Yum the pizza is incredible such a classic pizza taste. I can’t stop thinking about the mild wings sauce! So good! Can’t wait to have it again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Greg Clyde
Colombini's has some of the best pizza and deli selections in Chili.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza with Extra Cheese, Wings
Kathleen Meyers
My husband and I love Columbini's pizza. So fresh and delicious. Highly recommend their pizza.
Vegetarian options: Pizzas, appetizers, yummy cookies and brownies.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza with Extra Cheese
Geoffrey Woodward
Awesome. Pricey but food is MINT!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Ethan Lucas
Placed an online order for the "Salami American Assorted" sub on everything, with Swiss, mayo, mustard, lettuce, onion and hot peppers (banana). The bread was amazing. Best sub roll I may have ever had. Also, the condiment and topping ratios were perfect. Very happy with overall construction. However, instead of anything "American assorted" it was JUST SALAMI. I would not have ordered it if I knew it was going to be just salami, and the menu doesn't specify what is on it, so it could have just been a mistake. I wish there was more meat on it, but am also glad there wasn't as it would have been a lot of salami, but if it were turkey or beef in that quantity, I would have been slightly disappointed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Nazya
I came in a few days ago with my mom to get 3 subs. When we entered we weren’t greeted at all by the guy and girl standing at the front counter and instead were kind of awkwardly stared at lol. We didn’t think too much of it so we just start ordering our 3 subs and the guy asks the girl “how long do you think this will take” to which to responds “15 minutes”. It wasnt until almost an hour later that we received our order. I understand places get busy around dinner time but to take 4 times longer than what you told us is a bit absurd. I’m not sure if the unorganization is because of the amount of younger kids working that day or what but please do better.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Gary Davis
Great selection!
Christine Holland
Their wings are delicious and their customer service exceeded our expectations! Would definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristin marie
The pizza is always 10/10. Pricey but good. The chicken wings though... they looked half eaten. We didn't even touch them. Threw the whole box out. Really surprised they would even box these ..
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
john krystan
Ordered a large cheese and pepperoni pizza. Very under cooked and the cheese was like chewing bubble gum. Disgusting. Also got a small chicken wing pizza . Chicken was dry as cardboard and flavorless. To top it off were the chicken wing. When are chicken wing prices so high. Anyways ordered a dozen told them I wanted buffalo mild sauce and the girl even wrote it down on a posted note. Got home with the ordered and it seemed like a very sticky sweet sauce was used. Not buffalo wing sauce. For the price I paid ill never go back. Threw away the left overs and there was alot of it. Garbage.
This was the best pizza in the 80s after d&d pizza closed & 100% still is!! Quality ingredients and fair prices & always clean
Andrew McCloskey
New to the area, trying different spots around town. Nick's wasn't opened yet so hit up Google and this place was so close I could almost throw a rock and hit it and figured it was worth a try. Walked in and was feeling the place out and shooting the breeze with the guy behind the counter and was a good dude and had answers to all my questions about the food and such. Ordered my son a pepperoni pizza and he told me their in house made bread was really good and they were known for their steak subs and chicken finger subs with their own special buffalo sauce and gave me a sample and decided to pull the trigger on that. Looked around at all the Bills memorabilia and chatted some more while we waited for our food. Everything was hot and fresh and we decided to throw on a brownie that we couldn't help but notice was a huge thick slab of chocolaty goodness and threw that on for dessert. My son absolutely loved the pizza. The dough was delicious and the sauce was well balanced and a healthy amount of mozzarella with a slight crisp to the pepperoni was now become my son's favorite pizza. The Buffalo chicken sub which I had toasted on the home made bread didn't disappoint. The breat was tasty I got the sesame seeded bread and the tenders in their signature sause was very good with the provolone I paired with it hit the spot with red onion, hot peppers, black olives, tomato and lettuce. Will be going back for the steak sub and the next time my pizzaholic son wants pizza it's going to be from here. Very happy with our first experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nite Owl
Good subs xcept for $20. lrge was skimpy on the meat. Otherwise 5 stars. Nice signed jersey of Josh Allen on display. Not sure yet on pizza....have to try and they got like FIVE PIZZA OVENS in the back!!?
James Stone
Friendly staff and customers gave a beautiful space an even nicer vibe. I only rated the atmosphere a 4 because I know it would be even better if there was a picture of Josh Allen biting into a Colombini's turkey sub framed next to his signed jersey which is proudly displayed behind the counter.
Any Buffalo fans looking for good fingers, subs, pastries, appetizers and more for their game day parties/tailgates need look no further. Special mention for their delicious take on their Buffalo sauce - it's really flavorful, slightly sweeter and worth a shot even for the Buffalo purists. If it's not to your liking, they offer a traditional version as well.
Go Bills!! and go to Colombini's for amazing food and a great overall experience; they really might have the best chicken finger subs in town, but also offer so much more.
I should also mention that this was my first visit and I called in to ask questions as opposed to looking up the menu; the person who helped me was very patient and helpful to me which is what got me to order in the first place!
