OK so I don’t usually buy oatmeal out because I find it to be overpriced and not really that good it’s usually cold the fruit is hard not worth it.However, I came in to Sag town which I haven’t been in a few years but I work in Sag harbor again so I came in and I had the oatmeal with coconut milk.Oh my gosh next level.! it was so delicious so home made fresh delicious. I came back two days in a row! People are really chill good music, comfortable seating.:)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Luke Rosen
It’s rare to find a cafe with such an extensive menu of delicious local food, healthy smoothies, and the finest coffee. What’s the coolest part of Sagtown Coffee? The people and environment match the high quality eating/drinking experience.Sagtown is a cafe where everybody who steps through the welcoming doors is treated like a local. Doesn’t matter if you live down the street and you stop in daily for morning coffee on the way to work (or an early morning surf), or it’s your first time visiting Sag Harbor. You’re treated like a friend in this gem of a neighborhood cafe and eatery.This is a spot that makes you feel at home. There’s a real community vibe inside, especially when the owner (a local community leader and volunteer firefighter) is there to make sure every customer is satisfied and greeted with a sincere smile and a hearty Sag Harbor handshake.This is one of those unique spots which everybody passing through town must visit. If there was any coffee shop with the same energy and warmth as the TV show “Cheers” this is it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rachel L
I love stopping by for a morning latte on my way to work! Inside has limited seating, but there's more tables outside to sit at, plus benches along the sidewalk if you take your food to go. They have plenty of options for food, from snacks to full meals for breakfast and lunch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tony del pino
The space is on the small side but plenty of outdoor seating when the weather permits. Variety of different coffee and smoothies/shakes available. Can't speak on the food as I haven't had. Although in a s***** for their Black and White cookies.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Acai Bowls, Acai
Michael Moore
Very good coffee drinks and INCREDIBLE baked goods, esp. the doughnuts. Worth a side trip if you’re in the area.
Y O
It’s always almost too busy but their coffee and overnight oats bowl are fantastic. (Overnight oats is pretty big too!) It’s a fun place to watch people and chill.
KJT Tembi
No hi or good morning… just a blank stare. Same throughout whole experience with robotic staff. Ironic that they have the nerve to ask for a “service” tip at reg and pickup points btw, seriously?! Jarringly loud at 6am Coffee although lukewarm wasn’t bad, pastries were good.First and last time coming here.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Nick Jacobson
If you drink Keurig or Nespresso coffee from pods then you’ll probably like this coffee. Don’t order the la Colombe or whatever. I don’t know how that even passes as a beverage. If you brew coffee at home, stay home.
I went with 3 friends for gelato (which tasted more like sherbet).I asked for the ladies room and the server pointed to the corner. When I walked over to where she pointed I asked a young man where to use the restroom, he looked at 2-3 bags of garbage on the floor at the entrance of the restroom and said “It’s not available right now”My friend asked another worker who told her to use the municipal restroom across the street. As visitors, we were not familiar with the area and asked for clarification. The girl told us to google it.I was very surprised and disappointed by the poor customer service.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Carmine M.
What a zoo. Still once you get past the cramped and crowded entrance and place your order you are the subject to screaming staff yelling out " number 15 ! "as if officiating a football game. That said, if you can handle all the overly loud poor choice of hip hop music while joining ten other " detainees " desperately waiting until your number is screamed out!! You take your bag... still warm from being toasted , unwrap your long awaited lunch and there lies the most beautiful Turkey club I ever laid eyes on. Better yet it was just perfect in every way It's now my go to for Sandwiches etc. I'll just bring my earplugs next time
Jim Olivo
Best coffee house in town, unless you go in summer. Shane, you need a separate line for people who just want a coffee and pastry (your regulars) so they don't wait behind a bunch of people ordering acai bowls. Sorry, but I'm guessing I'm not the only regular who walks away in the summer
Alex D.
Smoothies are great if you're willing to wait 35 minutes! Apparently they make them all in batches so you end up waiting a very, very long time for yours to come out.
Lilly T.
Cute coffee shop and lots of yummy treats. I got an iced cold brew with the monkey smoothie. The smoothie was delicious if you're a peanut butter fan!! We also got the vegan carrot cake muffin, blueberry muffin, chocolate croissant and regular croissant. All were really good and I liked that they had vegan and gluten free options. The cafe isn't too small and has seating both inside and outside. My order came out pretty quick despite it being quite busy. It's right in town and you can walk to a bunch of different shops and restaurants. Def check out this spot if you're in the area!
