M.J. Dowling's

3360 Noyack Rd, Sag Harbor
(631) 725-4444

Recent Reviews

Sort by
HARVEY

Good local tavern for a no frills meal offering a set menu Dailey specials and dinner 3 course early bird specials on weekends A busy bar can be VERY LOUD ! 

Kathryn

The food was delicious and hot food arrived hot. Portions are large and the menu has a wide number of selections. The staff is friendly and attentive. The restaurant can be loud with families with children and the bar crowd.

Jo

Dowling's has a variety of choices. Specials were very good. Service was a 10. Bartender great cocktails.. Nice atmosphere. Thank you enjoyed everything...

Antoinette

This is going to become one of our favorite restaurants! The burgers are the best of any neighboring restaurants, the prices are very reasonable, and the atmosphere is perfect. Very happy!

Adam

Definitely an “off night” I'm sorry to say. First time ever in all these years. Tuna appetizer was tasteless & warm. Sent it back. That was a first. Ordered wings instead. They came 5 minutes after ours in dishes. Sauce was diluted & flavor was off. Steak Fajita main was off as well. Guac was thin & tasteless, steak was raw & sour cream was missing. Going to just say it was an off night. Hope this is not a new pattern. Time will tell.

Albert

Party of 6. 5 adults and 1 child. Brought a Birthday cake Danny was our waiter. 4 orders of marinated hanger steak (cooked to perfection each one). One order of the salmon (also perfect) and one kids meal hamburger and fries. 5 orders of Cesar salad with fresh made croutons (delectable). All orders came in a timely fashion with individual preferences adhered to. We weren't rushed ate at our own pace. After main course was cleared they brought out the birthday cake sung “happy birthday “ and served cake and coffee. We then got out PreFixe dessert to go paid and left. Overall fantastic food and a great time. Thank you Mike and our waiter Danny. Highly Recommend. Reasonably Priced Great food

Kevin Tate

Good food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Diver Scallop and Corn App, Cheesecake, Caesar Salad

Kearston Zerzanek

Great spot for casual drinks and food. The boneless wings were tasty and almost like untreated chicken bites, the restrooms were clean, the ambiance was not overly loud. Gluten free options are available and parking is available.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free options available

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings

Tristan Nelson

Terrible experience with MJD. We were visiting friends and stopped to try this restaurant. Our server was friendly but forgot what we asked for several times. Had to ask other employees for sides that we didn't get and more refills that we never got. We ordered 2 steaks in our group. The ribeye was delicious while the filet was inedible. It had a funny smell and taste. We own restaurants, so we tried not to complain, but there was something definitely wrong with this meat. The server took the plate away and said he would speak to the owner. He came back and told us that they wouldn't make another one, nor would they remove it from the bill. If we wanted, we could choose something else on the menu. The server was apologetic, but the owner didn't want to speak with us. When you pay $70 for a meal, you should get what you paid for, not replace it with a $15 order of wings. I'm just disappointed in this restaurant and its crew. I would not recommend this place, not because we didn't get items with our meal but because the owner couldn't be bothered by our complaint. We weren't locals.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 2

Elijah

Great buffalo wings and steak fajitas.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

cold sweat

Place is trash.

Laura J

Highly recommend. Awesome atmosphere and friendly staff. We tried several dishes and none of them disappointed!!! Definitely going back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lisa

We frequently dine at Dowlings. The food is always good and the staff could not be nicer and more accommodating. I have food sensitivities and they work to suite my needs. I love that the staff remains loyal and stays there for years! That says something about the business. The shrimp Po boy is my favorite! Crispy, with delicious sriracha sauce, avocado, tomato and red onion. The specials are always tasty! Last nights lobster rigatoni did not disappoint! We love Dowlings!

Appealing place. It was not especially busy, but we sat for 30 minutes before we could get a server. While waiting, the non-English speaking person who attended our table could not communicate with us or get us attention from a server.

PaulaD

Fantastic burger did not disappoint. The only problem was we went at 6:30. It was very crowded and hard to find a parking space. The restaurant cleared out by seven and had gone at 7:30. There would've been plenty of spaces.

Loading...