Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

They don't take orders to detail. And they suck for that. I can't eat what they sent. I placed an order I should receive the order I placed. They seem to not care.

Today, June 22, 2025, my husband was the winner of a pizza for the radio mega and we came to get it for this Salvatore and I can tell you that since we entered and said that he had been the winner of a pizza they began to treat us super badly, they left us waiting 20 minutes for a soda that never arrived, they did not give us the pizza and the 2 girls who were in front attending were super rude they never gave us the pizza or soda, I am angry about that and I recommend not going there

i’m waiting for my pizza and my soda they never give to me

Great pizza.

Great place to hang out and watch the game or have a couple of bees with friends!

Ordered a chicken finger sub best I’ve had in a long time crispy sesame roll lots of fingers crispy. Good fries ordered a few slices to good as well blows marks out of the water. Only tried this place because of a free pizza for moving to the area and now it’s my go too

Come here all the time. Friendly staff, Good food and clean place. Daily food and drink specials with lots of TV's to watch!

Just ok. Again, Rochester customer service stinks.

The best Salvatore's! I live on the West side but I always come to this one

My food that I ordered wasn't exactly what I ordered it was okay but I prefer to go to the other one that I've always been going to

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

You can spend a lot of money in this place you will never be rewarded or important to them as a customer!

Wheelchair accessibility: They have the worst Old lady hag nag working there she’s always rude as hell!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Favorite Pizza, Buffalo Wings

Hadn't been here in a while so I decided to check it out for old time sake, and was quickly reminded why. I ordered my food and sat at the bar, and never got serviced. Servers were eating behind the counter, only one out of four servers were actually working. Then to top it off the steak in my sandwich was way overcooked..... Let's just say I'll NEVER have this problem again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

always happy ro shop there

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

They burn my pizza I ask for light sauce and I got extra

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

For got to put drink in bag so I had to go back to get it waste of gas

Service: 1

Been a long time that I've gotten pizza decided to order a super slice just to be disappointed with two slices instead of one giant slice, pizza was room temp and extremely dry as if the slices sat out all day. Delivery driver refused to walk the pizza to the door as well.

Food: 1

Service: 5