Barrila's Pastaria Restaurant & Bar + Catering Services & Event Venue
300 E Main St, Riverhead
(631) 726-4444
Customers' Favorites
Assorted Meatballs in Sauce
Spinach and Cheese Ravioli
La Pastaria Risotto Fungi
Vitello Milanese Panini
Bucatini Amatriciana
Caprese Salad Small
Shrimp Francaise
Spinach Ravioli
Appetizers
Meatballls
Party Deposit
Party Room Rent
Our beautiful private party room is perfect for any occasion including business or celebratory luncheons, dinners and events. The cocktail lounge leads to the dining room for up to 60 guests. There is also coat check and pristine restrooms.
Antipasto
LA PASTARIA Bucatini Amatriciana
signature fresh pasta with guanciale bacon, tomatoes, red pepper flakes. Served with house bread
Mozzarella In Carozza With Salad
Bruschetta Duo / Mushroom & Tomato (Lunch)
Local Mussels (Lunch)
Fritto Misto (Lunch)
Gnocco Fritto
Trio di Polpette
Local Mussels (Dinner)
Crostone di Robiola
Bruschetta Duo / Mushroom and Tomato (Dinner)
Frito Misto (Dinner)
Antipasto Misto di Verdure (Large)
Antipasto Misto di Verdure (Small)
Salads
Giardiniera Salad (Large)
Giardiniera Salad (Small)
Caprese Salad (Large)
Caprese Salad (Small)
Caesar Salad (Large)
Caesar Salad (Small)
Entrees
Salumi Board (Lunch)
Zuppa Di Pesce (Large)
Zuppa Di Pesce (Small)
Salumi Board (Dinner)
Pastaria
Signature Fresh Pasta + Chefs Special
Caesar Salad + Pasta Tasting + Dessert
Frutti di Mare Alla Fra Diavolo
Fettuccini Mare Monte
Lobster Ravioli
Linguine Vongole
Casarecci Ghiotta
Penne Pesto
Fettuccini Bolognese
Lo Spaghetto al Pomodoro
Gnocchi Gorgonzola
Bucatini Amatriciana
Fresh Pasta
Spaghetti (1 Pound)
Papardelle (1 Pound)
Squid Ink Linguine (1 Pound)
Lasagna (1 Pound)
Proscuitto & Parmesan (1 Pound)
Spinach & Goat Cheese (1 Pound)
Eggplant & Ricotta Salata (1 Pound)
Gnocchi (1 Pound)
Casarecci Squid Ink (1 Pound)
Fresh Signature Sauces
Vodka (1 Pint)
Quattro Formaggi (1 Pint)
Puttanesca (1 Pint)
Pomodoro (1 pint)
Pesto (1 pint )
Ghiotta (1 Pint)
Costola Breve (1 Pint)
Bolognese (1 Quart)
Arrabiata (1 Quart)
Amatriciana (1 Quart)
Macellaio
Tagliata Di Manzo
Costola Di Vitello
Insatiable Burgers
Flounder Milanese
Seafood
Shrimp Mare Chiaro
Shrimp Francaise
Roasted Salmon
Coda Rospo al Limone
Flounder Oreganata
Braciole di Pesce Spada
Italian Paninis
Verdure
Di Tonno
Melazane
Petto Di Pollo Alla Griglia
Caprese
Desserts
Nutella Panini
Frutti Di Bosco
Deconstructed Italiano Cannoli
Pizza
Capricciosa Pizza
Calabrese Pizza
Margherita Verace Pizza
Classic Margherita Pizza
Beverages
Tea
Iced Decaf Coffee
Iced Coffee
Pineapple Juice
Grapefruit Juice
Orange Juice
Cranberry Juice
Apple Juice
Lemonade
Iced Tea
Ginger Ale
Sprite
Diet Coke
Coke
Club Soda
Pitcher Soda
Panna Still Water
Pellegrino
Red Bull
Red Wine
Cabernet Suavignon 246 Reserve
Specialty Cocktails
$5 Bottled Beers
$5 Bottled Beers Only In House Tuesdays Only
$8 Margarita Monday Special
$8 House Only Margarita
Specials
Lobster Roll
Brunch
Bucatini Amatriciana
Giardiniera Salad (Small)
Market
'A Mista Carta Napoletana 500g
'E Ziti Luong 500g
Online Take-Out Menu
Corn Beef & Cabbage Dinner
Celebrate St. Patricks' Days with chef Barrila's masterful take on this traditional Irish dish! Served with healthy portion of succulent corn beef, braised cabbage and carrots
Vegan Vegetarian Dish Of Day
Mediterranean Couscous with Roasted Seasonal Vegetables
