Garguilos Bakery

503 Lake Ave, St James
(631) 584-9400

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Maria Schwartzberg

I got a cannoli cake for my step mom’s birthday and it was incredible!! The only bakery in Suffolk county that has done cannoli right! Will certainly be coming back for more! The staff were very friendly and quick service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kathy Ward

I ordered a 50th birthday cake for my daughter. It was delicious. Everyone ate it all, no leftovers. Beautiful cake.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Adam Dorsey

2.5/3 star rating
Have new owners taken over this place? I felt sad not seeing the old doors n entryway it seems to be lacking the old style feel.
I got a Boston-cream doughnut that was undercooked on the bottom, tasted doughy not a lot of cream like previous purchases..
I’m hoping it was just because it’s a holiday weekend was the case.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 4

Nicholas D

Cleary using canned fruit in their pies. Woman told me that they use fresh fruit in their pies after I asked her, "what pies are fresh and do you use fresh fruit." I want to use this local business but have a hard time with their quality.

Sean Kuttin

Great espresso!

Molly C

Delicious. Everything always tastes fresh. The jelly donuts are to die for!

custom eyes

The Chocolate Coffee cake is to die for. I have made the trip from Coram to get just that half a dozen times. The Jelly Donut is also fantastic.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

L B

Best bakery around!

Brendon Patton

Meltaways are awesome

Peter Lindner

I miss the original owners

Mr Mattydeez

Last week I purchased red velvet cupcakes and st Joseph’s pastry. The red velvet was freezer burned and it tasted horrible. The st Joseph’s were oozing liquid and the cream tasted like it had gone bad. I threw it all in the trash after one bite. Worst 20 dollars I’ve spent in recent memory.

grace park

I love this bakery... always a delight. Cinnamon cake donuts crispy even when you buy them at 2:00, my favorite are the raspberry filled butter cookies dipped in chocolate. I recently got the chocolate chocolate cup cake...the cake moist (not dry like most places), and the frosting was melt in your mouth. So much better than other bakeries...this is a neighborhood secret !

Edward Clement

Hands down the best cannoli I’ve ever had. Stopped on a whim after a hike nearby. Huge selection of interesting pastries.

Chris Cirillo

I can’t believe I only discovered this place for the first time today …. This is a top-notch bakery with excellent customer service. I will most definitely be back on a regular basis!

Robert Torres

Do any Italian bakeries make Italian bread anymore? I've been looking for prosciutto & Foccaci breads? Or even Semolina !! That's why I Loved Authur Ave in the Bx.

Loading...