Goldberg's Famous Bagels
1742 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Sag Harbor
(631) 808-3029
Customers' Favorites
Bacon Egg and Cheese
Ham Egg and Cheese
Bagels
Menu
Photos
Recent Reviews
I’ve been in here several times. I’ve never experienced an incorrect order. Bagels are always delicious and I always take 2 dozen to go to take back to Kentucky. They freeze and defrost well and are delicious every time!
Absolutely, the best bagel place on the island. The bagels are very good and their flagels are to die for. I'm a huge fan of the chicken salad and egg salad. Sandwiches are always packed with meat. Staff is very friendly as well.
This place is fine except for one thing I noticed: when you order lox and bagel, they don't use regular cream cheese; they use cream cheese SPREAD. I don't know whether this is a short-cut (easier and faster to smear on the bagel or whether it's cheaper. Regardless, I don't like it. I like regular cream cheese. It has a different taste and texture from the spread.
You May Also Like
Estia's Little Kitchen - 1615 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike
![]()
Latin American, Seafood, New Mexican Cuisine, Vegan
Goldberg’s Famous Bagels - 111 Main St
![]()
Brunch, Bagels