The food here was fantastic! I highly recommend their steak dinners, especially with their gravy because it is delicious!
I also really liked how clean this place was going in, & how attentive and sweet all the staff were. We had actually just left from a really bad spot and this place saved our night.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt
Had a very good dinner at the bar. Ed is a great bartender, and very welcoming. They had live music going which was a good touch. This is going to be come my local spot since I am new to the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
gay giles
I ordered take-out burger med rare (comes w/fries) and potato skins($44.00).I waited a couple of minutes. The fries were undercooked and cold. The cook on the burger was uneven. The potato skins were a baked potato cut in half with toppings. This lapse in judgment was a clear reminder as to why I stopped eating at MJs
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Elsa C Lorenzo
I like the tropical-like umbrellas and flower pots at their outdoor seating. It’s hopping despite its dishes being pricey in comparison to other restaurants.
Their thin pizza looked very good. Two in our group were satisfied with their salmon. One of us did not finish his hamburger and a fourth ate one of three quesadilla pieces. My crispy fried chicken was a sandwich and a breast.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Wendy
Everything was awesome- food, service & atmosphere. Would definitely go again for their local crust pizza & brick chicken!
Erica
The food is really good. The noise level is ridiculous. They desperately need to find a way to mitigate it.
Leon Katselnik
Amazing Pizzeria in the back!
Food: 5
Sharon
Good pub menu, friendly staff, reasonable prices. Sports bar, and indoor & outdoor dining seating. Very loud was the only negative.
Hope Liquidimagination
A-1 everything. Enjoyable everything, for years. 💯 recommended on all fronts.
Michael
Just a great place to eat in an otherwise fussy Hamptons restaurant world. Good solid food, great service, reasonable pricing and pleasant unpretentious place. Always enjoy eating here!
It's really nice to be a regular there. They always remember us and their food is alway delicious and great value
Robin Austin
Best French onion soup ever. Intimate atmosphere. Great service from George. Wonderful first time experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Saf A
The to go isn’t great. Burger came cold with cheese unmelted and I only live 5 mins away.
HARVEY
Good local tavern for a no frills meal offering a set menu Dailey specials and dinner 3 course early bird specials on weekends A busy bar can be VERY LOUD ! 
Judian TJ Cooney
Love the arugala salad & the wedge!! Always crispie & fresh..
The food here was fantastic! I highly recommend their steak dinners, especially with their gravy because it is delicious!
I also really liked how clean this place was going in, & how attentive and sweet all the staff were. We had actually just left from a really bad spot and this place saved our night.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had a very good dinner at the bar. Ed is a great bartender, and very welcoming. They had live music going which was a good touch. This is going to be come my local spot since I am new to the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered take-out burger med rare (comes w/fries) and potato skins($44.00).I waited a couple of minutes. The fries were undercooked and cold. The cook on the burger was uneven. The potato skins were a baked potato cut in half with toppings. This lapse in judgment was a clear reminder as to why I stopped eating at MJs
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
I like the tropical-like umbrellas and flower pots at their outdoor seating.
It’s hopping despite its dishes being pricey in comparison to other restaurants.
Their thin pizza looked very good. Two in our group were satisfied with their salmon. One of us did not finish his hamburger and a fourth ate one of three quesadilla pieces. My crispy fried chicken was a sandwich and a breast.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Everything was awesome- food, service & atmosphere. Would definitely go again for their local crust pizza & brick chicken!
The food is really good. The noise level is ridiculous. They desperately need to find a way to mitigate it.
Amazing Pizzeria in the back!
Food: 5
Good pub menu, friendly staff, reasonable prices. Sports bar, and indoor & outdoor dining seating. Very loud was the only negative.
A-1 everything. Enjoyable everything, for years. 💯 recommended on all fronts.
Just a great place to eat in an otherwise fussy Hamptons restaurant world. Good solid food, great service, reasonable pricing and pleasant unpretentious place. Always enjoy eating here!
Restaurantji Recommends
It's really nice to be a regular there. They always remember us and their food is alway delicious and great value
Best French onion soup ever.
Intimate atmosphere.
Great service from George.
Wonderful first time experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The to go isn’t great. Burger came cold with cheese unmelted and I only live 5 mins away.
Good local tavern for a no frills meal offering a set menu Dailey specials and dinner 3 course early bird specials on weekends A busy bar can be VERY LOUD ! 
Love the arugala salad & the wedge!! Always crispie & fresh..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...