Jimmy Jims Deli

3348 Noyack Rd, Sag Harbor
(631) 725-1930

Recent Reviews

Mark II

the best organic juices you can find in

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Avocado Sandwich, Long Islander Hero, Chicken Cutlet, Steak Burrito

t.j. m.

The Noyack is their tuna melt- get it on a baguette. Great GREAT bread here. I ordered a meaty sandwich (Italian I think) and it wasn't great. So choose your sandwich wisely. I look forward to coming back for their Cuban sandwich. Great breakfast options too!!

M O.

LocAl secret. absolutely the best, fresh food , juices are served. the pleasant staff makes this spot even better! love the avocado toast.

Hilario Alvarez

Not my favorite but I like this place.

John B.

Ordered breakfast sandwiches and they were super tasty. The egg salad was exceptionally good. Only downside was that it was a tad expensive. But then again pretty much on par with everything else out here. Staff we're friendly as well.

Anjali B.

Stopped by here yesterday morning before heading to the beach to eat our breakfast. We called ahead and picked up 3 "house" breakfast burritos and 3 iced coffees. The coffee was actually very good, your classic deli coffee. The burritos were yummy, consisting of peppers, cheese, eggs, sausage, all wrapped together in a white wrap. They said it would take 15 minutes on the phone but we arrived 10 minutes later and everything was ready to go. Now they definitely don't stand at deli prices but it is cheaper than most other Hamptons breakfast options. I would return, also because I love their acai bowl. Service is also consistently quick and polite, this wasn't a one time experience, as I can now more honestly review since I have been going here for quite a while. Usually opting for the acai bowl, but now after this positive experience I am open to trying more off of the menu.

Gabe Gabe

Great place to get food , sag harbor Jimmy Jim’s

Gabe Geovanny

Smoothies & açaí bowls are fresh made on the go !! Yum

F G.

Great sandwich lunch menu. Sandwiches are head & shoulders better than Cromer's & on the same street.

Sage A

I’m a local and honestly love going here but the prices have just gotten way too expensive ): pricier than any of the places nearby as well.

Alex Andra

I’m a local and honestly love going here but the prices have just gotten way too expensive ): pricier than any of the places nearby as well.

Michael Arocho

Best Acai Bowls I’ve ever had.

Will Shapiro

Legit best sandwich in the Hamptons - #36 w Bacon. Not your average deli....

rockyschnorkville

Beware. Reading the posted menu on the board, every sandwich is about $10. But if you get anything that’s not on the board, like a roll instead of bread, expect a $2.50 up charge. Crazy and maybe illegal.

Mike Anthony

Best Acai Bowls I’ve ever had.

Load More