Get Caked Bakery Inc
274 N Goodman St b132, Rochester
(585) 319-4314
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Out got our wedding cake and other pastries from Get Caked! I am so super happy with the final products! would recommend 10/10!! responsive, and our cake was EXACTLY how we wanted it! Kelly is easy to work with and she listens!
Kelly was amazing to work with, she helped with my bridal shower in May with cookies, and gluten free funfetti cake that tasted amazing! My husband and I loved it so much we decided to use them again for our dessert on our wedding day 6.22.25. The wedding cake was beautiful and it tasted amazing as well (almond flavored cake with raspberry filling). We also had mini cup cakes, cream puffs, mini brownies with frosting all gluten free, and regular mini eclairs, and mini cannoli's. Everything was so delicious. We will keep Get Caked for future events and would definitely recommend them for any of your events!!
The vegan and GF options! The wonderful flavors! SO many different baked goods. And truly kind staff and owners!
The vegan banana loaf is very tasty. I like that the most. I always get two each time I make it to the village gate. I enjoy those the most. Very affordable and hefty. I like those a lot.
Ordered 3 dozen cupcakes for a Bluey 2nd birthday (for the bluey lovers, it was called 'This episode of Bluey is called Peighton turns twoey' they were so delicious 😋 cookies and cream with chocolate ganache filling, funfetti with raspberry filling and frosting, then marble with peanut butter ganache filling and chocolate frosting 🤤 it was easy to order through email and the owner was great to work with! Will be ordering from Get Caked again 😃
Very happy with the custom cake that I ordered! They did exactly what I asked for, and it turned out prettier than I imagined! The funfetti and almond cake was also very tasty, a tad bit dry but still very good.
I have been a reoccurring customer for the past few years. The first custom cake we got was absolutely amazing. It was gluten and dairy free but still so delicious and moist. But the more we order custom cakes from them, the worse the quality has gotten. The last cake we ordered was so incredibly dry and dense; and it had barely any filling in it. There were chunks of unmixed ingredients like flour and food coloring.
I also couldn’t help but notice that they increased their prices from $55 to $90. For such a large jump in price, I would expect the quality to be good and consistent. I unfortunately don’t think we will be ordering custom cakes again and it’s a shame because we usually ordered a few per year to support their business.
I had a really good experience with this bakery! The entire process, from inquiry to pickup, was smooth and hassle-free. They were professional, responsive, and true to their word, which I really appreciated, especially after dealing with poor communication from another bakery.
The order was for a custom cake and it turned out lovely. The customization worked well, and the design matched closely with the picture I had sent them. The cake was delicious too, moist and sweet. Even though we moved the cake around quite a bit, it held its shape perfectly throughout the event.
Pickup was on time and easy as well, and I barely had to follow up. They handled everything with care and reliability. I’d happily order from them again!
My favorite bakery!! ❤️
We have ordered our son’s birthday cakes from here two years in a row now. Excellent customer service and quality. They turned out amazing both times! Pickup at the drive up out back was super quick and convenient. Grateful for vegan options as well. Thank you guys!
Restaurantji Recommends
Always a great tasting freshly made pastry to choose from and the options are worth it. Hardly no bad choices only due to allergies on my part. The people who work there are always very friendly so that makes for a great experience as well. They are well worth it. Just got out in some extra reps because you’ll go there for a couple things and end up with more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes, Chocolate Cake
Must have been an anomaly. The next cake that i got was spot on like I am used to getting from Get Caked. Their gluten free /dairy free cakes are out of this world!!
"I get one of their cakes about three times a year and have never been disappointed until today. A gluten free and dairy free cake that I ordered turned out dry or should I dare say, stale.
It was a birthday cake for my mother in law and she openly declared that the cake was too dry.
This is the first time I have not been happy with their work; in the past, I and my guests have raved about their cakes.
Everybody makes mistakes and I will order from them again, but they should probably invest in quality control."
Food: 2
Service: 2
Love their cakes 5 star absolutely!! I just wish they would bring bad my favorite turtle dove cake.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Get Caked baked our wedding cake, and we were so happy with the result. They made it so easy to order our cake. Delivery was on time and hassle free. It looked perfect and tasted even better!
When I walked in to Get Caked I was greeted by Kelly. I was so overwhelmed with all things wedding. I didn't know which bakery to use, quantity, cost, logistics about day of.. all the things. The first bakery I walked into told me "just look online at all their options." I guess they just expect everybody to know what they want walking in the door bc they've been around so long but it felt very impersonal. They also did not have many options without ricotta... heavy cream etc. But back to Kelly! She took the time to walk me through it all, and I left feeling completely taken care of and at ease that I made the right decision with putting our special day in her hands. She offers delivery. She said she would put the flowers on the cake and sent me a quote. My parents wanted to pay for the desserts so she sent me an invoice to forward. Super easy, every step. She has so many delicious dairy free options. She sent my mom, MIL and I home with several things to try. The lemon raspberry cupcakes and her smore macarons were delish!
-Savanah (using hubby's gmail to rave about you!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Macaron, Vegan Cupcakes, Wedding Cake, Lemon Cake with Raspberry Filling
Loading...