My first purchase at Carissa’s was four Madelines at $2.50 each. I should have noticed that the shape was off. They were over baked. and very dry . I am sure that most of their offerings are very good. I have heard great things about the breads. I may go back but will not for the Madelines..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
agrippa postumus
they charge 6 dollars for a v good baguette, but that's extremely greedy; 11 dollars for a v good walnut raisin boule, again extreme greed, but what motivates me to write this negative review is then they charge 22 cents for a bag i did not ask for and is literally garbage in quality or reusability. what greed. if baking is you passion, try taking your eye off the lucre.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Martin Kelly
Damn Carissa and her baked goods and sandwiches. They are as expensive as they are incredibly tasty and inventive.I think I have had everything they sell at least twice. Sometimes twenty times.Atmosphere isn't relevant as it is a take out bakery but do your tongue and stomach a favor and try the "anything at all as it's all great".
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anne C.
Love this bakery but do find them wildly inconsistent. Apple turnover's can be flaky and light and filled with apples or thin on apples and very doughy. Grilled cheese sandwiches have been carelessly "grilled" and more like - warmed. When Carissa's is good, it is great, when it is less good, it isn't awful, certainly, but not as good as it could/should be.
Karly DePaz
Nice place for quick bites and more.They have different options to choose from.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MacKenzie G.
What a wonderful bakery. My friend highly recommend this place on our visit to the Hamptons so we visited one of our first mornings. The ambience here is very sleek and beautiful. The service is very friendly and the vegan dessert and drink I got were so unbelievably good. I'm glad that they have options to meet dietary restrictions and my friends and I all left very happy.
TONY MUCI MATTA
Hello everyone! We have the perfect place for you! Prepare to be delighted!Welcome to Carissa's Bakery, the paradise of pastries and fresh coffee! This place is simply magical, friends. Their creations are so tempting that you won't be able to resist trying them all.Let's talk about cakes? My God! Carissa's Bakery has a wide selection that will blow your mind. And best of all, they are made with fresh ingredients, so you can taste a slice of happiness!But that's not all, friends, they have coffee too! Magic words: fresh coffee. Carissa's Bakery serves a coffee so aromatic and smooth that it will transport you to seventh heaven. Nothing better than accompanying your delicious cake with a cup of perfectly prepared coffee. It's a heavenly combination!And best of all, at Carissa's Bakery you will be greeted with a friendly smile. The staff are so charming and attentive that they will make you feel at home. Those little things make a big difference!So now you know, friends, when you're in Sag Harbor, Long Island, you can't miss Carissa's Bakery. Just come in, let yourself be carried away by the delicious aromas and let them seduce you with their irresistible cakes and fresh coffee.That's all folks! I hope I've worked up your appetite and you're already running to Carissa's Bakery in Sag Harbor. See you next time! Stay tasty and don't forget to share this video with your sweet tooth friends. See you soon! MMM!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alessandro Frati
Modern location in Sag Harbor.Nice if you are ordering baked goods to go. Otherwise, you'd better head to their other location since seating is limited/not existing here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Tony del pino
The space is immaculate. The pastries are both delicious and beautiful. The staff are equally as attentive and sweet. The Miso Chocolate Chip cookie is outstanding!
This place looked very clean and modern, almost like a little boutique instead of a bakery. The service was a bit slow as the man in front of me seemed to be waiting for a long time. I ordered the pistachio croissant, almond croissant, and raisin snail. The name of the pistachio croissant was misleading as this should be called a CHOCOLATE pistachio croissant. The pistachio cream filling was not too sweet but I definitely would have preferred just a plain pistachio croissant. The almond croissant had a good taste and the raisin snail met expectations. I wasn't blown away by the selections but it was very good to try while in Sag Harbor.
Samantha H.
Carissa's is my favorite treat in Sag Harbor! I always get the zucchini sandwich and had the pleasure of trying this pistachio chocolate croissant on my last visit. Absolutely beautiful store inside with friendly service. Restroom not technically available to customers and not really any seating except a bench to wait.
Kathrin Lausch
LOVE ?
Allison Spitzer
The epi baguette and focaccia are to die for. So so good. Would love to have an almond milk cappuccino option
Paige C
It was just ok, nothing exciting. Monkey bread was pretty dry, lattes were very milky/watered down.
