Tom & Nancy's Pizza

423 Stone Rd, Rochester
(585) 663-1274

Recent Reviews

Ed Starowicz

Great pizza & wings. Asked for thin crust cheese and pepperoni. The sauce flavor was wonderful.Wings were medium and nicely done.Parking: Located on the corner so parking is good but leaving can be tricky as the sight line of cars coming from the corner may surprise you.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Pepperoni Pizza

Quahmeik Harrell

Pizza is great, but customer service is bad the fat miserable guy in there bad for business. They lost a customer!!

Service: 1

Ronald J Houlihan

Best pizza, I've never been disappointed with the quality of the food I've

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, White Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza

Rosie Tantalo Moore

Best pizza place around. Wish there were more.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Linda Zuhlke

Asked for extra cheese,didn't look like extra cheese,I love their pizza,but very displeased, when I called to complain, they dismissed my complaint,won't be ordering there anymore!

Food: 2

Jim Abel

Was my favorite pizza for over 50 years.It’s my first stop off the plane from Phoenix ever since moving 20 years ago… making my annual stop.Sunday I made my annual trip to Tom and Nancy’s and it’s nowhere not even close to what it once was… it was a tasteless horrible pizza.I’m done.

Michael Feeney

Love the pizza here, they definitely use quality ingredients, prices are reasonable, I use to go here about once a week for years until I moved a few years back I’ve never once gotten bad food from here it’s always consistent, I just wish they were open later I now live and work on the other side of the city, hard to get over there in time but I get it, everyone is closing earlier nowadays.

Tracy Weimann

Always on que.. pepperoni is awesome. It doesn't matter what kind of pizza you get...#1 the best!!!!

Amy

Just found Tom and Nancy's again after years of thinking they closed, they just moved. Best pizza ever! Highly recommend.

Betty Paola

Best pizza! No short cuts taken here. All made from scrap. They have the years of experience and know how to do a pizza right. Only mad that I haven't lived here my whole life to enjoy. If you haven't tried then you must. If you do your gonna miss out on some serious good pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

steelbreach

The counter people really don't listen to the orders or they really don't care. I have ordered a lot and I tip the drivers good just to always get my order wrong.

Emmy vlogs

Best pizza I've had in a very long time!

Mary Ann C.

Good saucey pizza! Definitely in my top 5. The counter staff can be hit or miss with personality but the pizza is good!

Dan Cignarale

Been coming here since birth. Definately my fave

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Frank Alfano

Pizza cheese pepperoni and mushrooms

Load More