Pontillo's Pizzerias
4468 Lake Ave, Rochester
(585) 621-1816
Customers' Favorites
White Garlic Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
You can never go wrong with Pontillos, it’s always a solid choice. My only suggestion for improvement is a little more consistency on the menu from store to store. I’ve had times where I’ve called one location and accidentally looked at the menu for another, which confused the staff. Otherwise, it’s a great pizza place.
Something has changed with the taste of their dough and sauce within that last 6 months or so.This used to be my favorite pizza in Rochester for years, but now it lacks the flavor it used to have.They used to sprinkle romano cheese in clumps all over the pizza and over the crust, for one, but now it's non existent. I mentioned that specifically when I ordered and was told they would put extra on my pizza for me. My pizza arrived with the amount of romano cheese that would...
Didn’t care for the pizza at all. Both crust and sauce. The wings were really good. Extra large and flavorful. Just could have been cooked a little more. Would definitely order wings again and specify well done
You May Also Like
Ma'ama Tee's Cookin & Catering - 4435 Lake Ave
![]()
Caterers, Venues & Event Spaces
Whiskey River Pub and Grill - 421 River St
![]()
Bar & Grill, Pubs, Seafood