Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen & Space
370 Lake Ave, St James
(631) 594-4032
Customers' Favorites
Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich - Soft Serve
Mini Mick-Wich Ice Cream Sandwich
Topping - Crushed Waffle Cone
Topping - Rainbow Sprinkles
Cotton Candy Ice Cream
Peanut Butter Overload
Pint - Rainbow Cookie
Shakes & Floats
Icecream Cakes
Cookies 'Cream
Cones
Waffle Cone Junior (1 Scoop)
Large Waffle Cone With 1 Scoop of your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor & Toppings of Your Choice. Select 1 Flavors & Dry Toppings to Complete. Online Delivery orders of cones will arrive in a cup with toppings & cone on side.
Extra Waffle Cone (Single)
Spare Large Waffle Cone (Single)
Extra Waffer Cone (Single)
Extra Cone For Your Favorite Ice Cream to just to snack on.
Junior Cone - 1 Scoop
Classic Cone With 1 Scoop of your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor & Toppings of Your Choice. Select 1 Flavor & Dry Toppings to Complete.
Online Delivery orders of cones will arrive in a cup with toppings & cone on side.
Waffle Cone - Large (4 Scoops)
Large Waffle Cone With 4 Scoops of your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor & Toppings of Your Choice. Select 1-4 Flavors & Dry Toppings to Complete.
Online Delivery orders of cones will arrive in a cup with toppings & cone on side.
Waffle Cone - Medium (3 scoop)
Large Waffle Cone With 3 Scoops of your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor & Toppings of Your Choice. Select 1-3 Flavors & Dry Toppings to Complete.
Online Delivery orders of cones will arrive in a cup with toppings & cone on side.
Waffle Cone - Small (2 scoop)
Large Waffle Cone With 2 Scoops of your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor & Toppings of Your Choice. Select 1-2 Flavors & Dry Toppings to Complete.
Online Delivery orders of cones will arrive in a cup with toppings & cone on side.
Large Cone (4 Scoops)
Classic Cone With 4 Scoops of your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor(s) & Toppings of Your Choice. Select 1-4 Flavors & Dry Toppings to Complete.
Online Delivery orders of cones will arrive in a cup with toppings & cone on side.
Medium Cone (3 Scoops)
Classic Cone With 3 Scoops of your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor(s) & Toppings of Your Choice. Select 1-3 Flavors & Dry Toppings to Complete.
Online Delivery orders of cones will arrive in a cup with toppings & cone on side.
Small Cone (2 Scoops)
Classic Cone With 2 Scoops of your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor(s) & Toppings of Your Choice. Select 1-2 Flavors & Dry Toppings to Complete.
Online Delivery orders of cones will arrive in a cup with toppings & cone on side.
Cup
Waffle Bowl (1 Scoop)
Classic Waffle Bowl With. A Scoop Of Ice Cream & Toppings
Extra Waffle Bowl
Extra Waffle Bowl
Cup - Waffle Bowl (2 Scoops)
2 Scoops Of Your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor In Waffle Bowl
Cup - Waffle Bowl (3 Scoops)
3 Scoops Of Your Favorite Ice Cream Sundae In A Waffle Bowl
Junior Sundae Cup - 1 Scoop
Classic Cup With 1 Scoop of your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor & Toppings of Your Choice. Select 1 Flavor & Dry/Wet Toppings to Complete Your Dessert.
All Sundae Cups are Delivered with 1 Spoon & Lid.
Cup - Waffle Bowl (4 Scoops)
Waffle Cup With 4 Scoops & Toppings
Brownie - Fudge (Single)
Add a Fudge Brownie Square to Any Size Sundae Cup on Your Order.
Large Sundae Cup (4 Scoop)
Classic Cup With 4 Scoops of your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor(s) & Toppings of Your Choice. Select 1-4 Flavor(s) & Dry/Wet Toppings to Complete Your Dessert.
All Sundae Cups are Delivered with 1 Spoon & Lid.
Medium Sundae Cup (3 Scoop)
Classic Cup With 3 Scoops of your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor(s) & Toppings of Your Choice. Select 1-3 Flavor(s) & Dry/Wet Toppings to Complete Your Dessert.
All Sundae Cups are Delivered with 1 Spoon & Lid.
Small Sundae Cup (2 Scoop)
Classic Cup With 2 Scoops of your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor(s) & Toppings of Your Choice. Select 1-2 Flavor(s) & Dry/Wet Toppings to Complete Your Dessert.
All Sundae Cups are Delivered with 1 Spoon & Lid.
Pints
Seasonal Flavor Pint
Enjoy The Ice Cream Flavor Of The Month In Resealable Pint Size
Cinnamon Ice Cream Pint
Pint Of Cinnamon Flavored Ice Cream
Jolted Cow Pint
Sweet Cream Ice Cream With Kiss Of Esspresso, Caramel, & Brownie Bites
Pint - Barking Pretzel
16 oz Pint of creamy Vanilla Ice Cream With Touch Of Brown Sugar, Peanut Butter Ripple, & Chocolate Covered Pretzel Pieces
Cotton Candy Pint
Pink & Blue Cotton Candy Flavored Ice Cream
Pint - Mini Mick(All)
8oz Cup Of Your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor as a Mini treat or just to try a new flavor without all the guilt.