DOLCE Tiramisu
Layers of esprsso drenched lady fingers separated by mascarpone cream and dusted with cocoa powder
DOLCE Profiteroles
Italian cream puff pastry balls filled with vanilla cream and coated in chocolate
DOLCE Frutti Di Bosco
Creamed filled pastry with sponge cake and seasonal berries
DOLCE Deconstructed Cannoli
crispy pastry shells with fresh ricotta cream, Sicilian style
SEAFOOD Cacciucco Soup
Fisherman's soup with local fish and shellfish in a deliseaous seafood broth
SEAFOOD Shrimp Mare Chiaro
Sauteed shrimp over spinach with white wine tomato sauce
SEAFOOD Roasted Salmon
Atlantic filet with champagne mustard sauce. Served with vegetable of the day
SEAFOOD Braciole Di Pesce Spada
Grilled swordfish with fresh herbs crispy bread crumbs. Served with side vegetable of hte day
TAGLIATA DI MANZO
Prime steak with borolo wine reduction. Served with rosemary roasted potatoes and vegetables of the day
OSSOBUCCO MILANESE
Braised veal shank over signature saffron risotto, parmesan cheese
COSTOLA DI VITELLO
Veal chop valdostana / bone in veal chop with prosciutto di parma, mozzarella, spinach. Served with garlic roasted mashed potatoes
Pollo Parmigiana
Chicken breast covered with pomodoro sauce and fresh mozzarella cheese. Served with rosemary roasted potatoes
DINNER Pollo Milanese
Cripsy chicken breast cutlet with arugula and cherry tomatoes. Served with rosemary roasted potatoes
DINNER Pollo Marsala
Chicken breast smothered with sauteed mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce. Served with rosemary roasted potatoes and vegetables
DINNER IL Macellaio Pollo Francaise
Chicken with lemon beurre blanc sauce. Served with rosemary potaotes and vegetables
CALZONE Tradizionale
Calzone with ham and cheese
ROSTICCERIA Mini Pizzette
Individual mini pizza with basil tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella
ROSTICERRIA Mozzarella in Carozza Bianca
Crispy bread filled with fresh mozzarella cheese (Appetizer)
ROSTICERRIA Arancini Bianco
Crispy risotto balls filled bechamel, prosciutto cotto
ROSTICERRIA Arancini Messinesi
Crispy risotto balls filled with meat ragu
PIZZA RIPIENA IL Venetian
Focaccia filled sandwich with porchetta, gorgonzola, pistachio cream
PIZZA RIPIENA IL Toscano
Focaccia filled sandwich with prosciutto Toscano, mozzarella, tomato, basil pesto
PIZZA RIPIENA IL Siciliano
Focaccia filled sandwich with mortadella, stracciatella, pistachio cream
PIZZA RIPIENA IL SARDINIAN
Focaccia filled sandwich with spicy eggplant and zucchini, sundried tomatoes, gorgonzola, arugula
PIZZA RIPIENA IL Napoleano
Focaccia filled sandwich with fresh handmade mozzarella, tomato and basil
PIZZA RIPIENA IL Laziate
Focaccia filled sandwich with porchetta, roasted pepper cream, grilled vegetables, arugula
PIZZA RIPIENA IL Romano
Focaccia filled sandwich with salami, pecorino cream, artichoke cream spicy eggplant
PIZZA RIPIENA IL Parmagiano
Focaccia filled sandwich with parma prosciutto, parmesan Toscano, truffle cream, arugula
PIZZA RIPIENA IL Lombardino
Focaccia filled sandwich with prosciutto cotto, mozzsarella, truffle cream, spicy eggplant
PIZZA RIPIENAIL Calabrese
Focaccia filled sandwich with Italian cured meats of capoccola, stracchino, truffle cream, arugula
PIZZA RIPIENA
Focaccia filled sandwich with pistachio cream, stacchino, truffle cream, arugla.
