Captain Jim's Fish Market
2329 E Main St, Rochester
(585) 482-3640
Menu
Photos
+47 photos
+46 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Fish fry is EXCELLENT.... one of very best ever have had. Been wanting to try for long time, finally did & very glad we did. Beer batter is a lite, crispy crust & fish flaky just excellent. Know now why voted one of top best fish fry in Rochester.
Very disappointed. Maybe because it was so busy on a Friday? Had to wait in line to pick up phone order. Asked for names of everyone in line, then rang up people behind me first! Food was not hot when opened at home, so had to microwave. Fries were soft/underdone, coleslaw & macaroni were bland. Fish had good flavor and onion rings were good.
You May Also Like
JJ's Pub - 669 Winton Rd N
![]()
Bar, Pubs, Karaoke, Whiskey Bar, Pet Friendly
The Silver Iguana - 663 Winton Rd N
![]()
Tacos, Bar, Vegan
Tryon City Tavern - 2300 E Main St
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Beer Bar, Vegetarian
First, the good, and I mean really good!
I ordered the fried oyster dinner with fries, and coleslaw. The oysters were large, plump, and like the fries, perfectly done to a crispy golden brown. I also appreciated that the fries were not pre seasoned, and the coleslaw was creamy without being overly dressed.
The food was perfect, freshly ready right on time, and very importantly for take out, not sitting...