Celebration Quart - Fill Your Own
Empty 32oz Quart To Give As Gift To Fill With Favorite Ice Cream Flavor
Mickeys Quart - All Flavors
Mickeys Grab2Go Quart (32oz) Of Your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor
Pint - Rum Raisin
Pint Of Rum Raisin Ice Cream
Pint - Happy Birthday
Empty Pint with Happy Birthday Label for a FREE Pint of Ice Cream when returned to the shop
Pint - Chocolate Black Raspberry Swirl
Black Raspberry Ice Cream With Chocolate Chunks
Pint - Butter Crunch
Toffee Ice Cream With Toffee Pieces
Pint - Java Chunk
Coffee Ice Cream With Chocolate Chunks
Pint - Cherry Vanilla
Vanilla Ice Cream With A Cherry Swirl And Cherry Chunks
Pint - Vanilla Chocolate Chip
Pint Of Vanilla Ice Cream With Chocolate Chips
Pint - White Chocolate Raspberry
Vanilla Ice Cream With Raspberry Swirl And Chocolate Raspberry Chunks
Pint - Chocolate
Chocolate Ice Cream
Pint - Vanilla
Premium Vanilla Ice Cream
Pint - Strawberry
Strawberry Ice Cream With Strawberry Chunks
Pint - Coconut Caramel Chip
Coconut Ice Cream With Caramel Swirl And Chocolate Chips
Pint - Rocky Road
Chocolate Ice Cream With Chocolate Chips, Nuts, & Marshmallows
Pint - Birthday Cake
Vanilla Ice Cream With Cake Pieces And Rainbow Sprinkles
Pint - Butter Pecan
Nutty Ice Cream With Roasted Pecan Pieces
Pint - Chocolate PB Ripple
Chocolate Ice Cream With Peanut Butter Ripple
Pint - Vanilla PB Ripple
Vanilla Ice Cream With Peanut Butter Ripple
Pint - Moosetracks
Vanilla Ice Cream With Fudge Ripple Peanut Butter Cups And Chocolate Chips
Pint - Celebration Pint
Fill A Pint With Any Desired Flavor
Pint - Pistachio Almondine
Pistachio Ice Cream With Almond Pieces
Pint - Peppermint Bark
Peppermin Infused Ice Cream With Dark Chocolate Chips And White Chocolate Chips
Pint - Cookie Dough
Vanilla Ice Cream With Chocolate Chips And Cookie Dough Chunks
Pint - Cookie Monster
Blue Vanilla Ice Cream With Oreo Cookie Pieces
Pint - Mint Chip
Mint Ice Cream With Chocolate Chunks
Pint - Rainbow Cookie
Vanilla Ice Cream With Italian Rainbow Cookie chunks
Pint - Coffee
Rich & Smooth Coffee Flavored Ice Cream
Pint - Cookies & Cream
Vanilla Ice Cream With Crushed Cookie Pieces
Pint - Brownie Smores
Vanilla Ice Cream With Marshmallows, Graham Pieces, & Chocolate Chips
Pint - Cannoli Chip
Vanilla Ice Cream With Cannoli Shell Chunks And Cannoli Chocolate Chips
Pint - Choco-Holic
Chocolate Ice Cream With Chocolate Hunks And Chocolate Fudge Swirl
Shake
Small Shake (16 oz)
16oz Cup Of Your Favorite Ice Cream & Toppings Blended To Perfection
Large Shake (20 oz)
20 Oz Shake Cup Of Your Favorite Ice Cream & Toppings Blended To Perfection
Float
Cookie Dough MickStacker
Stacked Soft Serve Ice Cream With Cookie Dough Bites & Hershey Chocolate Syrup In A Large Cup
Mick Stacker - Cookies N ' Cream
Mick Stacker Cookies N ' Cream Overload Is Half Shake & Half Sundae With Spoonfuls Of Soft Serve Ice Cream Stacked With Crushed Chocolate Cremed-filled Cookies, Hersheys Syrup, & More Crushed Cookies
Peanut Butter MickStacker
Peanut Butter MickStacker Is Half Shake & Half Sundae With Spoonfuls Of Soft Serve Ice Cream Stacked With Peanut Butter Cups, Peanut Butter Sauce, Chocolate Syrup & Mini Reeses Pieces
Ice Cream Soda - Large Cup
A Classic Blend of Milk, Chocolate Syrup, & the Perfect Splash of Cold Seltzer Topped with a Scoop of Your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor.
Egg Creme - Large
The Brooklyn Summer Classic Blend of Milk, Chocolate Syrup, & the Perfect Splash of Cold Seltzer for a Refreshing Old-School Neighborhood Treat.
