Comiskey Park Bar

485 Lake Ave, St James
(631) 584-3880

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Irena Morris

If I could put zero stars I would. As a young woman, do not let your guard down. I got groped by a guy and nothing was done. I spent money just to be told I don't matter through their lack of action. I ended up leaving out of discomfort because they wouldn't address the man harassing me.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Steven Betz

Great vibes local spot in the smithtown, St. James area. Tend to the bartenders, and they shall serve you well. Highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephen Renard

Such a fun night! Everyone there was super friendly and warm. What an awesome group!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Peter Savrides

Quality neighborhood bar experience. Friendly patrons and bartenders! Great place to end a night out.

Thomas JC Grimaldi

The best pub in the Town of Smithtown! Swan, Jeff and the gang..
Any persons willing to hold yearly breast cancer benefits and seriously go all out like the carnival just set up shop; to me, that shows good people and good people I know personally for many many years are nice to me and cut me off when I didn't know my limit? All around good vibes and fun and caring management. Mad respect and love y'all.

Johanna XoJo Izquierdo-Aquino

Swan and Jeff are AMAZING! The staff is welcoming and fun. They are VERY ACCOMMODATING with any event ❤️

Raquel Castro

lots of fun, people are very friendly, food drinks, bans, you will definitely have a great time there.

Thomas Grimaldi (Cornelius Castiglione)

The best pub in the Town of Smithtown! Swan, Jeff and the gang..Any persons willing to hold yearly breast cancer benefits and seriously go all out like the carnival just set up shop; to me, that shows good people and good people I know personally for many many years are nice to me and cut me off when I didn't know my limit? All around good vibes and fun and caring management. Mad respect and love y'all.

Shinoj Joseph

Cool place to hang out!! Nice genuine people! Very friendly atmosphere

Cornelius Castiglione

The best pub in the Town of Smithtown!! Swan and the gang A+!ECHODELTA signing out

Steve M

Great little dive bar. Friendly bar tender and good drinks. Exactly what you'd expect. ??

Secret Ion

CANCEL YOUR PLANS TOMORROW NIGHT if you wanna see something cool. Come to Comiskey Park Bar tomorrow at 830 and stay til 1010 when my Un-Rebirthening Day Sextravaganza takes over Comiskey Park Open Mic & Jam for the 2nd year in a row without spite for planning and with Nicholas Jon Lewandowski hosting the pants off of it. Ty in advance, gonna be a banger if it's anything like last year.

donna Adams

Very friendly atmosphere... Owner and staff treat you like family

Deirdre Mauk

Great place to relax and enjoy a laugh with friends!

Jennie Golden

Owners are great and treat everyone with respect. Fair prices and good company. Its clean and crowd is mixed ages but all get along together. Every visit you meet new friends and share in the fun atmosphere. 😎👍😊 I've enjoyed visiting for 20+ years and look forward to return of normal abilities to have shows and more people able to come in. It's literally next to train station so you have ability for safe travel if you drink. Take a chance and go on down...wont be disappointed 😀

Loading...