One of my favorite Italian restaurants in Rochester. It's stood the test of time, so that has to mean something.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve Bagnato (nissanlord)
Agatina's is a fantastic restaurant. We've there many times. Never had bad service or a bad meal. The food is great. This last time I got the chicken parmesano. It was one of if not the best one ever. A lot of cheese, sauce and pasta on the side. Couldn't be better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie
The staff is really nice and they are paying attention to the guests. Food was good too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Rachael Jones
My first time dining here, and I can see why my family raves about it! Got a very late reservation due to our procrastination, but the service was still friendly and attentive. My friend ordered the shrimp fra Diavlo in red, which the kitchen will make to your heat specification (it also comes in a white version for those that prefer. I ordered the eggplant parm with angel hair. Both came with soup or salad (though I forgot to grab a picture of them). House made Italian dressing for him, seafood bisque for me (for a small upcharge, totally worth it! ). Both were delicious! Fresh, warm, bread offered throughout the meal. Portions were huge! Mine enough for 2 more meals at home. I'm sad we didn't leave enough room for dessert, but certainly will the next time! Everything was great, and it made an otherwise blah Thursday night turn out wonderful! Thanks so much for your hospitality and delicious food...I'll definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karyn Rando
Our family has used Agatina’s for the past two years on Christmas Eve for catering our friends and family party. Rave reviews for all of the food! We chose the homemade meatballs (there were 20 and because they are so large we cut them in half and they were perfect for all of our guests!), chicken french bites, gnocchi, bacon wrapped scallops, chicken pastina soup, calamari, and rolls. Since the restaurant wasn’t open on December 24, we picked up the food cold on the 23rd and the restaurant provided reheating instructions for each dish. Food came out wonderful and our guests loved the selection!
Food: 5
Michelle Coval
Monday 12/22 called at 4:30 to place a pickup order for 6:30 was told to call back at 6….called back at 5:45 and was told they were not taking anymore to go orders! I told them I was told to call back at this time they said oh well…. Not a good way to business during the Holiday season…. Bella Pasta was more than Happy to help my family out with our annual Christmas dinner
Julie Pfenninger
Our server was ok! She definitely forgot about us, but the food is worth it!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
ja bet
Every time I come here I have an excellent meal. Hard to beat for authentic Italian cuisine. Beans and greens are delicious! The wait staff is highly trained and extremely accommodating. Highly recommend this restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carmen Rivera
We waited almost 45 minutes to be seated. The server was unsociable and a bit unconcerned when my grandson found a long hair in his food, she said oh sorry do you want to take the rest home or order another one? She walked away without taking the hair or the plate off our table Grose! were speechless. I will never dine here again!
The Christmas decorations were beautiful and we had a very nice table for our party of 3. Unfortunately, the waitress must have had a bad night as once our food arrived, we didn't see her or another server until the hostess offered us boxes to wrap up leftovers. The stuffed haddock was excellent but my friend's ziti was way over cooked and she could not stomach it. My other friend had eggplant parm and it was a huge portion, but it was cool and after a couple bites was too cold to enjoy. We asked to hostess to let the waitress know we had some issues. When the waitress came by, she just had excuses but no apology. The manager came by and apologized but again was not helpful. They removed the cost of the dinner as well as the drink that never came. We noticed 2 other tables near us of the 4 tables the waitress had ask for quicker food service and the other for the bill when the waitress finished with us. We probably will not return to Agatina's. The interaction with the staff really ruined the evening.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
Kris Schulz
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Hands down the best Italian food we’ve ever had and most memorable meal in quite sometime.
We recently ordered takeout for four and were blown away. Not only was everything incredible, but the portions were unbelievable — easily 10 meals worth of food. We actually looked forward to eating the leftovers, which says a lot!
This is the first time we’ve tried this restaurant, even though we live close by, and our only regret is not discovering it sooner. This will absolutely be a new staple for us, and we already plan to use them for gatherings with friends and family.
What we loved:
Gnocchi – melt-in-your-mouth perfection
Fettuccine Alfredo – creamy, rich, and exactly what Alfredo should be. Bliss and my favorite!
Penne with sauce – perfect balance of flavor
Meatballs – the best I’ve ever had, topped with delicious creamy ricotta cheese sauce
Chicken French with greens – tender, flavorful, and beautifully prepared
Salad – the dressing alone is worth mentioning
Cannoli – the perfect sweet finish
If you’re looking for delicious Italian food with incredible value, look no further. We can’t wait to order again!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terry Herne
Family get together. Fantastic
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Suzanne Fava
The appetizers were delicious and every single entree for all 21 of us was just the right temperature. The taste of the sauce was exquisite and my veal Parmesan was cooked to perfection.
