The absolute best pot pies!!! Newbury’s pies are huge and packed full of delicious filling. The crust is buttery, flaky, and perfectly golden. They’re the ultimate comfort meal hearty, cozy, and so satisfying every time.
Benjamin Stephens (Ben)
They make some delicious pies. So far I've had the Panang pot pie and Green Curry With mussels. They have an amazing top and bottom crust that baked with a flaky buttery crispiness. The curry is mild enough for anyone who is sensitive to spice but still packs flavor. One small pot pie is enough for two people.
Kristi Stever
All of the pies that we have purchased were delicious, but the Shepherd's pie is amazing - we have served it to guests who told us that they don't like Shepherd's pie, but they loved this one! Make sure to order ahead of time.
Melissa McDade
This is the best chicken pot pie I have ever had. The chicken chunks were huge and everything was so fresh tasting. Highly recommend if you find comfort in pot pies. ❤️
NancyRose Kellison
Purchased their chicken pot pie from the Brighton Farmers Market and OH MY GOD! It is THE BEST pot pie we’ve had ever had! After exploring their website and social media, we can’t WAIT to try more of their specialty pies as well as their famous Turkey Pot Pie later this year. Thank you!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Pot Pie
MD062010
Visited them at the Brighton, Farmers Market- selected their breakfast quiche and Shepard’s pie- must say- I really enjoyed the quiche! Very nicely seasoned, but their crust is honestly amazing…. One of the best pastry crusts I have ever had. And it baked up perfectly in the oven. Looking forward to trying more of their pies.
Food: 5
iammealj
I have been ordering and buying in person the best savory pot pies I’ve ever had!! My favorite pot pie is this chicken and biscuit! The chicken is beyond tender, and there is so much of it! The veggies are bright and fresh. The pie shell itself, hand made, is so flaky every time. I first discovered this special bakery several years ago at the Brighton Market on Sundays, but I have ordered online several times to pick up at bakery direct. It was great during COVID to have these comfort foods. They have sweets as well! Good work deserves good words! Give them a try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Pot Pie
Tori
The panang pot pie is out of this world!!! It's such an unexpected pairing that works perfectly together!(: love love love!!
Came upon the pastry shop on accident when I was out for a walk. So glad that you had some turkey dinner pot pies available-had it for dinner tonight with a salad. Such a good flavor and quite enjoyable. Would recommend!
Monica McCullough
Most amazing coconut cream pie!! I’d give you 10 stars if I could! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Steve Pollet
We have enjoyed every pie we’ve tried, savory & sweet. We just had our first steak & ale pie, my favorite so far! Love this place!
Matt
Walking down the aisle in the frozen section, and almost did a double take. Panang pot pie?? Panang is my favorite curry so I absolutely had to grab one & give it a try. We changed our dinner plans for the evening & made the pie instead. And it was fantastic!!Seriously, even with the first bite I knew we were in trouble. The pie crust is so flaky, buttery, and delicious. And the panang sauce pairs incredibly well with the crust. The pie was full to the brim with wonderful, well spiced curry & vegetables. Not a single thing to complain about - except maybe that we only bought the small one ?Highly recommend giving some of these pies a try if you see them. I think they're going to make a fairly regular appearance in our home!
Carrie Roberts
I was finally lucky enough to get a pot pie from Newbury Park Pastries last weekend and it was fantastic! The crust was so buttery and flaky and the huge chunks of chicken and thick gravy was delicious. If you haven't yet, run, don't walk, and get you some as soon as humanly possible. Thanks Kate for making such fantastic food!
Fantastic pies, cookies, everything!
The absolute best pot pies!!! Newbury’s pies are huge and packed full of delicious filling. The crust is buttery, flaky, and perfectly golden. They’re the ultimate comfort meal hearty, cozy, and so satisfying every time.
They make some delicious pies. So far I've had the Panang pot pie and Green Curry With mussels. They have an amazing top and bottom crust that baked with a flaky buttery crispiness. The curry is mild enough for anyone who is sensitive to spice but still packs flavor. One small pot pie is enough for two people.
All of the pies that we have purchased were delicious, but the Shepherd's pie is amazing - we have served it to guests who told us that they don't like Shepherd's pie, but they loved this one! Make sure to order ahead of time.
This is the best chicken pot pie I have ever had. The chicken chunks were huge and everything was so fresh tasting. Highly recommend if you find comfort in pot pies. ❤️
Purchased their chicken pot pie from the Brighton Farmers Market and OH MY GOD! It is THE BEST pot pie we’ve had ever had! After exploring their website and social media, we can’t WAIT to try more of their specialty pies as well as their famous Turkey Pot Pie later this year. Thank you!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Pot Pie
Visited them at the Brighton, Farmers Market- selected their breakfast quiche and Shepard’s pie- must say- I really enjoyed the quiche! Very nicely seasoned, but their crust is honestly amazing…. One of the best pastry crusts I have ever had. And it baked up perfectly in the oven. Looking forward to trying more of their pies.
Food: 5
I have been ordering and buying in person the best savory pot pies I’ve ever had!! My favorite pot pie is this chicken and biscuit! The chicken is beyond tender, and there is so much of it! The veggies are bright and fresh. The pie shell itself, hand made, is so flaky every time. I first discovered this special bakery several years ago at the Brighton Market on Sundays, but I have ordered online several times to pick up at bakery direct. It was great during COVID to have these comfort foods. They have sweets as well! Good work deserves good words! Give them a try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Pot Pie
The panang pot pie is out of this world!!! It's such an unexpected pairing that works perfectly together!(: love love love!!
The thanksgiving pie was AMAZING.
Restaurantji Recommends
Came upon the pastry shop on accident when I was out for a walk. So glad that you had some turkey dinner pot pies available-had it for dinner tonight with a salad. Such a good flavor and quite enjoyable. Would recommend!
Most amazing coconut cream pie!! I’d give you 10 stars if I could! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
We have enjoyed every pie we’ve tried, savory & sweet. We just had our first steak & ale pie, my favorite so far! Love this place!
Walking down the aisle in the frozen section, and almost did a double take. Panang pot pie?? Panang is my favorite curry so I absolutely had to grab one & give it a try. We changed our dinner plans for the evening & made the pie instead. And it was fantastic!!Seriously, even with the first bite I knew we were in trouble. The pie crust is so flaky, buttery, and delicious. And the panang sauce pairs incredibly well with the crust. The pie was full to the brim with wonderful, well spiced curry & vegetables. Not a single thing to complain about - except maybe that we only bought the small one ?Highly recommend giving some of these pies a try if you see them. I think they're going to make a fairly regular appearance in our home!
I was finally lucky enough to get a pot pie from Newbury Park Pastries last weekend and it was fantastic! The crust was so buttery and flaky and the huge chunks of chicken and thick gravy was delicious. If you haven't yet, run, don't walk, and get you some as soon as humanly possible. Thanks Kate for making such fantastic food!
Loading...