Fůċķĩňğg
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My first purchase at Carissa’s was four Madelines at $2.50 each. I should have noticed that the shape was off. They were over baked. and very dry . I am sure that most of their offerings are very good. I have heard great things about the breads. I may go back but will not for the Madelines..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
they charge 6 dollars for a v good baguette, but that's extremely greedy; 11 dollars for a v good walnut raisin boule, again extreme greed, but what motivates me to write this negative review is then they charge 22 cents for a bag i did not ask for and is literally garbage in quality or reusability. what greed. if baking is you passion, try taking your eye off the lucre.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Damn Carissa and her baked goods and sandwiches. They are as expensive as they are incredibly tasty and inventive.I think I have had everything they sell at least twice. Sometimes twenty times.Atmosphere isn't relevant as it is a take out bakery but do your tongue and stomach a favor and try the "anything at all as it's all great".
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this bakery but do find them wildly inconsistent. Apple turnover's can be flaky and light and filled with apples or thin on apples and very doughy. Grilled cheese sandwiches have been carelessly "grilled" and more like - warmed. When Carissa's is good, it is great, when it is less good, it isn't awful, certainly, but not as good as it could/should be.
Nice place for quick bites and more.They have different options to choose from.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What a wonderful bakery. My friend highly recommend this place on our visit to the Hamptons so we visited one of our first mornings. The ambience here is very sleek and beautiful. The service is very friendly and the vegan dessert and drink I got were so unbelievably good. I'm glad that they have options to meet dietary restrictions and my friends and I all left very happy.
Hello everyone! We have the perfect place for you! Prepare to be delighted!Welcome to Carissa's Bakery, the paradise of pastries and fresh coffee! This place is simply magical, friends. Their creations are so tempting that you won't be able to resist trying them all.Let's talk about cakes? My God! Carissa's Bakery has a wide selection that will blow your mind. And best of all, they are made with fresh ingredients, so you can taste a slice of happiness!But that's not all, friends, they have coffee too! Magic words: fresh coffee. Carissa's Bakery serves a coffee so aromatic and smooth that it will transport you to seventh heaven. Nothing better than accompanying your delicious cake with a cup of perfectly prepared coffee. It's a heavenly combination!And best of all, at Carissa's Bakery you will be greeted with a friendly smile. The staff are so charming and attentive that they will make you feel at home. Those little things make a big difference!So now you know, friends, when you're in Sag Harbor, Long Island, you can't miss Carissa's Bakery. Just come in, let yourself be carried away by the delicious aromas and let them seduce you with their irresistible cakes and fresh coffee.That's all folks! I hope I've worked up your appetite and you're already running to Carissa's Bakery in Sag Harbor. See you next time! Stay tasty and don't forget to share this video with your sweet tooth friends. See you soon! MMM!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Modern location in Sag Harbor.Nice if you are ordering baked goods to go. Otherwise, you'd better head to their other location since seating is limited/not existing here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
The space is immaculate. The pastries are both delicious and beautiful. The staff are equally as attentive and sweet. The Miso Chocolate Chip cookie is outstanding!
Restaurantji Recommends
This place looked very clean and modern, almost like a little boutique instead of a bakery. The service was a bit slow as the man in front of me seemed to be waiting for a long time. I ordered the pistachio croissant, almond croissant, and raisin snail. The name of the pistachio croissant was misleading as this should be called a CHOCOLATE pistachio croissant. The pistachio cream filling was not too sweet but I definitely would have preferred just a plain pistachio croissant. The almond croissant had a good taste and the raisin snail met expectations. I wasn't blown away by the selections but it was very good to try while in Sag Harbor.
Carissa's is my favorite treat in Sag Harbor! I always get the zucchini sandwich and had the pleasure of trying this pistachio chocolate croissant on my last visit. Absolutely beautiful store inside with friendly service. Restroom not technically available to customers and not really any seating except a bench to wait.
LOVE ?
The epi baguette and focaccia are to die for. So so good. Would love to have an almond milk cappuccino option
It was just ok, nothing exciting. Monkey bread was pretty dry, lattes were very milky/watered down.