, it’s definitely worth a visit. buttah Bakery is one of those places you’ll want to come back to again and again.
September 2025
Beautiful people doing beautiful things.
The best cupcakes in all New York. The flavor and the butter…. Its 10/10!
Lovely people working there and i felt like home.
September 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Onderdonk Cafe - 353 Onderdonk Ave
Coffee Shops, Cafe, Coffee
G&D Deli & Grocery Inc. - 402 Onderdonk Ave
Grocery, Imported Food
Daddy’s Bar - 4-64 Onderdonk Ave
Cocktail Bar

Buttah

377 Onderdonk Ave, Ridgewood, NY 11385
(347) 833-7899