$31 in the menu but $46 in my check
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
One of my favorite Italian restaurants in Rochester. It's stood the test of time, so that has to mean something.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Agatina's is a fantastic restaurant. We've there many times. Never had bad service or a bad meal. The food is great. This last time I got the chicken parmesano. It was one of if not the best one ever. A lot of cheese, sauce and pasta on the side. Couldn't be better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The staff is really nice and they are paying attention to the guests. Food was good too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
My first time dining here, and I can see why my family raves about it! Got a very late reservation due to our procrastination, but the service was still friendly and attentive. My friend ordered the shrimp fra Diavlo in red, which the kitchen will make to your heat specification (it also comes in a white version for those that prefer. I ordered the eggplant parm with angel hair. Both came with soup or salad (though I forgot to grab a picture of them). House made Italian dressing for him, seafood bisque for me (for a small upcharge, totally worth it! ). Both were delicious! Fresh, warm, bread offered throughout the meal. Portions were huge! Mine enough for 2 more meals at home. I'm sad we didn't leave enough room for dessert, but certainly will the next time! Everything was great, and it made an otherwise blah Thursday night turn out wonderful! Thanks so much for your hospitality and delicious food...I'll definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our family has used Agatina’s for the past two years on Christmas Eve for catering our friends and family party. Rave reviews for all of the food! We chose the homemade meatballs (there were 20 and because they are so large we cut them in half and they were perfect for all of our guests!), chicken french bites, gnocchi, bacon wrapped scallops, chicken pastina soup, calamari, and rolls. Since the restaurant wasn’t open on December 24, we picked up the food cold on the 23rd and the restaurant provided reheating instructions for each dish. Food came out wonderful and our guests loved the selection!
Food: 5
Monday 12/22 called at 4:30 to place a pickup order for 6:30 was told to call back at 6….called back at 5:45 and was told they were not taking anymore to go orders!
I told them I was told to call back at this time they said oh well…. Not a good way to business during the Holiday season….
Bella Pasta was more than Happy to help my family out with our annual Christmas dinner
Our server was ok!
She definitely forgot about us, but the food is worth it!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Every time I come here I have an excellent meal. Hard to beat for authentic Italian cuisine. Beans and greens are delicious!
The wait staff is highly trained and extremely accommodating. Highly recommend this restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We waited almost 45 minutes to be seated. The server was unsociable and a bit unconcerned when my grandson found a long hair in his food, she said oh sorry do you want to take the rest home or order another one? She walked away without taking the hair or the plate off our table Grose! were speechless. I will never dine here again!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
The Christmas decorations were beautiful and we had a very nice table for our party of 3. Unfortunately, the waitress must have had a bad night as once our food arrived, we didn't see her or another server until the hostess offered us boxes to wrap up leftovers. The stuffed haddock was excellent but my friend's ziti was way over cooked and she could not stomach it. My other friend had eggplant parm and it was a huge portion, but it was cool and after a couple bites was too cold to enjoy. We asked to hostess to let the waitress know we had some issues. When the waitress came by, she just had excuses but no apology. The manager came by and apologized but again was not helpful. They removed the cost of the dinner as well as the drink that never came. We noticed 2 other tables near us of the 4 tables the waitress had ask for quicker food service and the other for the bill when the waitress finished with us.
We probably will not return to Agatina's. The interaction with the staff really ruined the evening.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Hands down the best Italian food we’ve ever had and most memorable meal in quite sometime.
We recently ordered takeout for four and were blown away. Not only was everything incredible, but the portions were unbelievable — easily 10 meals worth of food. We actually looked forward to eating the leftovers, which says a lot!
This is the first time we’ve tried this restaurant, even though we live close by, and our only regret is not discovering it sooner. This will absolutely be a new staple for us, and we already plan to use them for gatherings with friends and family.
What we loved:
Gnocchi – melt-in-your-mouth perfection
Fettuccine Alfredo – creamy, rich, and exactly what Alfredo should be. Bliss and my favorite!
Penne with sauce – perfect balance of flavor
Meatballs – the best I’ve ever had, topped with delicious creamy ricotta cheese sauce
Chicken French with greens – tender, flavorful, and beautifully prepared
Salad – the dressing alone is worth mentioning
Cannoli – the perfect sweet finish
If you’re looking for delicious Italian food with incredible value, look no further. We can’t wait to order again!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Family get together. Fantastic
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The appetizers were delicious and every single entree for all 21 of us was just the right temperature. The taste of the sauce was exquisite and my veal Parmesan was cooked to perfection.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got charged double tip
Service: 4
Loading...