Their pizza is hands down the best I’ve ever had. I would travel from anywhere for it but thankfully I don’t have to travel far so this is a weekly dinner in our house!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Cheese Pizza Slice, Wings, Caesar Salad
Paige P
We're from Ohio and ended up in the area for a car. The dealership asked us if we'd ever had New York style pizza - nope! So they eagerly gave us a couple slices of cheese pizza they ordered for lunch and it was so good I asked where it came from, they said St. James Pizza. After we got done with the car deal this was the first place we stopped and got 2 larges to eat on the way home. That was on St. Paddy's Day weekend and here I am STILL thinkin about how good the pizza was. Excellent!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Julie's Tanks
Love, love, love this place. Food is always good. Great meatball heros and Sicilian slices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice
Michael P
Darren and Co are amazing owners. My wife and I order from St. James Pizza often. I will say as a pizza maker for 15 years, it’s appreciated when the pizza is A. cooked, B. crisp, C. Not sloppy. These guys cook a great pizza for delivery and in house. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Harlan Fischer
Great food and really nice people.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon Ranch
Eitan Klein
The item I ordered was unavailable but they took the order., and I had to wait 10 minutes for an alternative I didn't
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Christina V.
Nestled in the heart of our quaint town on Lake Avenue is a pizzeria that was taken over around the beginning of COVID. This also happened to correspond with when I moved to this area (late 2020). As any native New Yorker does, I scoped out the pizza places near by that I could call for delivery or get a quick slice from. In the years since, I have been rewarded greatly from being a patron at this wonderful establishment. The owners work hard behind the counter and doing deliveries, and of course, making pizza. Their pizza is absolutely delicious, with a sauce that EVER SO SLIGHTLY reminds me of vodka sauce without being a flat, caustic regular tomato sauce. A fresh pie is affordable, fast, and fresh. My kids' favorite is the Brooklyn pie - an "upside down" Sicilian, if you will, where the sauce goes on top of the cheese. It's one of mine as well. Be sure to get a copy of the paper menu, as it has coupons on it. Thanks for being a pizza place our town can be proud of!
Tunc
I have been there many times. The owner is very friendly and they serve the best pizza in town.
Been here many times and everything I have is amazing!! It's hard to make a recommendation because everything is delicious The regular slice,Sicilian and grandma it's hard to choose a favorite. My wife's favorite dish is the Chicken franchise. I was in last night and to go along with the great food is the great service, the young girl behind the counter is always so pleasant we always look forward to going back. This is a must try on Long Island !!!
Regina downing
Amazing! Since new ownership, you feel like you're going into your hometown pizzeria, friendly and delicious!!
C S
Recently found this hidden gem. Food and pizza are awesome!!. Service is welcoming. YOU MUST TRY!!! Catering for Christmas was loved by all!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Stanco
I've lived in the area for over 25 years and it's still has the best pizza in town.
John Larsen
Your typical Pizzaria but great pizza, entrees and staff!
Best Pizza in Saint James. Love the cornmeal crust.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon Ranch, Garlic Knots, Cheese Pizza Slice, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Sausage, Pepperoni Pizza
Great crust
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Their pizza is hands down the best I’ve ever had. I would travel from anywhere for it but thankfully I don’t have to travel far so this is a weekly dinner in our house!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Cheese Pizza Slice, Wings, Caesar Salad
We're from Ohio and ended up in the area for a car. The dealership asked us if we'd ever had New York style pizza - nope! So they eagerly gave us a couple slices of cheese pizza they ordered for lunch and it was so good I asked where it came from, they said St. James Pizza. After we got done with the car deal this was the first place we stopped and got 2 larges to eat on the way home. That was on St. Paddy's Day weekend and here I am STILL thinkin about how good the pizza was. Excellent!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love, love, love this place. Food is always good. Great meatball heros and Sicilian slices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice
Darren and Co are amazing owners. My wife and I order from St. James Pizza often. I will say as a pizza maker for 15 years, it’s appreciated when the pizza is A. cooked, B. crisp, C. Not sloppy. These guys cook a great pizza for delivery and in house. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and really nice people.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon Ranch
The item I ordered was unavailable but they took the order., and I had to wait 10 minutes for an alternative I didn't
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Nestled in the heart of our quaint town on Lake Avenue is a pizzeria that was taken over around the beginning of COVID. This also happened to correspond with when I moved to this area (late 2020). As any native New Yorker does, I scoped out the pizza places near by that I could call for delivery or get a quick slice from. In the years since, I have been rewarded greatly from being a patron at this wonderful establishment. The owners work hard behind the counter and doing deliveries, and of course, making pizza. Their pizza is absolutely delicious, with a sauce that EVER SO SLIGHTLY reminds me of vodka sauce without being a flat, caustic regular tomato sauce. A fresh pie is affordable, fast, and fresh. My kids' favorite is the Brooklyn pie - an "upside down" Sicilian, if you will, where the sauce goes on top of the cheese. It's one of mine as well. Be sure to get a copy of the paper menu, as it has coupons on it. Thanks for being a pizza place our town can be proud of!
I have been there many times. The owner is very friendly and they serve the best pizza in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, Garlic Knots, Cheese Pizza Slice, Chicken Roll, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Grandma Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Been here many times and everything I have is amazing!! It's hard to make a recommendation because everything is delicious The regular slice,Sicilian and grandma it's hard to choose a favorite. My wife's favorite dish is the Chicken franchise. I was in last night and to go along with the great food is the great service, the young girl behind the counter is always so pleasant we always look forward to going back. This is a must try on Long Island !!!
Amazing! Since new ownership, you feel like you're going into your hometown pizzeria, friendly and delicious!!
Recently found this hidden gem. Food and pizza are awesome!!. Service is welcoming. YOU MUST TRY!!! Catering for Christmas was loved by all!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've lived in the area for over 25 years and it's still has the best pizza in town.
Your typical Pizzaria but great pizza, entrees and staff!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, Garlic Knots, Cheese Pizza Slice, Sausage & Pepper Hero, Pepperoni Pizza