Yummylicious!

2 Main St, Sag Harbor
(631) 223-8119

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Grace Sha

Ice cream was ok, service was a bit slow

Jerry Fraelic

Ice cream was good. Very expensive. Two small scoops with tax and the credit card percent added on - over $17. Adding the credit card fee when it is a business expense and tax deductible? No chairs inside.
Will not go again.

You wanted ice cream? How about some overpriced frozen sugar water? That’s exactly what you get here at Yummilicious for $15 for 2 kids portions

HQJ Real Estate E143

Not the best

Julia L.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️Seriously, some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had worth every penny and now I am back home dreaming of this ice cream. Can’t wait to go back. 5 stars! No picture because I ate it up.

Paul Sarosi

This was some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had and it was still not that expensive. Well getting four scoops of ice cream all different flavors and five toppings. It was not very expensive at all. And still tasted amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cata Lloret

Great place. Good ice cream, the boba tea isn’t very yummy in my opinion. It tastes weird; but it might just be me.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Mei

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Yummylicious, and I must say, it was an absolutely delightful experience that left me with a smile on my face. If you're a fan of heavenly, creamy, and delectable ice cream, this is the place to be. From classic favorites like vanilla and chocolate to more exotic creations like key lime pie and banana pudding, there's something for everyone. In addition, their milkshakes are out of this world! They also offer a range of creative toppings to take your dessert to the next level. The price is up to par with everything else in the area. This charming ice cream shop is definitely worth a visit while you are in SAG.

EmojiFtw

so basically i was waddling down the street when I saw a girl with wolf ears saying “Ice cream so good! Yum Yum” and I was like ????so 20 minutes later I can confirm Ice Cream so good (yum yum)

KJT Tembi

8bucks for 2 scoops plus 4% charge if you use a cc.

Ilise Forman

This place is criminal. There’s barely room for toppings in your cup and the topping choices are beyond weak. I asked for Oreos and got a whole big Oreo! Not even crushed. $20 for two small ice creams. Immediately threw them out and went to Buddha which was mind blowing and 1000x better. Do not go here.

Brittany Valente

This place is criminal. There’s barely room for toppings in your cup and the topping choices are beyond weak. I asked for Oreos and got a whole big Oreo! Not even crushed. $20 for two small ice creams. Immediately threw them out and went to Buddha which was mind blowing and 1000x better. Do not go here.

Becky Marshall

Delicious froyo in an adorable environment!

Jr N

THE STAFF THAT WAS WORKING TODAY 08/12/23 WAS HORRIBLE. Disgusting customer service. NEVER AGAIN. Both females need to go!

Rosario S. Cassata (Batman)

Great for the special ice cream, sorbet or yogurt. Try a few samples. The mango and the cotton candy are awesome.

Loading...