Gatsby's Landing

1362 Old Northern Blvd, Roslyn
(516) 277-2318

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kraig

Quaint spot in Roslyn. Service was great - very friendly and cordial staff. Good American fare with lots of options!

Radha

Came for 83rd birthday for my mom in a wheelchair. They were so kind and helpful. Nothing was a problem for them to accommodate! We took our time and enjoyed a delicious lunch. Seat by the window in back was amazing for view of geese, ducks, and a swan in the pond. Ordered off of prix fixe and regular menu. Drinks were great too. Thank you for making it such a nice and delicious experience.

Phil

An early New Year's Eve dinner, terrific service and a delicious dinner. Always a tree at Gatsby's Landing!

Syng-Yon

Great Christmas dinner. All the foods were delicious with generous portion. We ordered wine, oysters, pasta, pork chop, burger and branzino. Everything was great!

Barbara

I ordered the salmon. It was cooked perfectly. It came with roasted vegetables which were delicious. There were freshly baked rolls that were hot and crispy.

Mary

Absolutely delicious I had the fig flatbread and upside down eggplant. Followed by the homemade pasta special. Staff was attentive and looking at the pind is beautiful. Highly recommend

Maureen

Our waiter was wonderful. The food was delicious and of course we had a pretty view of the pond. Our gathering of old friends was perfect!

LORI

OYSTERS, CRISPY CALAMARI AND CRAB CAKE WERE ALL DELICIOUS! AND, I HAD A PERFECT GREY GOOSE COSMO! WONDERFUL INTERMEZZO BRUNCH/ LUNCH!!

Sal

Excellent service. Food was okay to good. A bit heavy on the salt. Ordered the halibut and my wife had a pasta dish. Drinks were a bit steep, especially when 2/3 of the drink is ice. Four drinks totaled $76. Other than that it was a nice place. Careful parking on the street. Unbeknownst to me there is metered parking that warrants going to a kiosk. Didn't see the sign and ended up with a $40 ticket.

Jean Nesky

Went w/2 members of my family. Service & food was outstanding. Great atmosphere, congenial bartender, so sweet...attentive servers...Go & discover for yourself. Lava cake to die for.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eugene

We had an amzaing dinner cebebrating our 19th anniversary of our first date. The evening could not have been better. Food, service atmosphere, the best. I highly recommend this restaurant.

Deepnain Kaur

Beautiful setting and nicely decorated interior, which makes for a good first impression. The food, however, was a bit hit or miss, and not always worth the higher prices. Service was friendly, but overall, more style than substance.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Anthony

We went on a particularly rainy day so we practically had the restaurant to ourselves. I'm sure the place is bustling when the weather is nice because the view and ambiance is incredible. Service was fantastic! Our waitress caught wind that it was our anniversary and brought us glasses of champagne to celebrate — and then changed them out for something nonalcoholic when we thanked her but told her we don't drink. What a kind gesture! It made our day! Food is worth the asking price. Everything felt fresh and was delicious. We went home full and happy. We absolutely plan to come back, it'll be our spot for every anniversary.

Terry Lynch

Very nice place in town with a niche style. Food was above average presented sharp. Love the quaint style. Pond in back is a nice touch!! Service was good. Everything was standard but nothing exceptional. Will be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Jay Radano

Great food and nice atmosphere. Service was great and even brought out extra rolls bc they knew we would wanna dip in the sauce. Well done!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...