Creative Caterers

Creative Caterers supplied breakfast for a live audience show on 98.9 The Buzz and the food was outstanding!! It was aesthetically pleasing as well, and the staff was very friendly. I would highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We received so many compliments on the food at our wedding, especially the appetizers! I would highly recommend!!

Delicious food, everything was as stated.

Creative Caterers handled our Grand (Re)Opening here at Keuka Spring Vineyards in Penn Yan, NY and I can not say enough good things about our experience. Jeff and Mary Kay are awesome to work with and look forward to future events with them. Thank You!!

Absolutely fantastic! My guests went back for third helpings and raved about the food. The staff was professional, efficient, and 100% on task. I've never had an event run this smoothly in all my years of planning parties. They did an outstanding job.

The catering was handled superbly. The staff was very attentive while being unobtrusive and the food was excellent.

We had nearly 100 guests for our 45th high school reunion. I heard nothing but rave reviews for the menu and the staff. Well done, you should be very proud!

Had my wedding there 34 years ago they were awesome. The food was wonderful. The staff was point on! It’s such a beautiful location, beautiful inside and out! Highly recommended⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Creative Caterers went above and beyond to make my wedding amazing, especially since I contacted them a week before my wedding!!! Meg was super easy to communicate with over phone and email as we worked out the details, days before the wedding. Also, I wanted to give a shout out to the two servers that day - Edmundo and Joshua. They were absolutely fantastic and we couldn't have done it without them! Definitely recommend!!!

I just had my wedding catered by Glendoveers (at a different venue) and it was some of the best food any of us have had at a wedding! The carved sirloin and alfredo sauce were especially delicious. They were so helpful with getting everything set up and taken down, including centerpieces that we had brought ourselves. I have heard that a lot of newly-weds don't even get a chance to eat their own food, but the caterers prepared an entire plate of appetizers for us on our sweetheart table while we were doing photos. They also even served the two of us dinner plates even though we had a buffet dinner, and packed up the remainder of our cake and desserts nicely.

We just had our daughter’s wedding and reception at Toganenwood. It was perfect! The team was accommodating, the food was great, and so many of our guests said it was the best wedding they’ve ever attended! Chelsea was AMAZING! She guided everything so smoothly that we were able to just enjoy the whole event. Most of all my daughter and her wife had the ceremony and epic party they dreamed of.
Having use of the farmhouse at Toganenwood Friday and Saturday nights for the wedding party was ideal. Also, the bridal suite is exceptional with chairs, mirrors, outlets, comfortable seating, several make-up stations, full bathroom, and fridge.
If we have need for a large party again, we will use Creative Caterers again - whether at the barn (Toganenwood) or at Glendoveer’s. Customer service was unbeatable.

I attended an event that was catered by Creative Caterers and I cannot say enough good things about them! They were so seamless in their clean up and transitions and everything was so tasteful! I plan to use them for my own events moving forward!

They did such a beautiful job with my daughter's entire shower! The food was delicious and they were so accommodating! I highly recommend them!

On a day that is supposed to be the best day of someone’s life their wedding day was ridiculous ruined. The food which was a custom picked menu by the bride was not what not what she ordered. Some of us guest didn’t even get to eat because it was wrong. Steak was either over cooked or not cooked enough. Some of the potatoes were black. A bride should not have to go through with worrying about the dinner or hors d’oeuvres at a wedding that she paid good money for. If you want good food don’t go through this place they will rip you off and refused to even give you anything back. Oh and the bride over paid and they won’t even give her that back. Horrible service I wish you could pick 0 stars

I'm gonna keep this short but I do have a much more detailed post as well as receipts. I had my wedding on 6.22.24 and these were my caterers. From the very first meeting with them I had a custom menu. Which was gone over more than once leading up to my event. I was assured it was fine. On the day of my wedding I was missing appetizers and my dinners were not the custom options I had worked out with them. When I requested a PARTIAL refund (because the bar was fine. I'm not going to unreasonably request a full refund) they said they wouldn't because it wasn't their fault I received the wrong food. It was their employees fault because she put the custom notes in the wrong spot. So somehow they are not responsible for their employees. In addition, just be warned that they told me it's their policy not to refund overpayment. I overpaid by about $250 based on my invoice total and was told they won't give it back, in addition to not giving me a refund for messing up my menu. I gave them a chance to work this out privately but they refused to work with me, so here I am in the court of public opinion. Here's what I know their response to this is going to be, because they told me already. They said they don't owe me money because (besides not being responsible for their employees mistakes) I underpaid already. They think I underpaid because according to them the minimum charge for the RMSC is 100 people, which I was never told, and in fact, at my very first meeting I told them my guest count was 85 and they said okay that works. So I'm not sure how I underpaid when i signed a contract they made for my event. If they forgot to charge, that doesn't mean they can just freestyle my menu into something I didn't want with absolutely no communication about it. Aside from all this, the food tasted like a salt-free reheated frozen dinner.