So I order there today the pizza is very soggy, crust is not crispy, the sauce was bland, the owner thinks it's quality pizza when it's worse then any dollar slice but he charges $3+ for a slice. He wears a dirty shirt that looks like it has NOT been washed since pre Covid and it would be ok but then he is also very rude and argumentative. Will not eat from here again. Unless you like bad experiences and bad soggy pizza that bland avoid this place
Mika
Food was goodBelly fullWill return
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elizabeth Torres
Horrible and moldy pizza never again. Display food even has
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Rafael Lugo
The abomination of Myrtle ave time and time again disappointed in simple task
Nicholas Perez
Poor ingredients. I thought I had covid cause I couldn't taste anything.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Potato Jones
The best pizza around
Samantha Hernandez
I don't know how this got 3.4 stars ! Amazing pizza! Hot and fresh so good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J M Goodwin
Amazing slice went back for more!
Ismael S.
United Xtreme Martial Arts has been a customer of The Original Sal's Pizza for several years. Today we purchased 7 large pies and when a parent went to ask for plates, the owner said, we should go to the 99 cents store and buy plates. Then a senior staff member goes to the pizzeria and tries to speak with the owner, the owner tells him to get the FUXK out of here, after the senior staff asked for paper plates since we purchased 7 large pies.
Great classic NY slice, rest is noise, this ain't Per Se lol
Food: 5
Jose S.
Been in and out of here for the last 28 years I have been in the neighborhood, always jumping in for a slice when walking down Myrtle Ave. - never had a bad slice - unsure they offer delivery (last time I asked years ago it was no) but this is great place to get good slice, tasty, perfectly cooked- crispy but chewy, tasty sauce, lots of cheese. Need a quick bite good place to get a slice if near by.
Yarissa Abreu Espinal
NEVER AGAIN! Lady was wearing no gloves, put sliced pepperoni on my slices. Meanwhile husband is making a new pie and sprinkling cheese on it with no gloves. Lady charges me (Touching Money) then grabs an old rag and comes around cleaning the counter glass, still no gloves. She then goes and takes out my pizza and bags it. If I could give them no stars, I would! Nasty place!!
Keyvan Taveras
They touch money and food without washing hands or wearing gloves … nasty
So I order there today the pizza is very soggy, crust is not crispy, the sauce was bland, the owner thinks it's quality pizza when it's worse then any dollar slice but he charges $3+ for a slice. He wears a dirty shirt that looks like it has NOT been washed since pre Covid and it would be ok but then he is also very rude and argumentative. Will not eat from here again. Unless you like bad experiences and bad soggy pizza that bland avoid this place
Food was goodBelly fullWill return
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Horrible and moldy pizza never again. Display food even has
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The abomination of Myrtle ave time and time again disappointed in simple task
Poor ingredients. I thought I had covid cause I couldn't taste anything.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
The best pizza around
I don't know how this got 3.4 stars ! Amazing pizza! Hot and fresh so good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing slice went back for more!
United Xtreme Martial Arts has been a customer of The Original Sal's Pizza for several years. Today we purchased 7 large pies and when a parent went to ask for plates, the owner said, we should go to the 99 cents store and buy plates. Then a senior staff member goes to the pizzeria and tries to speak with the owner, the owner tells him to get the FUXK out of here, after the senior staff asked for paper plates since we purchased 7 large pies.
Food ok pizza ok sicilian not
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Great classic NY slice, rest is noise, this ain't Per Se lol
Food: 5
Been in and out of here for the last 28 years I have been in the neighborhood, always jumping in for a slice when walking down Myrtle Ave. - never had a bad slice - unsure they offer delivery (last time I asked years ago it was no) but this is great place to get good slice, tasty, perfectly cooked- crispy but chewy, tasty sauce, lots of cheese. Need a quick bite good place to get a slice if near by.
NEVER AGAIN! Lady was wearing no gloves, put sliced pepperoni on my slices. Meanwhile husband is making a new pie and sprinkling cheese on it with no gloves. Lady charges me (Touching Money) then grabs an old rag and comes around cleaning the counter glass, still no gloves. She then goes and takes out my pizza and bags it. If I could give them no stars, I would! Nasty place!!
They touch money and food without washing hands or wearing gloves … nasty
The Sicilian was great thank u