Delmonico's Italian Steakhouse

125 White Spruce Blvd, Rochester
(585) 424-4242

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jennifer Bell-Colliver

Food and service were fantastic. Atmosphere was a little shticky for my tastes, but to each their own.
We started off with their calamari which was cooked perfectly, then I had the veal parm which was so good, and my partner got the veal marsala 🤤 To finish up the meal we ordered the pumpkin cannoli to share and it was perfect. Overall would definitely come back and recommend to others.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephanie Thurston

This restaurant brings you back to the 80s with the decor on the walls, the furniture was decent but the wall decor was very dated and tacky. It could use an update. The service was fantastic, we had a party of 6 and our server was very attentive to our needs. We were all very satisfied with the food. Although, I had mentioned an allergy when ordering and my food came out with my allergin on it. The server was very apologetic and quickly made it right which I appreciated. Overall it was a great place with good food worth the cost. It just needs a face-lift with the wall decor.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Tina

Great atmosphere, delicious food and the manager went above and beyond to accommodate my reservation of 6, we asked for another table so my party of 6 can sit comfortably instead of having to all fit in a booth with 6 adults and a toddler.

Matthew Saltzberg

Decent deals if you sit at the bar and get happy hour items. Filet sandwich was delicious.

Debra Gonzalez

I have had the privilege to dine here with my husband for the first time today! Wow! What delicious chicken prosciutto, tomato mozzarella salad and tiramisu. I will never go back to Olive Garden lolol
I highly recommend it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mark Miller

Had the 24oz prime rib steak, 10x better than red osier!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rick Moscato

We requested a small private room and we got it, the last two times we did not. But manager Addison since you would hold it are waitress Amanda was more than five stars she was excellent! All in all a great experience!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kellie Michele

I had a small wedding ceremony and decided to go to Delmonico's for dinner after. I wasn't sure how many people would attend the dinner after so when I made the reservation I told them the number would be 15 give or take. I explained I was unsure. When we got there we had 18 people and there were only 15 seats. If 3 more were added to the table it would be very cramped. The manager was completely useless!! She acted like this issue has never happened and she was unable to problem solve the situation at all. My best friend had to leave because the only soulution the manager had was for my best friend to sit somewhere else in the restaurant. Does that seem like a reasonable solution to you? Me either!! Then, my family sat at the table for 20 minutes before a waitress asked if we wanted water. The servers were nice but the food wasn't worth the price. That manager ruined my wedding celebration and I'll never get celebrating with my best friend ever again.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

Paul

The food was delicious and our service was excellent! We had our own private booth that was very roomy and cozy! Everything was perfect and made my birthday celebration special! We cannot wait to come back!!

John Everett

Take out order. Timely. Friendly staff. Delmonico steak was a hockey puck. If you want a tender steak, this steak is not for you. Caesar salad great. Butter/bread good. Broccoli fine.

Food: 1

Linda

We went for steaks. They were awful. Dry. Chewy. No flavor. Certainly not worth any money. It's not a good food evening, when I can cook better than what was served to us. The wine was good.

Rodney Thompson

Great pasta, next visit will include the Bone in Ribeye!!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fred Davis

The bomb great gotta go back

Jesus Natrigo

Ordered the ribeye and after adding salt and pepper it wasn't too bad. Most of my steak was just fat. Not worth paying over $40.00. 3 of us ordered it and all of them had more fat than meat wouldn't recommend it

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Lance

We had a wonder night. We will be back! The steaks we're cooked perfectly seem to lack a little seasoning. Still excellent kind of meat. Our server was amazing. She really took good care of us and the booth was just outstanding great ambience. The mentalist on staff is amazing.

Loading...