We stumbled upon this place (not really though we love it here) a night that Jocelyn/Josslyn? was working and it couldn’t of gone better. I asked for a tequila recommendation and she put us on to a new liquor I’ve never enjoyed like it before. We left the bar we were at 3 times just to come back to her. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patty Westenbroek
My husband and I enjoyed a delicious calamari appetizer prior to visiting the community theatre across the street. We experienced great service. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vito DeMola
A very enjoyable hole in the wall with a very old school and welcoming feel.
We sat at the bar where our bartender was very helpful and attentive. We were immediately offered drinks and menus as well as explained the specials of the day.
All of the food was delicious, the drinks were cold, and we had great seats.
It’s not an uppity townie spot, it’s got a very local waterfront feel like you want to stop in for some beers after a long day of fishing.
If you want to avoid snobby tourists, this is your spot.
If you don’t want to be ripped off and pay tourist prices, this is your spot.
Definitely a fan.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Loftin
Not much of a draft menu. If your into liquor drinks probably a good place for you. Took forever to get a seat and the place was empty
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 3
Anthony Gonzalez
Surprise with their chili and cod bites, very good. I would stop by here again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joel Mariano
I had a great experience - I was visit from out of state and after some late night drinks, I forgot my jacket there. I called days later and the manager Jennifer promptly shipped it to me (and paid for shipping!). THANKS SO MUCH for your kindness and hope to visit again!!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Rene M.
Great establishment and vibes ... Sadly got ill from the food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
James Hain
Been awhile since last visit. Bartender remembered us. Made room for a seat. All good. Great experience
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Heather Rocco
The food and service were great! We had our dog so we sat on the patio and it was a little loud. But other than that we would definitely come back. Give the Rachel sandwich a try.
It's an old school bar and restaurant with large portions and damn good food. I've been here several times throughout the decades, and it is consistently good food. It's97 right that it should be on the corner because it is a cornerstone of the restaurant culture in Sag Harbor. Stop by for the full lunch or dinner experience. Bring your friends and share what's at the table.
Undercover Astrology
04/12/25
Small local bar with good food. It was a chilly night and I stopped in for a bowl of chowder ($10) and a drink, which the server never came back to take my drink order. So all I had was a glass of water that was brought with my soup. I was unable to find the young man who took my order and brought my food when I was ready to pay and leave.
Jeemin Lee
idk why people would leave bad reviews. like
Are you sure?
maybe this time you'll learn
try the turkey club
Thomas “The Critic” Schiavoni
My Conrer bar experience was splendid. Every bite of my food was mouth watering. I was served by a strong and charismatic fellow with a US WWII graffiti tattoo on his arm and his accomplice which sported the Viltrumite mustache and striking aura to follow. I would recommend this fine establishment to anyone seeing to add a significant amount of spice in their life. Not to mention, the Long Island Ice tea Corner burger combo is to die for.
Sincerely, The Consumable Critic
Tanya Layburn
Deliscious burgers and amazing onion soup! Great service too!!!
We stumbled upon this place (not really though we love it here) a night that Jocelyn/Josslyn? was working and it couldn’t of gone better. I asked for a tequila recommendation and she put us on to a new liquor I’ve never enjoyed like it before. We left the bar we were at 3 times just to come back to her. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I enjoyed a delicious calamari appetizer prior to visiting the community theatre across the street. We experienced great service. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A very enjoyable hole in the wall with a very old school and welcoming feel.
We sat at the bar where our bartender was very helpful and attentive. We were immediately offered drinks and menus as well as explained the specials of the day.
All of the food was delicious, the drinks were cold, and we had great seats.
It’s not an uppity townie spot, it’s got a very local waterfront feel like you want to stop in for some beers after a long day of fishing.
If you want to avoid snobby tourists, this is your spot.
If you don’t want to be ripped off and pay tourist prices, this is your spot.
Definitely a fan.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not much of a draft menu. If your into liquor drinks probably a good place for you. Took forever to get a seat and the place was empty
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 3
Surprise with their chili and cod bites, very good. I would stop by here again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had a great experience - I was visit from out of state and after some late night drinks, I forgot my jacket there. I called days later and the manager Jennifer promptly shipped it to me (and paid for shipping!). THANKS SO MUCH for your kindness and hope to visit again!!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Great establishment and vibes ... Sadly got ill from the food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Been awhile since last visit.
Bartender remembered us.
Made room for a seat.
All good.
Great experience
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food and service were great! We had our dog so we sat on the patio and it was a little loud. But other than that we would definitely come back. Give the Rachel sandwich a try.
They move quick here and the food was good.
Restaurantji Recommends
It's an old school bar and restaurant with large portions and damn good food. I've been here several times throughout the decades, and it is consistently good food. It's97 right that it should be on the corner because it is a cornerstone of the restaurant culture in Sag Harbor. Stop by for the full lunch or dinner experience. Bring your friends and share what's at the table.
04/12/25
Small local bar with good food. It was a chilly night and I stopped in for a bowl of chowder ($10) and a drink, which the server never came back to take my drink order. So all I had was a glass of water that was brought with my soup. I was unable to find the young man who took my order and brought my food when I was ready to pay and leave.
idk why people would leave bad reviews. like
Are you sure?
maybe this time you'll learn
try the turkey club
My Conrer bar experience was splendid. Every bite of my food was mouth watering. I was served by a strong and charismatic fellow with a US WWII graffiti tattoo on his arm and his accomplice which sported the Viltrumite mustache and striking aura to follow. I would recommend this fine establishment to anyone seeing to add a significant amount of spice in their life. Not to mention, the Long Island Ice tea Corner burger combo is to die for.
Sincerely,
The Consumable Critic
Deliscious burgers and amazing onion soup! Great service too!!!
Loading...