PIZZA RIPIENA Il Americano
Focaccia filled sandwich with roast beef, onion porcini cream, tomato, arugula
PIZZA ALLA PALA Tartufina Bianca (Full Pala)
Authentic Sicilian style pizza with buffalo ricotta, fresh mozzarella, marscarpone, shaved truffles (equivalent to eight slices)
PIZZA ALLA PALA Capricciosa
Authentic Sicilian style pizza with fresh mozzarella, artichokes, mushrooms, black olives, ham and basil (equivalent to eight slices)
PIZZA ALLA PALA Calabrese (Full Pala)
Authentic Sicilian style pizza with fresh mozzarella, spicy salami, fresh basil (equivalent to eight slices)
PIZZA ALLA PALA Classica (Full Pala)
Authentic Sicilian style pizza classic style with San Marzano pomodoro sauce and melted mozzarella cheese (equivalent of eight slices)
PIZZA ALLA PALA 1/2 PALA (TARTUFINA BIANCA)
Four slices of authentic Sicilian style pizza with buffalo ricotta, fresh mozzarella, shaved truffles
PIZZA ALLA PALA Capricciosa (1/2 Pala)
Four slices of authentic Sicilian style pizza with fresh mozzarella, artichokes, mushrooms, black olives, ham and basil (equivalent to four slices)
PIZZA ALLA PALA Calabrese (1/2 Pala)
Four Slices of authentic Sicilian style pizza with fresh mozzarella, spicy salami, fresh basil (equivalent to four slices)
PIZZA ALLA PALA
Authentic Sicilian style pizza classic style with San Marzano pomodoro sauce and melted mozzarella cheese (equivalent to four slices)
PIZZA ALLA PALA
Authentic Sicilian style pizza with buffalo ricotta, fresh mozzarella, mascarpone, shaved truffles (equivalent to two slices)
PIZZA ALLA PALA - SLICE Capricciosa
Authentic Sicilian style pizza with fresh mozzarella, artichokes, mushrooms, black olives, ham and basil (equivalent to two slices)
PIZZA ALLA PALA - SLICE Calabrese
Authentic Sicilian style pizza with fresh mozzarella, spicy salami, fresh basil (equivalent to two slices)
PIZZA ALLA PALA - SLICE Margherita Verace
Authentic Sicilian style pizza classic style with house made bufalo mozzarella and fresh basil (equivalent to two slices)
PIZZA ALLA PALA - SLICE - Classica
Authentic Sicilian style pizza classic style with San Marzano pomodoro sauce and melted mozzarella cheese
INSATIABLE BURGERS Baby Bella Melt
Signature roasted portobello mushroom burger with sauteed mushrooms, bell peppers and melted mozzarella cheese. Served with house fries
INSATIABLE BURGERS Flounder Fritto
Signature crispy white flounder fish filet burger with lettuce, tomato, tartare sauce. Served with house fries
INSATIABLE BURGERS
Signature burger with angus beef, caramelized onions, lettuce and tomato. Served with house fries
ITALIAN PANINIS Verdure
Warm Italian sandwich with roasted seasonal vegetables. Served with side
ITALIAN PANINIS Vitello
Warm Italian sandwich with crispy veal cutlet, arugula, shaved parmesan cheese, balsamic drizzle. Served with side
ITALIAN PANINIS Bistecca
Warm Italian sandwich with prime steak filet, fresh mozzarealla, tomato. Served with side
ITALIAN PANINS Pollo
Warm Italian sandwich with crispy chicken cutlet, arugula, shaved parmesan cheese and balsamic drizzle. Served with side
ITALIAN PANINIS Petto di Pollo
