Driving around drunk in a company van at 4 am almost t bone a plow truck nearly blowing through a red light and then tailgating cars and blowing red lights down browncroft sure represents the business quite well. Get your house in order before I post the dash camera footage all over social media.
Lincoln DeCoursey
Their oven delivers a consistently nice crust. Traditional Rochester style. Jumbo wings were also excellent.
Amy schumaker
Got a sheet pizza for my guys at work...1st time they have had this pizza and its their FAVORITE now. Guess this will be my GO TO spot for the guys! Great job and thank you!
Ro Ru
They are THE BEST. They treat customers like family. Every employee here is super kind. The food is delicious and the prices are super fair. I can always trust in the Bay & Goodman Pizza team to deliver promptly and treat me with utter respect. Other places (that shall not be named… but rhyme with Terrys Tizza and Hinos Pizza) will either refuse to deliver to me or come up with an excuse to not deliver to me. Since covid hit some places are being weird. But never Bay & Goodman. They’ve always had my back when it comes to my favorite food: Pizza!
Gregory “Irish” Rolland
Best pizza I’ve had in years. Friendly staff and clean shop. Don’t forget to try a cookie
Christopher White
Food taste good but cost too much
Clarice Ryan
By far my favorite place to eat pizza Cheesesteak garlic knots in Rochester
Mark S. Crysel
Came all the way from Wayne county to pick up two pizzas . Wasn’t disappointed. Still the best. No one makes a better “ deluxe” pizza.
Tara DiMartino
Clean but the pizza changed. It doesn't taste as good as it used to be.
Emily Rivera
I was pleasantly surprised when the meal was served at my table. It's the first time I come here to try this plate. I found it so pretty that I took a picture of it! It was as delicious as it looked! I'm going to tell my oldest son about it, and bring my husband! The service was great!
Got two slices of pizza.The guy serving it was pleasent and handsome.very professional and polite. The music was great in the background. The pizza slices were as big as the paper plates with nice Ozzy delicious cheese. Filled me up quick. I will be comming back with friends ?
Frank Barttlett
The pizza was greasy and undercooked, the person cashing us out was rude and very inpatient. I did some research and the owner is a stand out socialist, bordering on communist. Keep your ideals in the closet and your pizza in the oven Larry.
jk k
Ordered a pizza and wings on Friday. I knew we should have hung up and ordered from somewhere else when we were asked to repeat out order. Ordered pepperoni, onions and green peppers. Got there and received a green and red pepper, extra cheese and onion. No pepperoni. The wings we ordered were tiny. The one flat we got (one out of five) didn't have any meat on it. Also the pie was cold. I walked in right on time to pick up the pizza. It was a terrible experience.
Lindsay R
Pizza was soggy and wings weren’t great. The pizza box was literally wet on the bottom and we had to put the leftover pizza on a cookie sheet on top of napkins in the fridge to try and soak up some moisture. The medium wing sauce was flavorless and extra oily, seemed to only be made of oil & no actual sauce. Last part is a personal preference but out of 10 wings only two were actual wings, the rest were drumsticks which I don’t enjoy as much... you’d just think there’d be some actual wings in there. Probably won’t reorder from this place again, nothing was good.
Joseph Blank
I took a chance and ordered plates just to try something different. Was very pleasantly surprised! Just really good!
Driving around drunk in a company van at 4 am almost t bone a plow truck nearly blowing through a red light and then tailgating cars and blowing red lights down browncroft sure represents the business quite well. Get your house in order before I post the dash camera footage all over social media.
Their oven delivers a consistently nice crust. Traditional Rochester style. Jumbo wings were also excellent.
Got a sheet pizza for my guys at work...1st time they have had this pizza and its their FAVORITE now. Guess this will be my GO TO spot for the guys! Great job and thank you!
They are THE BEST. They treat customers like family. Every employee here is super kind. The food is delicious and the prices are super fair. I can always trust in the Bay & Goodman Pizza team to deliver promptly and treat me with utter respect. Other places (that shall not be named… but rhyme with Terrys Tizza and Hinos Pizza) will either refuse to deliver to me or come up with an excuse to not deliver to me. Since covid hit some places are being weird. But never Bay & Goodman. They’ve always had my back when it comes to my favorite food: Pizza!
Best pizza I’ve had in years. Friendly staff and clean shop. Don’t forget to try a cookie
Food taste good but cost too much
By far my favorite place to eat pizza Cheesesteak garlic knots in Rochester
Came all the way from Wayne county to pick up two pizzas . Wasn’t disappointed. Still the best. No one makes a better “ deluxe” pizza.
Clean but the pizza changed. It doesn't taste as good as it used to be.
I was pleasantly surprised when the meal was served at my table. It's the first time I come here to try this plate. I found it so pretty that I took a picture of it! It was as delicious as it looked! I'm going to tell my oldest son about it, and bring my husband! The service was great!
Restaurantji Recommends
Got two slices of pizza.The guy serving it was pleasent and handsome.very professional and polite. The music was great in the background. The pizza slices were as big as the paper plates with nice Ozzy delicious cheese. Filled me up quick. I will be comming back with friends ?
The pizza was greasy and undercooked, the person cashing us out was rude and very inpatient. I did some research and the owner is a stand out socialist, bordering on communist. Keep your ideals in the closet and your pizza in the oven Larry.
Ordered a pizza and wings on Friday. I knew we should have hung up and ordered from somewhere else when we were asked to repeat out order. Ordered pepperoni, onions and green peppers. Got there and received a green and red pepper, extra cheese and onion. No pepperoni. The wings we ordered were tiny. The one flat we got (one out of five) didn't have any meat on it. Also the pie was cold. I walked in right on time to pick up the pizza. It was a terrible experience.
Pizza was soggy and wings weren’t great. The pizza box was literally wet on the bottom and we had to put the leftover pizza on a cookie sheet on top of napkins in the fridge to try and soak up some moisture. The medium wing sauce was flavorless and extra oily, seemed to only be made of oil & no actual sauce. Last part is a personal preference but out of 10 wings only two were actual wings, the rest were drumsticks which I don’t enjoy as much... you’d just think there’d be some actual wings in there. Probably won’t reorder from this place again, nothing was good.
I took a chance and ordered plates just to try something different. Was very pleasantly surprised! Just really good!
Loading...