What a cozy place! Beautiful store with a wonderful customer service! Definitely a place to come back again and again! Coffees are 100% tasty!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
sagtown açaí bowls and smoothies r so goodMust
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Overnight Oats, Acai Bowls, Acai, Iced Caramel Macchiato
OK so I don’t usually buy oatmeal out because I find it to be overpriced and not really that good it’s usually cold the fruit is hard not worth it.However, I came in to Sag town which I haven’t been in a few years but I work in Sag harbor again so I came in and I had the oatmeal with coconut milk.Oh my gosh next level.! it was so delicious so home made fresh delicious. I came back two days in a row! People are really chill good music, comfortable seating.:)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It’s rare to find a cafe with such an extensive menu of delicious local food, healthy smoothies, and the finest coffee. What’s the coolest part of Sagtown Coffee? The people and environment match the high quality eating/drinking experience.Sagtown is a cafe where everybody who steps through the welcoming doors is treated like a local. Doesn’t matter if you live down the street and you stop in daily for morning coffee on the way to work (or an early morning surf), or it’s your first time visiting Sag Harbor. You’re treated like a friend in this gem of a neighborhood cafe and eatery.This is a spot that makes you feel at home. There’s a real community vibe inside, especially when the owner (a local community leader and volunteer firefighter) is there to make sure every customer is satisfied and greeted with a sincere smile and a hearty Sag Harbor handshake.This is one of those unique spots which everybody passing through town must visit. If there was any coffee shop with the same energy and warmth as the TV show “Cheers” this is it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love stopping by for a morning latte on my way to work! Inside has limited seating, but there's more tables outside to sit at, plus benches along the sidewalk if you take your food to go. They have plenty of options for food, from snacks to full meals for breakfast and lunch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The space is on the small side but plenty of outdoor seating when the weather permits. Variety of different coffee and smoothies/shakes available. Can't speak on the food as I haven't had. Although in a s***** for their Black and White cookies.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Acai Bowls, Acai
Very good coffee drinks and INCREDIBLE baked goods, esp. the doughnuts. Worth a side trip if you’re in the area.
It’s always almost too busy but their coffee and overnight oats bowl are fantastic. (Overnight oats is pretty big too!) It’s a fun place to watch people and chill.
No hi or good morning… just a blank stare. Same throughout whole experience with robotic staff. Ironic that they have the nerve to ask for a “service” tip at reg and pickup points btw, seriously?! Jarringly loud at 6am Coffee although lukewarm wasn’t bad, pastries were good.First and last time coming here.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
If you drink Keurig or Nespresso coffee from pods then you’ll probably like this coffee. Don’t order the la Colombe or whatever. I don’t know how that even passes as a beverage. If you brew coffee at home, stay home.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
I went with 3 friends for gelato (which tasted more like sherbet).I asked for the ladies room and the server pointed to the corner. When I walked over to where she pointed I asked a young man where to use the restroom, he looked at 2-3 bags of garbage on the floor at the entrance of the restroom and said “It’s not available right now”My friend asked another worker who told her to use the municipal restroom across the street. As visitors, we were not familiar with the area and asked for clarification. The girl told us to google it.I was very surprised and disappointed by the poor customer service.
Food: 1
Service: 1
What a zoo. Still once you get past the cramped and crowded entrance and place your order you are the subject to screaming staff yelling out " number 15 ! "as if officiating a football game. That said, if you can handle all the overly loud poor choice of hip hop music while joining ten other " detainees " desperately waiting until your number is screamed out!! You take your bag... still warm from being toasted , unwrap your long awaited lunch and there lies the most beautiful Turkey club I ever laid eyes on. Better yet it was just perfect in every way It's now my go to for Sandwiches etc. I'll just bring my earplugs next time
Best coffee house in town, unless you go in summer. Shane, you need a separate line for people who just want a coffee and pastry (your regulars) so they don't wait behind a bunch of people ordering acai bowls. Sorry, but I'm guessing I'm not the only regular who walks away in the summer
Smoothies are great if you're willing to wait 35 minutes! Apparently they make them all in batches so you end up waiting a very, very long time for yours to come out.
Cute coffee shop and lots of yummy treats. I got an iced cold brew with the monkey smoothie. The smoothie was delicious if you're a peanut butter fan!! We also got the vegan carrot cake muffin, blueberry muffin, chocolate croissant and regular croissant. All were really good and I liked that they had vegan and gluten free options. The cafe isn't too small and has seating both inside and outside. My order came out pretty quick despite it being quite busy. It's right in town and you can walk to a bunch of different shops and restaurants. Def check out this spot if you're in the area!