eLTacobar

62 Main St, Sag Harbor
(631) 899-4646

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Laura Levine

The waiter never told me these burgers were loaded with salt and pepper corns .
They gave me another burger without but still charged me for the first burger loaded with salt /small pepper corns

Dimitri Kontogiannopoulos

Delicious burger, and fries, very well priced for the location.

Morgan Berger

Not sure why they got rid of the normal burgers and switched to smash burgers.

Matthew Rosario

I used to go to this place a few years ago and it was my favorite, but since they reopened it feels like a completely new place trying to capitalize on a popular old name.

The apps were good, but the thing that used to be amazing (the burgers) are all just okay now.

I was super excited to see one of my favorite places come back, but unfortunately the burgers are pretty boring. (Not every burger needs to be smashed).

Staff were nice, and responsive but this new version of LT burger is not something I would recommend. Especially for the price.

Andy Toso

The manager is awful Charlie the worse he stop us to have fun just because super disappointed really 😖😖

lynn rhodes

Sat at the bar,first visit back since opening.Feels like old times! Had 27East burger.Yes,they are smash burgers-just the right amount of food for a hot summer day!
Cheerful atmosphere!

Saf A

The best part about LT burger was the burgers and for some reason they changed them. What used to be a decent sized, well seasoned patty on a buttered and toasted roll is now a flimsy smash burger on a plain potato bun - still $14 a la carte though. Such a weird decision, especially considering they don’t state on the Menu they’re all smash burgers.
The Gouda fries were still pretty good but I probably wouldn’t go back

Riley Spieler

Food was good but had a few problems with the menu. It was advertised as items came with cheese and then was charged 3$ for cheese on a burger. It also said it was 2$ for bacon and was also charged 3$ for it. Also there were no free refills on a fountain soda, makes no sense. None of this was a big deal it should just be mentioned before we order or mentioned on the menu! I recommend the bleu cheese burger and the gouda fries as well!

Josh Nedelka

This new iteration of LT Burger is now doing smash burgers. They're very good and prices are reasonable. Service was very quick at 8pm on a Saturday.

Koo Cho

Very cute restaurant, attentive service, average food.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

aditya Mangla

Zero stars. They have no chance of being successful with this level of incompetence. Ordered food. Waited an hour. Was told multiple times it ‘would be a few minutes’. This place is amateur hour.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Peter Myers

elTacobar has gluten free items marked on their menu, and most items are marked gluten free. Staff is knowledgeable in answering questions. Be cautious though because my tacos were on the same tray as my fiancée - just happened to be all gluten free even though I am the only one with Celiac. I’m glad that the chips are in a seperate fryer.

Personally, I believe elTacobar is extremely overpriced!! $22 for chips, salsa, and guacamole is ridiculous, especially when most Mexican restaurants include chips & salsa for free. The tacos are small street size and priced around $9 for 1 taco and they require you to order a minimum of 2 tacos. The pricing of this restaurant is a Hamptons tourist trap so I’m not rushing to come back anytime soon!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Patricia Malloy

Taco’s were pure grease !!! The cokes were good but not for the price

Matt Don

Fun and outstanding eatery on Main Street. All of our dishes were tasty, fresh and delicious. We ordered two plates of the chicken quesadillas and they were delightful. The flour tortillas were perfectly prepared and the chicken was juicy and tangy. The shrimp tacos as well as the chipotle cauliflower tacos were equally fresh and delicious. Our server Sallyleonie was exceptionally kind and helpful. Thank you for a wonderful dining experience. Most importantly, El Tacobar is super family friendly!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Neil Issacoff

Worst place I’ve been to eat in years. The server was not professional, she was a young girl and incorrectly took my order, was very rude, rushed us, and did not provide water for the table. The food was not good, I could not finish my order, and the kitchen had been closed so I was unable to order anything else. Additionally, our table was not notified that a 20% auto gratuity was included. Save the hassle and don’t go here, there’s plenty of better restaurants next to it. Also, the bathrooms were disgusting.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...