Found this seafood heaven a couple of years ago and is worth every penny. I challenge you to find better Salmon anywhere!! Always friendly, super fresh and tasty
Dani McDowl
Wonderful fresh fish. Delicious. Great experience! Will be back!
Kevin Maser
Outstanding Ryan!
I wanted to let you know that every single one of those PEI muscles opened up and were delicious. The squid was fantastic. The seafood salad was over the top this year, even my parents said so.
I’ll be sharing your contact with the people on my block . Happy new year!
Kevin - Commack
Lynn Shortis
At first I was a little surprised it was not a stand alone store. I went for my Christmas Eve fish for the 1st time following reviews on Google. There was a brisk business, which to me was a great sign. The fish I bought was delicious! My family was happy. I bought: swordfish , flounder , cod and bay scallops. I will definitely recommend them and buy my fish from them again ☺️
Maryellen Conboy
Just enjoyed the best shrimp, seafood salad, and wild oysters from Fresh Catch Seafood. I highly recommend this business, as they clearly take pride in their offering. It was easy to order ahead for the holidays, and I'm always happy to support a local small business.
Amanda Cerrato
Highly recommend! We have been ordering from Ryan for a few years now. We always get a lobster and shrimp platter for the holidays and have never been disappointed. The seafood is fresh and the best I’ve ever had. Customer service has always been top notch also.
Joe Dee
Best shrimp on Long Island. Worth the price
M G
My wife was looking to make a clam dish and we stumbled upon Fresh Catch on our way out to Long Island.
I called up and immediately was greeted by Ryan who was incredibly knowledgable about his selection.
We ended up picking up 3 dozen little neck clams which were clean and delicious. Thank you Ryan for the great experience.
rae ermelino
People if you want the absolute best tasting salmon look no further. I’ve been eating salmon for the last 15 years and have never ever tasted such amazing salmon as here at fresh catch. They import their salmon from Norway and it’s light airy flavorful and flaky. Just incredible
Just got 2 dozen little necks from here. Fresh and delicious. A little lemon and hot sauce and down the hatch! This place is awesome. If you've never been here, get there soon. All their seafood is very Fresh and prices are reasonable. So glad I found this place. Local too.
Krys S
They are the best!
Daniella Passarelli
My husband went to numerous places looking for tuna today and nothing was as fresh as what they had at Fresh Catch. When he got there, there was only a few pieces left but they grabbed a fresher cut for him from the back. Great quality!! Highly recommend!
Nichole Abbruzzese
Came here recently for oysters and clams for a party. The owner shucked and served an oyster for us as a “welcome” for my first time being there. We went back the NEXT DAY for more and fish! So fresh and so good! Will never get seafood from anywhere else!
Just had the Manhattan clam chowder the best. 👍
Found this seafood heaven a couple of years ago and is worth every penny. I challenge you to find better Salmon anywhere!! Always friendly, super fresh and tasty
Wonderful fresh fish. Delicious. Great experience! Will be back!
Outstanding Ryan!
I wanted to let you know that every single one of those PEI muscles opened up and were delicious. The squid was fantastic. The seafood salad was over the top this year, even my parents said so.
I’ll be sharing your contact with the people on my block . Happy new year!
Kevin - Commack
At first I was a little surprised it was not a stand alone store. I went for my Christmas Eve fish for the 1st time following reviews on Google. There was a brisk business, which to me was a great sign. The fish I bought was delicious! My family was happy. I bought: swordfish , flounder , cod and bay scallops. I will definitely recommend them and buy my fish from them again ☺️
Just enjoyed the best shrimp, seafood salad, and wild oysters from Fresh Catch Seafood. I highly recommend this business, as they clearly take pride in their offering. It was easy to order ahead for the holidays, and I'm always happy to support a local small business.
Highly recommend! We have been ordering from Ryan for a few years now. We always get a lobster and shrimp platter for the holidays and have never been disappointed. The seafood is fresh and the best I’ve ever had. Customer service has always been top notch also.
Best shrimp on Long Island. Worth the price
My wife was looking to make a clam dish and we stumbled upon Fresh Catch on our way out to Long Island.
I called up and immediately was greeted by Ryan who was incredibly knowledgable about his selection.
We ended up picking up 3 dozen little neck clams which were clean and delicious. Thank you Ryan for the great experience.
People if you want the absolute best tasting salmon look no further. I’ve been eating salmon for the last 15 years and have never ever tasted such amazing salmon as here at fresh catch. They import their salmon from Norway and it’s light airy flavorful and flaky. Just incredible
Restaurantji Recommends
Just got 2 dozen little necks from here. Fresh and delicious. A little lemon and hot sauce and down the hatch! This place is awesome. If you've never been here, get there soon. All their seafood is very Fresh and prices are reasonable. So glad I found this place. Local too.
They are the best!
My husband went to numerous places looking for tuna today and nothing was as fresh as what they had at Fresh Catch. When he got there, there was only a few pieces left but they grabbed a fresher cut for him from the back. Great quality!! Highly recommend!
Came here recently for oysters and clams for a party. The owner shucked and served an oyster for us as a “welcome” for my first time being there. We went back the NEXT DAY for more and fish! So fresh and so good! Will never get seafood from anywhere else!
Incredible Sea Bass, Tuna & lobster tail!
Loading...