Sag Harbor Tavern
Customers' Favorites
Cheeseburger and Fries
Ryan's Rainbow Cookies
Shrimp Cocktail
Fish and Chips
Wedge Salad
Cheese Balls
Burger
Menu
Photos
+18 photos
+17 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
The experience started out highly disappointing. There was no clear place to check in since we arrived to the patio first. When we went inside, there was an empty wood podium with no book or computer so we ventured into the restaurant. A man came out and asked if we had a reservation and we apologized for not being sure that the empty wood podium was where we should have waited. He was very snarky and asked what we thought the podium was for. He seated us and we looked forward...
Made a reservation 3 weeks in advance for a table in the dining room and got sat at two bar seats right by the service station by the two swinging doors. Tried to talk to the host about it because we were celebrating our wedding anniversary. She did not care. She said they had to move their outdoor reservations indoor and that’s all they had. Seems totally weird to move the person that made the indoor resy to accommodate the people that book tables that clearly state are weather...
You May Also Like
DOPO La Spiaggia - 6 Bay St
![]()
Italian, Pet Friendly
Murf’s Backstreet Tavern - 64 Division St
![]()
Bar, Dive Bar, Pubs
I'm hooked. I highly recommend Sag Harbor Tavern