Warm Italian sandwich with grilled chicken, sauteed mushroms, fresh mozzarella cheese. Served with side
ITALIAN PANINIS Di Tonno
Warm Italian sandwich with Italian cured tuna, black olives, red onions, cucumbers. Served with side
ITALIAN PANINIS Melanzane
Warm Italian sandwich with roasted eggplant, fresh mozzarella and tomatoes. Served with side
ITALIAN PANINIS Caprese
Warm Italian sandwich with heirloom tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil spread. Served with side of day
MAIN DISH Vegan Vegetarian of Day
Mediterranean Couscous served with variety of roasted seasonal vegetables
LA PASTARIA
Signature lasagna with short rib meat ragu, mozzarella and ricotta. Served with house bread
LA PASTARIA Gnocci Gorgonzola
Handmade potato dumplings with gorgonzola sauce and topped with toasted walnuts. Served with house bread
LA PASTARIA Risotto Fungi
creamy Italian vialone nano rice with sauteed mushrooms and parmesan cheese. Served with house bread
LA PASTARIA Lobster Ravioli
Signature handmade ravioli filled with fresh poached lobster filling, cacacha sauce. Served with house bread
LA PASTARIA Papardelle Costola Breve Ragu
Signature fresh pasta with braised short ribs in tomato based ragu. Served with house bread
LA PASTARIA Frutti Di Mare Alla Fra Diavolo
Signature fresh pasta with local clams, garlic and white wine sauce. Served with house bread
LA PASTARIA Casarecci Ghiotta
Signature fresh pasta with swordfish, tomatoes, capers, onions, green olives, raisins. Served with house bread
LA PASTARIA Fettucine Mare Monte
signature fresh pasta with sauteed mushrooms and shrimp, garlic and olive oil. Served with house bread
LA PASTARIA Penne Pesto
Signature fresh pasta with basil sauce (pine nuts) and parmesan chees. Served with house bread
LA PASTARIA Pansotti Alla Norma
Signature fresh pasta of triangular ravioli filled with eggplant and ricotta and topped with eggplant tomato sauce. Served with house bread
LA PASTARIA Paccheri Broccoli & Salsiccia
Signature fresh pasta with broccoli, Italian sausage, garlic and oil. Served with house bread
LA PASTARIA Fettucini Bolognese
Signature fresh pasta with a traditional meat ragu. Served with house bread
LA PASTARIA Spinach Agnolotti with Pomodoro Sauce
Signature fresh ravioli pasta filled with spinach and ricotta with cream of basil pomodoro sauce. Served with house bread
LA PASTARIA Agnolotti Spinach Ravioli
Signature fresh ravioli pasta filled with spinach and ricotta with cream of wild mushroom sauce. Served with house bread
LA PASTARIA Lo Spaghetto Al Pomodoro
signature fresh pasta with san marzano tomato sauce, fresh basil. Served with house bread.
LA PASTARIA Bucatini Amatriciana
signature fresh pasta with guanciale bacon, tomatoes, red pepper flakes. Served with house bread
INSALATE Giardiniera
mixed greens, seasonal vegetables / aged balsamic vinaigrette.
INSALATE Caprese
heirloom tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and basil
INSALATE Caesar
romaine lettuce, house croutons, shaved parmesan cheese, fresh anchovy dressing.
INSALATE Roasted Beets
Roasted beets, red onions, goat cheese puff, raspberry vinaigrette.
