The best pizza/calzones! and they have vegan options! I notice that negative reviews here seem to have some things in common, and that's a) they're 2+ years old, and b) a lot of people seem confused about crust. All-Star is under new ownership, so those old bad reviews aren't accurate. This pizza is so delicious, with plenty of veggies to choose from (and meats too for folks who like that) and the best part is: they have vegan cheese as an option!! And they're going to have vegan pepperoni from GrassFed here shortly! As for the confusion with the crust, just be sure you know how you want your crust and request whatever thickness you prefer. (also, they do have gf crust as an option as well) P.S. this is definitely more of a pick up or delivery kinda place, very small seating area. But I highly recommend All-Star to anyone!Vegetarian options: vegan cheese, lots of veggies to choose from, and they're about to start carrying vegan pepperoni from GrassFed here shortly!Dietary restrictions: vegan (dairy free) cheese, vegan pepperoni available soon, and gluten free crust available
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lydia M.
Pizza was okay. I really liked the thin crust, but I felt like the pizza itself didn't have a lot of taste. My family got a basic pizza with half broccoli and half pepperoni. The inside is really just a storefront...there are a few seats along an eating bar, but it's Def a takeout place. Id try the pizza again, but would try their white sauce one because it has really good reviews. I know they do have slices too!
Nick Bakolas
Great pizza and service. Food is always delicious and service is top notch.
Ordered pizza for NYE and picked it up. Pizza and wings were GREAT. very nice ppl and food was very tasty . Will be back for sure !!
Jessica Bradway
Delicious pizza! I love the thin crust. It's not so thin as to make the pizza soggy. Not at all! And the amount of toppings is just right! They don't skimp. Their wings are delicious as well. Nice and plump. Crispy on the outside. All the sauces are tasty! The garlic ones are the best! Very friendly staff. Fast delivery when we don't have time to pick-up. There's no seating in the place, it's just a little hole in the wall, those places are often the best as is the case with these guys. I get their salads too and they're very good. Lots of meats/toppings. And the lettuce isn't wilted by the heat of the pizza. The only thing u don't like is their onions. I'm a huge onion fan but I don't get theirs anymore. They're always a little off/strange tasting. But it's no great loss! Bc everything they make is delicious! I recommend this place to all my friends/family.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Rich Mesa
I love that their wings are not over sauced!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Tim Ostrander
For me to leave a review online, the food has to be phenomenal. I ordered from All Star through DoorDash for the first time and got their medium wings and a large country sweet pizza. I was blown away from the first bite. Absolutely the best authentic NY thin crust pizza in Rochester!
The pizza is great! But not the best area to sit down. Classic grab a slice and go!Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free and vegan cheese so can accommodate most restrictions.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Large, Subs, Wings
Lydia Chociej
Finally! A great place to get some great pizza! The sauce is perfect, the crust is tasty and you can tell the cheese is good quality. Will absolutely be coming back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Punky Starwood
This lil shop is awesome is small, but the staff is friendly. My pizza was awesome. I love white pizza and this one was amazing. I love that they add ricotta. Mouth watering and heavenly! I'll be back for more 10/10Parking: It's in a small plaza, but free parking and I've never had issues parking.