Dietary restrictions: Gf pizza available
Parking: Ample parking, but the road you turn off from is quite busy at times
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Glen Layfield
Food was great but I ordered 40 buffalo wings with our pizza for a family gathering because I'm on a low carb diet for diabetes management and when we got back to the house they were tossed in some kind of extremely sweet glaze and we were in a time crunch so we were unable to order replacements
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza with Extra Cheese
Yum the pizza is incredible such a classic pizza taste. I can’t stop thinking about the mild wings sauce! So good! Can’t wait to have it again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Colombini's has some of the best pizza and deli selections in Chili.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza with Extra Cheese, Wings
My husband and I love Columbini's pizza. So fresh and delicious. Highly recommend their pizza.
Vegetarian options: Pizzas, appetizers, yummy cookies and brownies.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza with Extra Cheese
Awesome. Pricey but food is MINT!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Placed an online order for the "Salami American Assorted" sub on everything, with Swiss, mayo, mustard, lettuce, onion and hot peppers (banana). The bread was amazing. Best sub roll I may have ever had. Also, the condiment and topping ratios were perfect. Very happy with overall construction. However, instead of anything "American assorted" it was JUST SALAMI. I would not have ordered it if I knew it was going to be just salami, and the menu doesn't specify what is on it, so it could have just been a mistake. I wish there was more meat on it, but am also glad there wasn't as it would have been a lot of salami, but if it were turkey or beef in that quantity, I would have been slightly disappointed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
I came in a few days ago with my mom to get 3 subs. When we entered we weren’t greeted at all by the guy and girl standing at the front counter and instead were kind of awkwardly stared at lol. We didn’t think too much of it so we just start ordering our 3 subs and the guy asks the girl “how long do you think this will take” to which to responds “15 minutes”. It wasnt until almost an hour later that we received our order. I understand places get busy around dinner time but to take 4 times longer than what you told us is a bit absurd. I’m not sure if the unorganization is because of the amount of younger kids working that day or what but please do better.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Great selection!
Their wings are delicious and their customer service exceeded our expectations! Would definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is always 10/10. Pricey but good. The chicken wings though... they looked half eaten. We didn't even touch them. Threw the whole box out. Really surprised they would even box these ..
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Ordered a large cheese and pepperoni pizza. Very under cooked and the cheese was like chewing bubble gum. Disgusting. Also got a small chicken wing pizza . Chicken was dry as cardboard and flavorless. To top it off were the chicken wing. When are chicken wing prices so high. Anyways ordered a dozen told them I wanted buffalo mild sauce and the girl even wrote it down on a posted note. Got home with the ordered and it seemed like a very sticky sweet sauce was used. Not buffalo wing sauce. For the price I paid ill never go back. Threw away the left overs and there was alot of it. Garbage.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
This was the best pizza in the 80s after d&d pizza closed & 100% still is!! Quality ingredients and fair prices & always clean
New to the area, trying different spots around town. Nick's wasn't opened yet so hit up Google and this place was so close I could almost throw a rock and hit it and figured it was worth a try. Walked in and was feeling the place out and shooting the breeze with the guy behind the counter and was a good dude and had answers to all my questions about the food and such. Ordered my son a pepperoni pizza and he told me their in house made bread was really good and they were known for their steak subs and chicken finger subs with their own special buffalo sauce and gave me a sample and decided to pull the trigger on that. Looked around at all the Bills memorabilia and chatted some more while we waited for our food. Everything was hot and fresh and we decided to throw on a brownie that we couldn't help but notice was a huge thick slab of chocolaty goodness and threw that on for dessert. My son absolutely loved the pizza. The dough was delicious and the sauce was well balanced and a healthy amount of mozzarella with a slight crisp to the pepperoni was now become my son's favorite pizza. The Buffalo chicken sub which I had toasted on the home made bread didn't disappoint. The breat was tasty I got the sesame seeded bread and the tenders in their signature sause was very good with the provolone I paired with it hit the spot with red onion, hot peppers, black olives, tomato and lettuce. Will be going back for the steak sub and the next time my pizzaholic son wants pizza it's going to be from here. Very happy with our first experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good subs xcept for $20. lrge was skimpy on the meat. Otherwise 5 stars. Nice signed jersey of Josh Allen on display. Not sure yet on pizza....have to try and they got like FIVE PIZZA OVENS in the back!!?
Friendly staff and customers gave a beautiful space an even nicer vibe. I only rated the atmosphere a 4 because I know it would be even better if there was a picture of Josh Allen biting into a Colombini's turkey sub framed next to his signed jersey which is proudly displayed behind the counter.
Any Buffalo fans looking for good fingers, subs, pastries, appetizers and more for their game day parties/tailgates need look no further. Special mention for their delicious take on their Buffalo sauce - it's really flavorful, slightly sweeter and worth a shot even for the Buffalo purists. If it's not to your liking, they offer a traditional version as well.
Go Bills!! and go to Colombini's for amazing food and a great overall experience; they really might have the best chicken finger subs in town, but also offer so much more.
I should also mention that this was my first visit and I called in to ask questions as opposed to looking up the menu; the person who helped me was very patient and helpful to me which is what got me to order in the first place!
Dietary restrictions: Gf pizza available
Parking: Ample parking, but the road you turn off from is quite busy at times
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was great but I ordered 40 buffalo wings with our pizza for a family gathering because I'm on a low carb diet for diabetes management and when we got back to the house they were tossed in some kind of extremely sweet glaze and we were in a time crunch so we were unable to order replacements
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza with Extra Cheese
Loading...