Hi, I came in for 12 cupcakes this past Friday. Wow! So many flavors! Everything looked delicious. I believe they had 14 cupcake flavors on hand. It was hard to choose so I filled a dozen with 12 different flavors. The service was amazing from start to finish, very friendly conversation. It’s nice to have a local bakery in town to visit for sweet goodies. Now the cupcakes, I knew they would be delicious, but they exceeded my expectations. The frosting was light and fluffy, the cupcakes were moist and every flavor was on point. 11 of 12 flavors had fillings which is hard to come by. I loved the s’mores one and the cheesecake one. I will be back for sure! If you’re looking for special treats that are out of the usual, this place is the place. I’m sure they can do anything really.
Brittany Kent
A very special THANK YOU to Go Frost Yourself for the most perfect Bluey cake ? This is our second time ordering a custom cake, and it surpassed our expectations (even though we knew it would be good ?)If you live on the west side of Rochester (or are willing to drive), I recommend checking out GFY. They always have an incredible display filled with cupcakes, various pastries, cookies, and other assorted goodies. The owners take pride in their work, and it clearly shows. Everything is high quality and absolutely delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erika Kirsch
We ordered a smash cake for my son's first birthday and the staff were so easy to work with, provided a ton of options for sizing, flavors, etc and did a fantastic job with our airplane theme! Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Dean Wight
They are amazing bakers. Their scones are delicious. My favorite local baked goods. I worked In a bakery for15 years.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Julie Fitzsimons
Oh my where to begin! Everything we got was soo good. My favorite was a coconut cupcake. The cake is homemade & you can definitely taste it. The frosting is delicious too..no nasty store buttercream here. The cinnamon rolls are about the size of your face topped with the best cream cheese frosting I've ever tasted. They also have huge cookies of which I got the confetti & like everything else it was outstanding. We highly recommend Go Frost Yourself for any baked goods they have!
Absolutely amazing cake & cupcakes for my daughters birthday. They came out exactly how she wanted and everyone loved the flavors. I heard from a couple people at the party that they were the best cupcakes/ cake they have ever had. Hard to find places that can make them look great and taste great at the same time. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeremy M.
Had to stop by and give it a try. Small scratch made bakery is how it should be done. Got a variety of cupcakes and some brown butter chocolate chip cookies as well as a snickerdoodle cookies. All very good and would not hesitate to stop there again. There are some places that might be out of the way but the quality of what they do makes the trip worthwhile. This is one of those places. Now when I say out of the way it only takes me 15 min to drive there but I would drive further.
Stephanie Lee
Everything is always so good! We personally love their cheesecakes! Mollie and Jenn are always so helpful and make such delicious treats. Would highly recommend!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dave Edwards
Hands down the best place to get a custom cake in the city of Rochester. Mollie you did an absolutely amazing job with the cake thank you so much. If you ever need anything custom these two ladies should be your go to! Quick to respond and not afraid to take on a challenge. Tastes as good it looks too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristina Gramlich
This is one of the best bakeries I have ever done business with! From beginning to end Jenn and Mollie were a pleasure to work with and made an amazing cake for our daughters baptism! If anyone is looking for pastries, cookies, or cakes I highly recommend them!
Absolutely my go-to place for my fix of decadent pastries made with love. I love businesses that take pride in quality for their customers. So glad I’ve found this bakery. P.s. Their cakes for special events are amazing too!!!
The BEST cinnamon rolls and the BEST friendly service. All their bakes goods are delicious and I always leave with more than I planned on. I don’t even live here anymore but make it a point to come to this bakery every chance I visit. Well worth it!
Danielle Seier
The best cinnamon rolls I’ve ever had!! On top of a convenient location and wonderful customer service. Can’t go wrong with GFY!
Justin Porter
Great owners, friendly staff, a must try if you haven’t already!
Hi, I came in for 12 cupcakes this past Friday. Wow! So many flavors! Everything looked delicious. I believe they had 14 cupcake flavors on hand. It was hard to choose so I filled a dozen with 12 different flavors. The service was amazing from start to finish, very friendly conversation. It’s nice to have a local bakery in town to visit for sweet goodies. Now the cupcakes, I knew they would be delicious, but they exceeded my expectations. The frosting was light and fluffy, the cupcakes were moist and every flavor was on point. 11 of 12 flavors had fillings which is hard to come by. I loved the s’mores one and the cheesecake one. I will be back for sure! If you’re looking for special treats that are out of the usual, this place is the place. I’m sure they can do anything really.
A very special THANK YOU to Go Frost Yourself for the most perfect Bluey cake ? This is our second time ordering a custom cake, and it surpassed our expectations (even though we knew it would be good ?)If you live on the west side of Rochester (or are willing to drive), I recommend checking out GFY. They always have an incredible display filled with cupcakes, various pastries, cookies, and other assorted goodies. The owners take pride in their work, and it clearly shows. Everything is high quality and absolutely delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered a smash cake for my son's first birthday and the staff were so easy to work with, provided a ton of options for sizing, flavors, etc and did a fantastic job with our airplane theme! Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
They are amazing bakers. Their scones are delicious. My favorite local baked goods. I worked In a bakery for15 years.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Oh my where to begin! Everything we got was soo good. My favorite was a coconut cupcake. The cake is homemade & you can definitely taste it. The frosting is delicious too..no nasty store buttercream here. The cinnamon rolls are about the size of your face topped with the best cream cheese frosting I've ever tasted. They also have huge cookies of which I got the confetti & like everything else it was outstanding. We highly recommend Go Frost Yourself for any baked goods they have!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rainbow Cookie, Cinnamon Rolls
Absolutely amazing cake & cupcakes for my daughters birthday. They came out exactly how she wanted and everyone loved the flavors. I heard from a couple people at the party that they were the best cupcakes/ cake they have ever had. Hard to find places that can make them look great and taste great at the same time. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had to stop by and give it a try. Small scratch made bakery is how it should be done. Got a variety of cupcakes and some brown butter chocolate chip cookies as well as a snickerdoodle cookies. All very good and would not hesitate to stop there again. There are some places that might be out of the way but the quality of what they do makes the trip worthwhile. This is one of those places. Now when I say out of the way it only takes me 15 min to drive there but I would drive further.
Everything is always so good! We personally love their cheesecakes! Mollie and Jenn are always so helpful and make such delicious treats. Would highly recommend!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hands down the best place to get a custom cake in the city of Rochester. Mollie you did an absolutely amazing job with the cake thank you so much. If you ever need anything custom these two ladies should be your go to! Quick to respond and not afraid to take on a challenge. Tastes as good it looks too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is one of the best bakeries I have ever done business with! From beginning to end Jenn and Mollie were a pleasure to work with and made an amazing cake for our daughters baptism! If anyone is looking for pastries, cookies, or cakes I highly recommend them!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely my go-to place for my fix of decadent pastries made with love. I love businesses that take pride in quality for their customers. So glad I’ve found this bakery. P.s. Their cakes for special events are amazing too!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Almond Raspberry Cupcake, Cinnamon Roll, Birthday Cake
Delicious, Delicious, Delicious!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The BEST cinnamon rolls and the BEST friendly service. All their bakes goods are delicious and I always leave with more than I planned on. I don’t even live here anymore but make it a point to come to this bakery every chance I visit. Well worth it!
The best cinnamon rolls I’ve ever had!! On top of a convenient location and wonderful customer service. Can’t go wrong with GFY!
Great owners, friendly staff, a must try if you haven’t already!