CRUST PIZZA DELI & RESTAURANT

739 Middle Country Rd, St James
(631) 656-9800

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Rachel Heller

If I could give this place ZERO stars I would. They changed owners but have kept the name - except now they are essentially a Hispanic deli. The pizza was VILE and tasted like chemicals… worse than any pizza I’ve ever had before. This is not the same brick oven pizza place that it used to be. GROSS. Also ordered delivery on DoorDash and it took them over an hour to make 2 pies and when the dasher was there asking how long they kept saying 5 min which went on forever. Would not recommend this place at all - allif the good reviews you see are from BEFORE they were bought by new people, very sneaky not changing the name.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

amanda ranieri

Just got delivery. Pizza is good, but mozzarella sticks were completely overcooked/burnt :(

triton2286

2nd worst pizza I've ever had on Long Island. This place clearly must have recently been bought out and instead of just turning it into a Hispanic deli they decided to keep selling pizza (under the pizzeria name) which is absolute trash and they only have room to display 2 pies. The cheese in the chicken roll tasted so unbelievably synthetic. Funny how the worst places on Long Island charge you the most ($15.60 for the worst chicken roll of my life and a pepperoni slice which was equally as bad).The woman behind the counter also had to take the chicken roll back into the kitchen and wait 3min for someone to cut it in half while my slice had already been in the oven for 5min. Talk about a$$ backwards

Food: 1

Service: 1

Elisa Ercolano

Corruption

James McMahon

4.50 for one plain slice which tasted like ellios freezer pizza.

Roy Longhitano

Great pizza and sauce, very friendly owners. My wife discovered it while my daughter was at the hair salon next door. We drove back 10 miles from our house to get dinner there, definitely worth the trip.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots

Timothy McCarthy

Nice people but the pizza tasted funny in and it was very very greasy. Would not recommend.

10lisamariem

We have been going here for ages. Always nice & food can vary a bit but good. Been out of town awhile. Just tried to order a pie. On a Friday At 630. Dome Spanish girl said you're closed??! At 630 on a Friday??? Just thought the boss should know this If he's not around ?

Murtaz Buskadze

The best pizza in Long Island! Super tasty and delicious ? Strongly suggest everyone to try it ?

Aymer Callejas

Great good and service. Highly recommended

c

First time getting food from here. Ordered the 18" garlic knot pie, very pleased. Will order again.

Martha Zapata

Spectacular food!! The unique attention!! I will always return!!!! Variety of food I loved it ?????

Christopher Bialecki

I tried to order on Doordash but it said your close it's 5:07pm and it's open right now. Why couldn't you just let it go ?

k.o. Konfusion

Brick oven pizza taste so gd

mike manzolina

Not a bad place clean friendly. The food was so so.

Loading...