Big Olaf

Wharf St, Sag Harbor
(631) 725-7505

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Alessandra Delacruz

Thanks for having a vegan ice cream flavor! It was great - salted caramel. Also have a vegan lemon sorbet.

Tess Amiria (Tessie)

Incredible flavours! Big sizes and we went back again the next day!

Tammey Graham

Delicious ice cream. Taste is very consistent and great customer service.

Simon Bacarella

Olafs is an ice cream shop that I frequent every summer. Loved this place but the last 2 yrs has been disappointing. Last weekend our server had the biggest attitude, some young kid who looked like he just did not wan to be there. There was 5 of us and everyone said why does e have an attitude.
I told him numerous times to put lids on the ice cream and he mumbled something under his breath and started slamming the cups of ice cream on the counter. It was not a good experience. Also I've brought this up to staff for 2yrs and no one listens, raise the temperature on the hot fudge warmer. It has been 2 yrs of cold fudge. Very disappointed.

Murat Tutak

Best treat when you are in town.

Ari Martell

Cash only, asked for atm and get answer was “sorry it’s broken you can go the bank”

Cash only means they don’t care to gain customers.

Mason Horn

Always a nice way to end your meal

Dimitri Kontogiannopoulos

Great local staple. CASH ONLY!!!

alan ascencio

Best ice cream shop on the east end.

J N (Jenny)

Best hot fudge I’ve had in a long time!

Mary M

The best vegan ice cream

Jason Kempner

Like the Lizzy Mcguire song, this is what dreams are made of

Michael Ruesga Kohler

Really good ice cream and the best in-house made waffle cones! During high season, the line can get long but it moves and it’s a great place to meet other people as the line moves along. For those that complain about the long line, please stay where you are and don’t come to the east end.

Lori Chavez

Big Olaf is open Monday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday until 9, closed Tuesday and Wednesday

Simon Glyzewski

Ice cream ok, nothing to write home about, though. Dissappointed about customer service. I visited on 9/7/24 in the evening, staff refused to add another scoop to one cone that we got without counting it as a brand new cone before we even paid and left. A good place would have just added it on the side without any discussion. Little things like that make you not feel appreciated as a customer.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Loading...