Gatsby's Landing

1362 Old Northern Blvd, Roslyn
(516) 277-2318

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Robert

We had a delightful meal outside overlooking the pond. Our server, Natalie, was excellent. The only problem with the food was that there was so much! Very generous servings. We also had a nice visit from the manager, Darren. We had had family Thanksgiving at Gatsby's last year, and they did a great job. So highly recommended indoors or out.

Judith

Quaint lovely setting by a pond, small intimate and good service. Not too noisy. Food good lots of choices. We had small plates salads and appetizers, hubby had salmon. All food was quite good. Would recommend especially for couples.

Suzana

Service was great! Food was awesome thought some stuff is on the salty side. Overall very good and will be back.

Dawn

Peaceful outdoor seating overlooking the water. Attentive staff, great service. Branzino was delicious. Definitely worth a trip.

Stacy

Sat on the outdoor patio which was beautiful. Shaded and no bugs. Service was excellent. Food was very good. The worst part was parking. This road is packed and small municipal lot was full. Had to drive around which takes some enjoyment away as we had to rush to make reservation time. But for food/service testing all was very good. We'd come back and add more time for parking next time.

Meryl

The view from the deck can't be beat. Our server Marcos was very cordial, attentive and had a 'can do' attitude. The menu options for lunch were varied, we chose sandwiches plus a watermelon with feta salad to share. All portions were generous, food quality was first rate.

Ellen

A lovely evening at gatsbys landing. Drinks and dinner were delicious and service top notch.

Saudia

Incredible experience for Easter. We went for lunch and enjoyed and early dinner menu. The service was excellent, waiter consistently checked in and there wasn't a long wait time for drinks or food. We had oysters, & grilled octopus as appetizers and duck & lamb chops for the entrees. Everything was delicious and seafood was so fresh!

William

Just a wonderful dining experience-great menu, service, location, and quality/preparation of meal. From appetizers to desert - just a lovely meal. Pasta dishes were superb.

Shelley

Server was terrific! Price fixe a good lunch value for fancy/cozy dining! We will be back!

Scott

The food was so good! Had the baked clams and halibut and could not have been more flavorful!

Susan

Yes I just ate there last week! But what can I say it's my favorite restaurant and luckily for me in my neighborhood! Gatsby's never disappoints! The food is always fresh and full of flavor, the staff are so friendly and attentive. It was my son's birthday so no better place to celebrate. Even my grandchildren love it!! It's been consistently great in every way! I often order delivery as well and it's just as delicious! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Steve

As always, Gatsby's does not disappoint. Even on a gloomy day, the view was nice from inside, and the food continues to be of the highest level and creativity. Could not be better.

Susan

Gatsbys is my go to! Def my favorite. The food is always great as is the service, great atmosphere.

Maria

We went here to celebrate a birthday. The appetizers were out of this world. We ordered fried calamari and baked clams, and ordered a special which a bruschetta that was toasted, with burrata, prosciutto, fig and drizzled with honey. For main course, we ordered the lamb chops which were cooked to perfection. The farro and cherry drizzle were superb.

Loading...