Have stopped off at Fresh Catch a few times. Each time has been a positive experience with amazing selections. Would highly recommend!
Susan Lofaro
Best place to go for super fresh local fish. Owners are amazing and respond quickly to calls & texts. They go above and beyond to accommodate their customers. Very well run & friendly business. I highly recommend checking them out, you will be hooked once you find this hidden St James gem !
Susan Lofaro
Best place to go for super fresh local fish. Owners are amazing and respond quickly to calls & texts. They go above and beyond to accommodate their customers. Very well run & friendly business. I highly recommend checking them out, you will be hooked once you find this hidden St James gem ! 🐟🐠🍤
Claire Moran
Went to Fresh Catch today and Ryan and Paul did not disappoint! Great people and the freshest seafood 🦪
Court Farruggia
Amazing fresh fish ! Have passed it plenty of times and never stopped. Today my husband and I stopped by, friendly service and fresh fish ! Will definitely be back again !
Brian Prensky
Possibly the juiciest and tastiest lobster I have had from anywhere. 6 - 2 lb lobsters, each one was delicious ! Thanks Ryan !!!!
One Last Cast Long Island Long Island
As a fisherman who knows fresh this was a great find probably the best baked clams, crab cakes and stuffed mushroom I've ever had cant wait to go back
Kathleen S
Plenty of fresh offerings. Knowledgeable gentleman at the counter. I purchased the cod and it was delicious!
pd speh
My sister was in town from St Louis. She wanted some seafood from a local market. And there's no better local seafood market in the area then this one.
It's so nice to see such fresh fish from local waters. Especially Striped Bass and Fluke. We got both. Plus the lobster bisque.
And came back the next day to get fresh local Little necks and Mussels. As well as the fresh made crab cakes.
Which the owner went and got for us. As he was out the day we went. Just awesome
Found this seafood heaven a couple of years ago and is worth every penny. I challenge you to find better Salmon anywhere!! Always friendly, super fresh and tasty
Dani McDowl
Wonderful fresh fish. Delicious. Great experience! Will be back!
Kevin Maser
Outstanding Ryan!
I wanted to let you know that every single one of those PEI muscles opened up and were delicious. The squid was fantastic. The seafood salad was over the top this year, even my parents said so.
I’ll be sharing your contact with the people on my block . Happy new year!
Kevin - Commack
Lynn Shortis
At first I was a little surprised it was not a stand alone store. I went for my Christmas Eve fish for the 1st time following reviews on Google. There was a brisk business, which to me was a great sign. The fish I bought was delicious! My family was happy. I bought: swordfish , flounder , cod and bay scallops. I will definitely recommend them and buy my fish from them again ☺️
Maryellen Conboy
Just enjoyed the best shrimp, seafood salad, and wild oysters from Fresh Catch Seafood. I highly recommend this business, as they clearly take pride in their offering. It was easy to order ahead for the holidays, and I'm always happy to support a local small business.
Have stopped off at Fresh Catch a few times. Each time has been a positive experience with amazing selections. Would highly recommend!
Best place to go for super fresh local fish. Owners are amazing and respond quickly to calls & texts. They go above and beyond to accommodate their customers. Very well run & friendly business. I highly recommend checking them out, you will be hooked once you find this hidden St James gem !
Best place to go for super fresh local fish. Owners are amazing and respond quickly to calls & texts. They go above and beyond to accommodate their customers. Very well run & friendly business. I highly recommend checking them out, you will be hooked once you find this hidden St James gem ! 🐟🐠🍤
Went to Fresh Catch today and Ryan and Paul did not disappoint! Great people and the freshest seafood 🦪
Amazing fresh fish ! Have passed it plenty of times and never stopped. Today my husband and I stopped by, friendly service and fresh fish ! Will definitely be back again !
Possibly the juiciest and tastiest lobster I have had from anywhere.
6 - 2 lb lobsters, each one was delicious !
Thanks Ryan !!!!
As a fisherman who knows fresh this was a great find probably the best baked clams, crab cakes and stuffed mushroom I've ever had cant wait to go back
Plenty of fresh offerings. Knowledgeable gentleman at the counter. I purchased the cod and it was delicious!
My sister was in town from St Louis.
She wanted some seafood from a local market. And there's no better local seafood market in the area then this one.
It's so nice to see such fresh fish from local waters. Especially Striped Bass and Fluke.
We got both. Plus the lobster bisque.
And came back the next day to get fresh local Little necks and Mussels. As well as the fresh made crab cakes.
Which the owner went and got for us. As he was out the day we went.
Just awesome
Thank you!
Just had the Manhattan clam chowder the best. 👍
Restaurantji Recommends
Found this seafood heaven a couple of years ago and is worth every penny. I challenge you to find better Salmon anywhere!! Always friendly, super fresh and tasty
Wonderful fresh fish. Delicious. Great experience! Will be back!
Outstanding Ryan!
I wanted to let you know that every single one of those PEI muscles opened up and were delicious. The squid was fantastic. The seafood salad was over the top this year, even my parents said so.
I’ll be sharing your contact with the people on my block . Happy new year!
Kevin - Commack
At first I was a little surprised it was not a stand alone store. I went for my Christmas Eve fish for the 1st time following reviews on Google. There was a brisk business, which to me was a great sign. The fish I bought was delicious! My family was happy. I bought: swordfish , flounder , cod and bay scallops. I will definitely recommend them and buy my fish from them again ☺️
Just enjoyed the best shrimp, seafood salad, and wild oysters from Fresh Catch Seafood. I highly recommend this business, as they clearly take pride in their offering. It was easy to order ahead for the holidays, and I'm always happy to support a local small business.
Loading...