M.J. Dowling's

3360 Noyack Rd, Sag Harbor
(631) 725-4444

Recent Reviews

E J.

The food lacks appeal. Mashed potatoes are made from a package. Food is overpriced & poorly made. The service was pushy & rude. The ambiance is nicer than the service.

Joan Holderness

Did not eat here. Just popped in for a

Atmosphere: 3

Service: 4

David Evans

Very good food. Lots of options. Great bartenders. Can be a little pricey. They have excellent pizza, but order the large, which they make on site. The small pizzas are frozen and very different.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

byron arnao

I don't go here for my dining experience /gourmet meals... But I do go here as the quick bite good food local spot that's relatively inexpensive. Great cheesesteak sandwich, a number of other selections on the menu that I've tried over the last year everything is pretty good I haven't found anything that should go wrong with Well other than the wings which I'm not found a place out in the Hamptons yet that equals my own old local spot in New Jersey the Glen Rock inn for wings..

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Michna

This is a great place in the Hamptons. Very real and unpretentious. Service was wonderful and attentive. Basic food is excellent: burgers, salads, sandwiches, etc. And the ambience is really pleasant, mixing the virtues of a good restaurant, a sports bar and friendly pub. Highly recommended!

Nancy T.

Pretty disappointed in my take out order tonight: clam chowder and a Caesar salad= $29.00. The salad was really skimpy and I get twice as much soup and a really good Caesar salad at The Corner Bar for about the same price.

Harvey Saks

Went for dinner with a friend, the service was very good though a little forgetful. I had a thin crust buffalo pizza can only eat half on a nice box to take the other half for the next day's breakfast, what are you going to do on the guy. We had a great evening and would recommend it for a light dinner.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

jon greenberg

Best burger we go here quite often and the people who work are so friendly with the food being great its just

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mini Burgers

Olaes C.

the food was phenomenal! i had a grilled chicken sandwich and it was amazing. the service was great and we barely had to ask for everything or waiter was very quick and nice. there was open mic so live music was playing and i loved it!

Steve Iori

Good food, Excellent service?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

doranne bakiewicz

went here on a mistaken recommendation. the food is horrible. sauerbraten "special" = cheap meat overcooked days earlier then reheated in a microwave; tougher than a pitbull raised on the mean streets, drier than a 7 year drought.With a dollop of (mediocre at best) jar gravy and red cabbage also out of an industrial container. the price? only $35.this is *after* the season,on a tuesday, presumably for locals.. ?One might think the drinks would a good deal ( ie get buzzed enough to eat the food) but a glass of house red is $15 (Alamos Malbec- budget supermarket wine, c'mon!). someone who looked to be FoH mgr does his best to ignore all of the patrons. 4 ppl spent over $200 for exceptionally bad food + 1 round of rack drinks. Wondering if Dowlings trying to be the F&B equivalent of the predatory lending industry.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Theresa Gibbs

Great place for a beer & burgerThey have pasta night, burger night, taco night, steak nightSomething for everyone

Mary M.

Excellent food and service! We come here often and it's the perfect spot if you're looking for good, elevated comfort food. Very homey environment and a perfect place to watch the game, without it being too loud. They also have live music some nights. The fajitas, salads and fries are some of my favorites, but the buffalo chicken pizza is the best I've ever had!

Mary M

Great food and service! We go here often and never had a bad experience. It’s the perfect spot if you feel like upscale comfort food. The best buffalo chicken pizza I’ve ever had!

Kathy

We arrived early and the staff accommodated us with early seating. Then we added two more to our table and that was no problem for them. They were out of some of the specials, which was disappointing, but the food was very good. Will definitely return!!!

Load More