food was good quality and came out fast, we waited at least 20 minutes for the check after we called her over to get the check. when she came back she gave us someone else’s credit card and did not give us our check, waited another few minutes didn’t get our check so I had to give her some cash because we had been there too long. also overheard complaints from other customers about missing food and long wait times
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Tessa Rossi
My boyfriend and I ordered food from them from DoorDash tonight. Our delivery driver got there and waited for our food. Somehow they gave our food away to the wrong person and when DoorDash asked them to remake our food for us they refused. Not many other places are open this late to order food. We have never ordered from here before and are very disappointed with this experience. We likely won’t order from them again.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Your Name
Sometimes it's fun, sometimes you get ignored. Hit or miss. The bartender that was really cool hasn't been there the last few times and the other staff isn't as attentive to their guests.
Mike & Alexis Updyke
We showed up at about 6:30p didn’t get food until after 7:30p there until after 8:30pThis was just the apps, one was the wrong app, meat potstickers when vegetable ones were ordered. Fried cauliflower was fantastic highlight of the evening other than company. The sign at the door showed a tomato bisque. When our main food came they brought out a different opinion with no conversation they didn’t have that prior. Steak meals had an odd texture and left stomachs upset. Servers were serving and tending bar. Our server was friendly but offended when we apologized for them being under staffed. Overall hope it was just an understaffed off night and kitchen isn't always as slow. One major recommendation is turn tvs down as it was so loud.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Cauliflower Bites
Elizabeth Carpenter
Underrated, hidden gem. The food here is actually incredible quality, the portions are great. I actually can’t get over how delicious and well made the food is. I can’t say it enough. I truly don’t think you could order something bad from here. My husband and I were looking for takeout one night, and we found this place via google search and their menu looked interesting, and creative so I figured we’d try it. I had a burger and fries and gravy and he had a fish fry. We split the spicy cheese curds. This food was still immpeccable 30 mins later at home. The gravy is SO good and I highly recommend the cheese curds. We ordered again tonight and again, stellar quality food. I got the KISS chicken sandwich with the bacon slaw. I would rate their food like 12/10. They did forget my salad, but accidents happen, I get it. We are gonna go back in person now. Definitely adding this to our list of go-to dinner places. If you haven’t tried it, you totally should.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brad Arthur
Great place. Friendly staff and good food. Variety of offerings, including vegetarian options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cauliflower Bites, Toutine
Tara Triana
I have been a handful of times and each time has been a lot of fun. The menu is diverse with something for everybody and the quality of their food is exceptional! The "regulars" are welcoming and very friendly. From live bands to trivia there is always something fun going on. If you're looking for a new place to go with great food and the opporunity to make new friends, I encourge you to try The Old Stone Tavern!
Parking: The parking lot is directly next to the tavern and there is also on-street parking avialable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Salt & Vinegar Wings
Kasim Wallace
By far the worse service I have ever experienced. My friends and I waited for nearly 2 hours for service while others who came after us were served with priority. Mind you, we were one of the only minority groups there. The manager told me I was lying when I checked in about the wait time and even provoked a woman having a mental health crisis. Would never eat here again. And I work in the service industry, I have a lot of patience and grace, but this was outrageous. 0/10.
Loved it here! Delicious burgers, must go back to try more of their food!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Greg Marshall
We come to Old Stone Tavern every few weeks. Owner is on site 90% of time. Every item we’ve had has been excellent. Sometimes “medium” is too well or rare. Prices are great. Atmosphere bright, safe, friendly. Chicken fingers are crazy good. Steak salad, pizza, wings and burgers have been great. Good parking and great hours. Recommend for any age, group or family.