This is a little hole-in-the-wall place for good NY style thin crust pizza. I went in for a slice - had a well-flavored vegetarian piece that was nicely done.Quick service, good prices, lots of parking, in and out, all made this an ideal spot when I am in Penfield and need a snack or a quick lunch.Traffic getting out can be a bit challenging if you're turning left.Just sayin'.Vegetarian options: I had a vegetarian slice. Artichoke, tomato, feta. It was quite tasty.Parking: Lots of spots directly in front of the entrance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt Johnson
Good pizza, decent prices. Price board was out of date, but that's how you know its good pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marc Hoffman
This pizza is fantastic. It's just the right amount of thickness, great sauce and cheese, and proper toppings. I will definitely be getting it again!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
jr s
Best pizza in rochester and yes this is a real review from a real
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large, Wings
Deanna Gordon
Little gem I wish I found 2 years sooner! Great pizza and wings
The best pizza/calzones! and they have vegan options! I notice that negative reviews here seem to have some things in common, and that's a) they're 2+ years old, and b) a lot of people seem confused about crust. All-Star is under new ownership, so those old bad reviews aren't accurate. This pizza is so delicious, with plenty of veggies to choose from (and meats too for folks who like that) and the best part is: they have vegan cheese as an option!! And they're going to have vegan pepperoni from GrassFed here shortly! As for the confusion with the crust, just be sure you know how you want your crust and request whatever thickness you prefer. (also, they do have gf crust as an option as well) P.S. this is definitely more of a pick up or delivery kinda place, very small seating area. But I highly recommend All-Star to anyone!Vegetarian options: vegan cheese, lots of veggies to choose from, and they're about to start carrying vegan pepperoni from GrassFed here shortly!Dietary restrictions: vegan (dairy free) cheese, vegan pepperoni available soon, and gluten free crust available
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was okay. I really liked the thin crust, but I felt like the pizza itself didn't have a lot of taste. My family got a basic pizza with half broccoli and half pepperoni. The inside is really just a storefront...there are a few seats along an eating bar, but it's Def a takeout place. Id try the pizza again, but would try their white sauce one because it has really good reviews. I know they do have slices too!
Great pizza and service. Food is always delicious and service is top notch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza, Wings
Ordered pizza for NYE and picked it up. Pizza and wings were GREAT. very nice ppl and food was very tasty . Will be back for sure !!
Delicious pizza! I love the thin crust. It's not so thin as to make the pizza soggy. Not at all! And the amount of toppings is just right! They don't skimp. Their wings are delicious as well. Nice and plump. Crispy on the outside. All the sauces are tasty! The garlic ones are the best! Very friendly staff. Fast delivery when we don't have time to pick-up. There's no seating in the place, it's just a little hole in the wall, those places are often the best as is the case with these guys. I get their salads too and they're very good. Lots of meats/toppings. And the lettuce isn't wilted by the heat of the pizza. The only thing u don't like is their onions. I'm a huge onion fan but I don't get theirs anymore. They're always a little off/strange tasting. But it's no great loss! Bc everything they make is delicious! I recommend this place to all my friends/family.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
I love that their wings are not over sauced!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
For me to leave a review online, the food has to be phenomenal. I ordered from All Star through DoorDash for the first time and got their medium wings and a large country sweet pizza. I was blown away from the first bite. Absolutely the best authentic NY thin crust pizza in Rochester!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large, Wings, Chicken Wing Pizza
The pizza is great! But not the best area to sit down. Classic grab a slice and go!Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free and vegan cheese so can accommodate most restrictions.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Large, Subs, Wings
Finally! A great place to get some great pizza! The sauce is perfect, the crust is tasty and you can tell the cheese is good quality. Will absolutely be coming back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This lil shop is awesome is small, but the staff is friendly. My pizza was awesome. I love white pizza and this one was amazing. I love that they add ricotta. Mouth watering and heavenly! I'll be back for more 10/10Parking: It's in a small plaza, but free parking and I've never had issues parking.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This is a little hole-in-the-wall place for good NY style thin crust pizza. I went in for a slice - had a well-flavored vegetarian piece that was nicely done.Quick service, good prices, lots of parking, in and out, all made this an ideal spot when I am in Penfield and need a snack or a quick lunch.Traffic getting out can be a bit challenging if you're turning left.Just sayin'.Vegetarian options: I had a vegetarian slice. Artichoke, tomato, feta. It was quite tasty.Parking: Lots of spots directly in front of the entrance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizza, decent prices. Price board was out of date, but that's how you know its good pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This pizza is fantastic. It's just the right amount of thickness, great sauce and cheese, and proper toppings. I will definitely be getting it again!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in rochester and yes this is a real review from a real
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large, Wings
Little gem I wish I found 2 years sooner! Great pizza and wings
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza, Subs, Wings