All Star Pizza - Penfield NY

Good thin style crust, much better than most others in the area that claim to be NYC style.

Always great stuff.
They have actual old school delivery guys on staff, which saves you a ton from DD/GH so order from them direct if possible.

Thin and Traditional are our go to crusts.
Enjoy!

The pizza is always 10/10 ! I love that they offer a dairy free cheese. They always seem happy and are patient on the phone even when it’s slammed. It’s become our Friday night pizza and movie staple! Always looking forward to it!

I understand that everything is going up in price….. but there is no excuse for what I received. I ordered 2 separate orders of chicken fingers and added French fries to both, fried dough and mozz stix. I wish I could post the pics of what I received. The chicken fingers were processed chicken, I paid extra for French fries and had maybe 7 French fries in each container. I requested a side of celery and paid extra for that. I got 4 pieces of celery. The fried dough was cold and hard and the mozz sticks were over cooked. I paid $57.00 for this order and it took almost an hour to receive it when I live just over a mile away from the pizza shop. This is the first and last time I will order anything from here.

Good parking, great pizza, friendly staff,small but very clean.

Hey now, you're an all star, get some pizza, eat it 😋. The pizza here is bussing with a capital b for busses. They make a good pie, pizza pie that is. The pizzas usually have cheese and sauce and crust. I would recommend any pizza here that has those ingredients. The paper bag it comes in is also fun. Yesterday my 180 lb German shepherd stuck is fat face in it and ran around the house like a fancy chicken. This place makes a meannn pizza folks. Give them a visit, or else...

Ordered a veggie, thin crust. Very wet and soggy. Very disappointed for what I paid for it.

I was craving a sub for lunch and I’ve been in search of the old school submarine sandwich that I remember having growing up. I’ve only been able to find it once recently, and that was about 2 hours out side of town. Although, the ham and cheese sub I had at All Star Pizza wasn’t 100% of what I am searching for, it was absolutely delicious. I walked in and ordered, sat at the counter to wait, which was only a few minutes. The employees were really friendly, and the atmosphere was clean. I recommend checking them out if you’re in the area.

Absolutely delicious! Reasonable prices.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza

This place is hopping which is always a good sign. Love the thin crust! Had the California White veggie tonight and it was great. Chicken Fingers were hot, juicy and delicious. Smaller waiting area, but the food is good and that’s really all that matters. The young man working register gets the job done. We'll be back.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: All Star White Pizza

Service was fast and the delivery driver was friendly but the calzone (just cheese- mozzarella and ricotta) is just okay

Food: 3

Service: 5

Good pizza at reasonable prices. Boneless wings were good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ny style thin crust and crispy pizza that tastes great.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

If like a thinner crust pizza with incredibly good flavor, All Star Pizza is a great pizza shop to go to. Prices are very fair and the food is consistently great!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza

Better pizza places in the area, crust was chewy, it was like cardboard, I was not impressed, flavor was minimal. I will not be returning.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2