Dylan Volk
Came to visit from out of town. Food was garbage, service wasn’t anything special, and beer options were not too good either. The girl on bar was busy with the whole restaurant so it wasn’t her fault. The bun on my smash burger was too small for the patties and the patty itself was burnt asf. Sauces were trash. Sincerely disappointed on my last day in Rochester.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
alex baer
My wife and I have been eating here for years. We just ordered in for the night and it was something special. Incredible fry job on the katsu and buffalo chicken salad. Old Stone has historically had a really solid kitchen but god damn this was even a step above the usual
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: The Stone Steak Burger, Spicy Honey Personal Pizza
A great place for a fish fry
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
food was good quality and came out fast, we waited at least 20 minutes for the check after we called her over to get the check. when she came back she gave us someone else’s credit card and did not give us our check, waited another few minutes didn’t get our check so I had to give her some cash because we had been there too long. also overheard complaints from other customers about missing food and long wait times
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
My boyfriend and I ordered food from them from DoorDash tonight. Our delivery driver got there and waited for our food. Somehow they gave our food away to the wrong person and when DoorDash asked them to remake our food for us they refused. Not many other places are open this late to order food. We have never ordered from here before and are very disappointed with this experience. We likely won’t order from them again.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Sometimes it's fun, sometimes you get ignored. Hit or miss. The bartender that was really cool hasn't been there the last few times and the other staff isn't as attentive to their guests.
We showed up at about 6:30p didn’t get food until after 7:30p there until after 8:30pThis was just the apps, one was the wrong app, meat potstickers when vegetable ones were ordered. Fried cauliflower was fantastic highlight of the evening other than company. The sign at the door showed a tomato bisque. When our main food came they brought out a different opinion with no conversation they didn’t have that prior. Steak meals had an odd texture and left stomachs upset. Servers were serving and tending bar. Our server was friendly but offended when we apologized for them being under staffed. Overall hope it was just an understaffed off night and kitchen isn't always as slow. One major recommendation is turn tvs down as it was so loud.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Cauliflower Bites
Underrated, hidden gem. The food here is actually incredible quality, the portions are great. I actually can’t get over how delicious and well made the food is. I can’t say it enough. I truly don’t think you could order something bad from here. My husband and I were looking for takeout one night, and we found this place via google search and their menu looked interesting, and creative so I figured we’d try it. I had a burger and fries and gravy and he had a fish fry. We split the spicy cheese curds. This food was still immpeccable 30 mins later at home. The gravy is SO good and I highly recommend the cheese curds. We ordered again tonight and again, stellar quality food. I got the KISS chicken sandwich with the bacon slaw. I would rate their food like 12/10. They did forget my salad, but accidents happen, I get it. We are gonna go back in person now. Definitely adding this to our list of go-to dinner places. If you haven’t tried it, you totally should.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place. Friendly staff and good food. Variety of offerings, including vegetarian options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cauliflower Bites, Toutine
I have been a handful of times and each time has been a lot of fun. The menu is diverse with something for everybody and the quality of their food is exceptional! The "regulars" are welcoming and very friendly. From live bands to trivia there is always something fun going on. If you're looking for a new place to go with great food and the opporunity to make new friends, I encourge you to try The Old Stone Tavern!
Parking: The parking lot is directly next to the tavern and there is also on-street parking avialable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Salt & Vinegar Wings
By far the worse service I have ever experienced. My friends and I waited for nearly 2 hours for service while others who came after us were served with priority. Mind you, we were one of the only minority groups there. The manager told me I was lying when I checked in about the wait time and even provoked a woman having a mental health crisis. Would never eat here again. And I work in the service industry, I have a lot of patience and grace, but this was outrageous. 0/10.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Smash burgers are phenomenal!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Great menu and it was all very good
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loved it here! Delicious burgers, must go back to try more of their food!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We come to Old Stone Tavern every few weeks. Owner is on site 90% of time. Every item we’ve had has been excellent. Sometimes “medium” is too well or rare. Prices are great. Atmosphere bright, safe, friendly. Chicken fingers are crazy good. Steak salad, pizza, wings and burgers have been great. Good parking and great hours. Recommend for any age, group or family.
Came to visit from out of town. Food was garbage, service wasn’t anything special, and beer options were not too good either. The girl on bar was busy with the whole restaurant so it wasn’t her fault. The bun on my smash burger was too small for the patties and the patty itself was burnt asf. Sauces were trash. Sincerely disappointed on my last day in Rochester.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
My wife and I have been eating here for years. We just ordered in for the night and it was something special. Incredible fry job on the katsu and buffalo chicken salad. Old Stone has historically had a really solid kitchen but god damn this was even a step above the usual
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: The Stone Steak Burger, Spicy Honey Personal Pizza
Loading...