Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

4000 Lake Ave, Rochester
(585) 663-4000

Recent Reviews

M & M

Food here USE TO be great. But lately the food has been tasteless and sloppy.Before they made your order just like you wanted it, now they do the opposite. I think they changed cooks and I will be changing location ☺️

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

MrMrs “Noneyabizness” Kro.

Lake ave location could use some help. Making clients wait longer than necessary. I'm sure you will have some workers who appreciate the

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 2

MrMrs Kro.

Lake ave location could use some help. Making clients wait longer than necessary. I'm sure you will have some workers who appreciate the

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 2

confident 77

Spent almost $60 through Door Dash 1/21/24 to deliver my food from the Lake Avenue Salvatores. Never again for ordering from this particular Salvatores or using Door Dash to deliver. Called and spoke to the person who prepared my order and they weren't very friendly or had a concern about the presentation of the meals Door Dash handed me or the missing items.I ordered the fish meal. The roll, butter, lemon, ketchup was missing even though the preparer said he placed it in there. The box had no seal on it to protect the Dashers from tampering with the food and eating it which what it looks like happened. My fish, french fries, onion rings looked like someone shook the box to make it look like there was a lot of food scattered around.I also ordered a double cheeseburger with onion rings.Some of the ingredients I asked to be on the cheeseburger wasn't there. And the onion rings was old tasting.I ordered two peanut butter cookies and two M&M cookies. Tell me why I got four M&M cookies that tasted like they were expired.I ended up apologizing to my guest and threw it all in trash. Since Door Dash refused to refund me my money back this is what I am doing to make others aware in case they order from this particular restaurant.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Sanyam Sharma

Good cheese pizza and breath mint

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Billy G

Love there pizza and so will u , they also make good subs here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Fingers, Pasta

Anthony N3lla

It's salvatores. If you've been to one you've been to them all. When it comes to pizza that is. The service is great. Super fast. The bar is a nice touch for sure. Especially if you are waiting for the pizza to be done. Definitely stop in.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Kathleen Carrera

The raspberry cheesecake I got today tasted nothing like cheesecake. It tasted old. Like it’s been sitting being showcased for months. It was hard and I really can’t explain the taste. Just stale or expired and like cardboard or basement I don’t know. But disgusting. Guess I’ll never be ordering dessert from there again. Check how long you guys keep your desserts. Pizza and wings were good as always though.

Food: 1

Joe Ignizio

This restaurant is on top of their game. Food, Price Staff. Top Notch

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marissa N.

I like Salvatore's sauce the best of any pizza place. I like this location, it's super convenient for me and the owner is lovely. I had a great steak sub, and look forward to the next one.

Claire McAuley

Their pizza perks points are sooooo worth it! Thank you for the birthday pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

John Wysocky

Absolutely horrible!!! All the food was really cold. You're better off getting a frozen dinner and putting it in the microwave. At least then, it would have been warm.I knew it was going to be bad when our order showed up after an hour and a half of waiting. The driver apologized that it was so late because all the employees just quit. After calling back to see what could be done, I see why they left.

David Knight

Just had a calzone from this joint… AMAZING falls short of describing this. Try lake Ave location and I suggest the double old fashioned pepperoni calzone!!Parking: Plenty of safe parking

Amy Lynn Massaro

Food was great, shop was very clean, staff was friendly!

Monarch

The food is almost always good, and delivery is quick. However, at this point, the prices are outrageous. As a long-time customer, I'm done. I won't be paying $17 for a meal, $5.40 for a "convenience fee" and a tip on top of that for a meal for one person. This isn't fine dining. Besides, do you know how many eggs I could get with those $$$? It's just no longer worth it.

Load More

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

4000 Lake Ave, Rochester, NY 14612
(585) 663-4000