Bell & Anchor

3253 Noyack Rd, Sag Harbor
(631) 725-3400

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jennifer

Best place in the Hamptons. The food is fantastic Service is wonderful. You just can't go wrong here ever.

Vincent

Great selections on the menu. Portion sizes are just enough. Service is impeccable. Noise level is tolerable...can converse with table mates comfortably. Great value for the money.

David

B&A is an old stand by for us. The food is always incredibly good and the menu changes seasonally. They always have certain customer favorites, like the pork chop. The food is only surpassed by the friendly and professional service! This is truly one of the better restaurants in the Hamptons. They are without a doubt consistently good! David G

Suzi

I was absolutely amazed at how beautiful it was once we walked in. The facade is completely different and the inside, amazing. Service was excellent, food outstanding! We will definitely be back!! Thank you for an enjoyable and lovely evening!

Jane

Terrific food both in quality and selection. Lovely waiter on a very busy night. Well done

Susan

Usually our dining experience is very positive at the Bell and Anchor. This time we had several issues. The drinks we ordered - blood orange margarita and Oaxaca old fashioned - weren't good at all. The margarita was extremely bitter and the old fashioned tasted strongly of artificial smoke. My husband's filet mignon had gristle in it while mine was very undercooked. The staff were all pleasant. The noise level was intense; I had a hard time maintaining a conversation. We will go back, but we were disappointed this time around.

ayhan

We enjoyed a wonderful dinner with our friends.. Staff was very friendly and engaging.. Great local spots all year around..

Jean-Yves

Wonderful dining experience, as usual. The bouillabaisse was outstanding, as were the tuna tacos.

A

Great meal as always, so happy the flounder francese is on the menu, it's a favorite of mine!

Nicola

Wonderful local restaurant that I visit often. The manager, Jonathan, is always very helpful. The menu offers many options and the food is always very good.

Margaret

Staff is always attentive and knowledgeable. Food is consistently delicious year after year. Nice to see some of the Beacon menu offerings made it over to Bell & Anchor this year too.

Michelle

Bell and Anchor has never disappointed me; I have been enjoying it for many years. Every meal is a delicious experience, and I always look forward to being there. I live in the Hamptons full-time, and it is my favorite, my go-to restaurant year-round.

roger

My wife and I have been dining at Bell and Anchor ever since it opened many years ago. We ate there last night, and, as always, the service was friendly, professional and impeccable - the food was creative, abundant and truly delicious - the lovely decor and lighting make the room the most comfortable to dine in... The positives about Bell and Anchor are timeless, and we always recommend it to our friends who might have passed it by. You are guaranteed a memorable evening! Roger Cooper

Tracy

It was absolutely amazing. We were very early for our scheduled reservation. But they sat us right away.

Gwen

Wonderful food. Charming and cozy interior that belies the exterior. Food is delicious from apps to mains to dessert. A place to go back to again and again.

Loading...