This is a tiny walk in walk out spot on North Winton. We ordered a pizza and 10 wings. It took about 25 minutes. We got the "Classic" which had cheese, onions, green peppers, mushrooms and pepperoni and sausage. It was actually pretty good and the wings also good I should have asked him to fry them hard but that's ok. We got hot and they were tasty enough. I guess this is a franchise operation so. It's decent pizza and the guy behind the counter was cool. It's more of a 3.5/5 Street parking or they have parking behind the building.
Zhiyue Gigi Chen
The pizza was really good! But for $21.99 the deep dish is pretty small, I’m a skinny girl and I can pretty much eat this whole thing without being full:(( probably won’t come back because of the price
One of the best pizza places in the area and by far the one with the best deep dish. Consistently solid food every time we order and have never been disappointed in anything we've tried (ever gotten breadsticks from somewhere and been sad they weren't good? you don't have to worry about that here!) Staff is always friendly and always busting their butts to get orders out fast. Just wish we lived closer so I could order more often!Parking: Parking is just off the street and near the back of the building. heads up that the lighting is pretty bad here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deep Dish, Garlic Bread, Sin Stix
Dan Zambito
Mid pizza.. plenty of other spots in Rochester who serve pizza with their heart and soul into it.Parking: 9-10 spots in the back behind the building. 2 entrances, one on Winton and one on Humboldt.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Mary Fasano
after ordering through grub hub for the first time I was extremely disappointed in the pizza. it had arrived cold that was really no big deal however after attempting to eat the pizza, long black hairs were in the toppings and inside the dough. completely unacceptable. I contacted the store only to be told they couldn't do anything and to contact grubhub. no were sorry, no omg let me get a manager nothing. just an oh well contact grubhub. unfortunately I will never order again nor recommend.
Jimmy Rodriguez
Love the Chicago Deep Dish!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt Goetz
Captain Tony’s is great pizza. I’ve never been disappointed with their calzones or wings either, they were always gas. The pizza is much more consistent than that bonehead Perri and his Pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anna Bartucca
I was craving pizza and this hit the spot! They give you a really big slice (basically 2 slices) and it had an amazing crunch with every bite. I’ve been wanting to try captain Tony’s for a few years and I’m glad I finally did!!
Food: 5
hayley burley
Best pizza in Rochester!!! My favorite for over 15 years!
This pizza was FANTASTIC. Exactly as I remember from the 70's!!! I will definitely be back!! ??
Food: 5
Martha Hanfland
Okay this place has the BEST calzones!!! Sauce on the side yum! Hands down best calzone delivery is always in a.timely manner!Love Captain Tony's! Have ordered calzones from them for 20 plus years!!!
Nina K.
Great pizza! Delicious plain sauce - great crust, really good flavor overall and arrived hot!
A Rose Shop
For sure right now, my favorite ? pizza place. ?that sauce, the crust. ? yummy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Mark L.
Ordered a extra large pepperoni pizza last night. Pizza was under cooked. Toppings were minimal and the pepperoni was flavorless. Still looking for a descent pizza in Rochester. Ordered a extra large pepperoni pizza last night. Pizza was under cooked. Toppings were minimal and the pepperoni was flavorless. Still looking for a descent pizza in Rochester.
This is a tiny walk in walk out spot on North Winton. We ordered a pizza and 10 wings. It took about 25 minutes. We got the "Classic" which had cheese, onions, green peppers, mushrooms and pepperoni and sausage. It was actually pretty good and the wings also good I should have asked him to fry them hard but that's ok. We got hot and they were tasty enough. I guess this is a franchise operation so. It's decent pizza and the guy behind the counter was cool. It's more of a 3.5/5 Street parking or they have parking behind the building.
The pizza was really good! But for $21.99 the deep dish is pretty small, I’m a skinny girl and I can pretty much eat this whole thing without being full:(( probably won’t come back because of the price
Pizza?is always
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Captain Tony's Pizza, Captain's Classic
One of the best pizza places in the area and by far the one with the best deep dish. Consistently solid food every time we order and have never been disappointed in anything we've tried (ever gotten breadsticks from somewhere and been sad they weren't good? you don't have to worry about that here!) Staff is always friendly and always busting their butts to get orders out fast. Just wish we lived closer so I could order more often!Parking: Parking is just off the street and near the back of the building. heads up that the lighting is pretty bad here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deep Dish, Garlic Bread, Sin Stix
Mid pizza.. plenty of other spots in Rochester who serve pizza with their heart and soul into it.Parking: 9-10 spots in the back behind the building. 2 entrances, one on Winton and one on Humboldt.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
after ordering through grub hub for the first time I was extremely disappointed in the pizza. it had arrived cold that was really no big deal however after attempting to eat the pizza, long black hairs were in the toppings and inside the dough. completely unacceptable. I contacted the store only to be told they couldn't do anything and to contact grubhub. no were sorry, no omg let me get a manager nothing. just an oh well contact grubhub. unfortunately I will never order again nor recommend.
Love the Chicago Deep Dish!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Captain Tony’s is great pizza. I’ve never been disappointed with their calzones or wings either, they were always gas. The pizza is much more consistent than that bonehead Perri and his Pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was craving pizza and this hit the spot! They give you a really big slice (basically 2 slices) and it had an amazing crunch with every bite. I’ve been wanting to try captain Tony’s for a few years and I’m glad I finally did!!
Food: 5
Best pizza in Rochester!!! My favorite for over 15 years!
Restaurantji Recommends
This pizza was FANTASTIC. Exactly as I remember from the 70's!!! I will definitely be back!! ??
Food: 5
Okay this place has the BEST calzones!!! Sauce on the side yum! Hands down best calzone delivery is always in a.timely manner!Love Captain Tony's! Have ordered calzones from them for 20 plus years!!!
Great pizza! Delicious plain sauce - great crust, really good flavor overall and arrived hot!
For sure right now, my favorite ? pizza place. ?that sauce, the crust. ? yummy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Ordered a extra large pepperoni pizza last night. Pizza was under cooked. Toppings were minimal and the pepperoni was flavorless. Still looking for a descent pizza in Rochester. Ordered a extra large pepperoni pizza last night. Pizza was under cooked. Toppings were minimal and the pepperoni was flavorless. Still looking for a descent pizza in Rochester.