Been awhile since last visit. Bartender remembered us. Made room for a seat. All good. Great experience
Heather Rocco
The food and service were great! We had our dog so we sat on the patio and it was a little loud. But other than that we would definitely come back. Give the Rachel sandwich a try.
Stefan Elm
They move quick here and the food was good.
Barbara Manning
It's an old school bar and restaurant with large portions and damn good food. I've been here several times throughout the decades, and it is consistently good food. It's97 right that it should be on the corner because it is a cornerstone of the restaurant culture in Sag Harbor. Stop by for the full lunch or dinner experience. Bring your friends and share what's at the table.
Undercover Astrology
04/12/25
Small local bar with good food. It was a chilly night and I stopped in for a bowl of chowder ($10) and a drink, which the server never came back to take my drink order. So all I had was a glass of water that was brought with my soup. I was unable to find the young man who took my order and brought my food when I was ready to pay and leave.
Jeemin Lee
idk why people would leave bad reviews. like
Are you sure?
maybe this time you'll learn
try the turkey club
Thomas “The Critic” Schiavoni
My Conrer bar experience was splendid. Every bite of my food was mouth watering. I was served by a strong and charismatic fellow with a US WWII graffiti tattoo on his arm and his accomplice which sported the Viltrumite mustache and striking aura to follow. I would recommend this fine establishment to anyone seeing to add a significant amount of spice in their life. Not to mention, the Long Island Ice tea Corner burger combo is to die for.
Sincerely, The Consumable Critic
Tanya Layburn
Deliscious burgers and amazing onion soup! Great service too!!!
WhatsInThePan
Food. Amazing. Oysters were some of the best we ever had. Lobster rolls - oh yes! I had a burger which I also recommend.
Service. Fast and efficient. The guys were a little too impersonal but fast.
Atmosphere. It’s a tight space but we had plenty of room at our table. We were there the day after Christmas and fully enjoyed ourselves.
Everything you want in a bar; great food and drinks at reasonable prices. Friendly service and low background bar chatter provide a nice atmosphere. My Burger hit the spot.
Robert Varcoe
A great local joint which never disappoints.. Unusual in these environs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
rajesh singh
Great service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David E
Food was great. Very tasty and good portions. The Monday afternoon frat boy wait staff however, was far more interested in socializing together than waiting tables.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Beer Bartered Cod Fish N Chips
claudia
Creepy old man staring at me and my girlfriends, bartender encouraged him and basically kicked us out of the bar by making us feel uncomfortable. If you want quiet and a classy atmosphere, get out of the dive bar
Been awhile since last visit.
Bartender remembered us.
Made room for a seat.
All good.
Great experience
The food and service were great! We had our dog so we sat on the patio and it was a little loud. But other than that we would definitely come back. Give the Rachel sandwich a try.
They move quick here and the food was good.
It's an old school bar and restaurant with large portions and damn good food. I've been here several times throughout the decades, and it is consistently good food. It's97 right that it should be on the corner because it is a cornerstone of the restaurant culture in Sag Harbor. Stop by for the full lunch or dinner experience. Bring your friends and share what's at the table.
04/12/25
Small local bar with good food. It was a chilly night and I stopped in for a bowl of chowder ($10) and a drink, which the server never came back to take my drink order. So all I had was a glass of water that was brought with my soup. I was unable to find the young man who took my order and brought my food when I was ready to pay and leave.
idk why people would leave bad reviews. like
Are you sure?
maybe this time you'll learn
try the turkey club
My Conrer bar experience was splendid. Every bite of my food was mouth watering. I was served by a strong and charismatic fellow with a US WWII graffiti tattoo on his arm and his accomplice which sported the Viltrumite mustache and striking aura to follow. I would recommend this fine establishment to anyone seeing to add a significant amount of spice in their life. Not to mention, the Long Island Ice tea Corner burger combo is to die for.
Sincerely,
The Consumable Critic
Deliscious burgers and amazing onion soup! Great service too!!!
Food. Amazing. Oysters were some of the best we ever had. Lobster rolls - oh yes! I had a burger which I also recommend.
Service. Fast and efficient. The guys were a little too impersonal but fast.
Atmosphere. It’s a tight space but we had plenty of room at our table. We were there the day after Christmas and fully enjoyed ourselves.
We’ll be back!
Excellent food and service
Restaurantji Recommends
Everything you want in a bar; great food and drinks at reasonable prices. Friendly service and low background bar chatter provide a nice atmosphere. My Burger hit the spot.
A great local joint which never disappoints..
Unusual in these environs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was great. Very tasty and good portions. The Monday afternoon frat boy wait staff however, was far more interested in socializing together than waiting tables.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Beer Bartered Cod Fish N Chips
Creepy old man staring at me and my girlfriends, bartender encouraged him and basically kicked us out of the bar by making us feel uncomfortable. If you want quiet and a classy atmosphere, get out of the dive bar
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Loading...