ANTIPASTO Polpette (Signature Meatballs)
Signature all beef Italian meatballs with pomodoro sauce. Served with crostino Toscano
ANTIPASTO Salumi Board
Selection of specialty salumi (Italian cured meats) such as prosciutto di parma, mortadella, capicola and eggplant caponata (for la famiglia) Add cheese $11
ANTIPASTO Local Mussels
local mussels in a broth of red (tomato based), white (fresh herbs, white wine) or fra diavolo (spicy tomato). served with Italian crostini
ANTIPASTO Mozzarella in Carozza
Crispy crusted bread with melted mozzarella cheese and side of pomodoro sauce
ANTIPASTO Gnocco Fritto
fried hollow dough donuts served with buffalo ricotta and side of pomodoro sauce
Antipasto Fritto Misto
fried calamari, shrimp and zucchini with side of basil aioli
Antipasto Prosciutto Con Mozzarella
Aged prosciutto di parma, fresh handmade mozzarella, arugula salad and crostini
Antipasto Affettati Misti
Imported Italian cured meats and gourmet cheese plate. Served with handmade breadsticks
A Special Easter Menu
Columba Classica
Italian Easter Cake
Dolce - Pannetone Zabliogne (Half Tray)
Holiday Italian Dessert Bread / Berry Custard Sauce
Dolce - Pannetone Zabliogne (Individual)
Imported Dessert Bread / Berry Custard Sauce
Pizza Rustica (Whole Pie / Feeds 6-8)
Traditional Deep Dish Easter Italian Quiche Style Oie With Cured Imported Salame
Pizza Rustica (Individual)
Traditional Deep Dish Easter Italian Quiche Style Pie With Cured Imported Salame
Pasta - Fettucine Bolognese (Half Tray)
Fresh Pasta With Lamb Ragout / Parmesan Cheese
Pasta - Fettucine Bolognese (Individual)
Fresh Pasta With Lamb Ragout / Fresh Parmesan Cheese
Chicken Roulade Half Tray
Chicken Breast Flled With Spinach And Fontina Cheese + Fingerling Potatoes + Roasted Portobello Mushrooms
Main Dish - Chicken Roulade (Individual)
Chicken Breast Filled With Spinach And Fontina Cheese + Fingerling Potatoes + Roasted Portobello Mushrooms
Main Dish - Leg Of Lamb (Half Tray)
Herb Roasted Leg Of Lamb + Mediterranean Grains + Braised Carrots
Main Dish - Leg Of Lamb ( Individual)
Herb Roasted Leg Of Lamb + Mediterranean Grains + Braised Carrots
Cobb Salad - Half Tray
Poached Chicken, Bacon, Hardboiled Eggs, Cheese / House Vinaigrette
Cobb Salad - Individual
Poached Chicken, Bacon, Hardboiled Egg, Cheese / House Vinaigrette
App - Minestrone Soup By The Quart + House Bread
Seasonal Vegetable Sioup, San Marzano Tomato Broth ( Serves 2-3)
Minestrone Soup + House Bread
Seasonal Vegetable Soup, San Marzano Tomato Broth (By The Pint)
Photos
+9 photos
+8 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
First time visiting this place, very cozy, good service, delicious food, I really liked it, very clean and spacious place to enjoy with family or with your partner. I recommend it. thank you
December 2024
Would definitely recommend for a nice handmade pasta meal. They were able to accommodate dietary restrictions (vegan and vegetarian) and still had a wonderful tasting pasta. We also had half plates of zucchini fries which was huge, and a half plate of baked clams, which came with 6 clams.
August 2024
Refreshing to find a great Sicilian restaurant in Riverhead beautiful open space on Main St
Great service, and delicious food fresh pasta and meatballs or the steak pizzaiola you will really enjoy it
Great service, and delicious food fresh pasta and meatballs or the steak pizzaiola you will really enjoy it
August 2024
You May Also Like
Shampaige Island Cuisine - 307 E Main St
![]()
Caribbean
Cliff's Rendezvous - 313 E Main St
![]()
Steak House, American, Burgers
Antigua Cafe Restaurant Bar - 309 E Main St
![]()
Bakery, Cafe, Juice Bar & Smoothies