Ice Cream Soda Float (Large Only)
Enjoy Your Soda Flavor poured over Your Favorite Mickey's Ice Cream Flavor in our Large Resealable Cup With a Lid.
Delivery Orders will have Ice Cream Scooped in Cup & soda delivered closed for you to pour-over when ready.
Pre-Made
Party Sundae Kit + 3pints (12-16)
Ultimate Party Sundae Bundle Serves 12-16 Guest Includes 3 Pints, 8 Cones, 8 Cups, 6 Toppings, 2 Wet Toppings & Carry Tray
Sandwich - Lil Micks (9pack)
Lil Micks Mini Ice Cream Sandwich 9-Pack Includes 3x Vanilla, 3x Chocolate, & 3x Swirl On Snack Size Entenmanns Mini Chocolate Chip Cookies
Sandwich - Lil Micks (4pack)
Enjoy Your Favorite Snackable Size Entenmann's Mini Chocolate Chip Cookies with Mickey's Soft Serve Ice Cream. Lil Micks Mini Ice Cream Sandwich 4-Pack has 2x Vanilla & 2x Chocolate In Each Pack.
Soft Serve Cone Dipped In Hard Shell
Hard Shell Dipped Soft Serve Ice Cream On A Sugar Cone
Bundle - Waffle Cone Kit +3 pints
Mickey's Custom Bundle To Make Your Own 10 Waffle Cone Kit + 3 pints
Soft Serve Chocolate Chip Cookie - 6-Pack
Six (6) 3" Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwiches With Ice Cream in a Plastic Resealable Sleeve. Topping May Arrive Seperately Based On Availability.
Hard Scoop Ice Cream Sandwich (6-Pack)
Six (6) 3" Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches With Your Favorite Hard Ice Cream Flavor & Favorite Dry Topping In A Resalable Sleeve. Topping May Arrive Seperately Based On Availability.
Bundle - No Bake Mich-Wich Kit (10 Sandwiches)
The Mickey's 10-PACK Mick-Wich Ice Cream Sandwich Party Bundle is the perfect Build-Your-Own Party Pack Includes 3 Pints. Be the Best Party Guest
Bundle - No Bake Sandwich Kit (4 Sandwich)
No Mess, No Baking needed for this Mickwich Ice Cream Sandwich Kit creates Four Colossal ice cream sandwiches
4-Pack Oreo Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich (4oz Each)
Four (4) 3" Oreo Cookie Sandwiches With Your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor Rolled In Your Favorite Topping. Topping May Arrive Seperately Based On Availability.
Oreo Sandwich (Single)
Large 3" Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich With Your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor Rolled In Your Favorite Dry Topping
4 JuniorvCup Sampler
Select 4 Ice Cream Flavors To Sample In Our Junior Size
Bake Your Own Kit - (4 Mick-wich)
Bake Your Own 4x Chocolate Chip Ice Cream With Pints & Toppings
Make Your Own Sundae Party Kit (4-8 Servings)
Mickey's Ice Cream Bundle offers 2 Ice Cream Pints, 4 Sundae Cups, & Cones, 4 Dry Toppings, 2 Wet Toppings with a resealable travel platter with clear lid.
Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich (Single)
Mick-wich Ice Cream Sandwich With Your Favorite Ice Cream Between Chocolate Chip Cookies Rolled In Favorite Toppings
4-Pack Of Homestyle Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches (4oz Each)
Four (4) Large Homestyle Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwiches With 4oz Scoop Of Your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor Rolled In Your Favorite Topping. Topping May Arrive Seperately Based On Availability.
Make Your Own Ice Cream Sandwich Kit (6-Pack)
Make 6 Ice Cream Sandwiches With Your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor In 2 Pints Included With 12 Chocolate Chip mcookies
Drink
Hals Blackberry Seltzer
Hals Blackberry Seltzer
Hals Seltzer Mango
Hals Seltzer Mango
Celsius Sparkling Grapefruit
Celsius Sparkling Grapefruit
Calypso Paradise Punch
Boylan Orange
Boylan Orange Soda
Boylan Black Cherry
Boylan Black Cherry Soda
Boylan Cream Soda
Boylan Shirley Temple
Boylan Root Beer
Boylan Root Beer Soda
Calypso Ocean Blue Lemonade
Calypso Ocean Blue Lemonade
Calypso Strawberry
Calypso Island Wave Lemonade
Calypso Island Wave Lemonade
Calypso Lemonade Original (16oz)
Calypso Lemonade Original (16oz)
Water - Essentia
20oz Essentia Water Bottle
Montauk Pink Lemonade
Montauk Pink Lemonade
Montauk Tea Southern
Montauk Premium Ice Tea Southern Sweet Tea Recipe (16oz)
Montauk Tea Raspberry
Montauk Tea Half n Half
Hals Ginger Ale
Hals Ginger Ale
Hals Seltzer Vanilla
Hals Seltzer Vanilla
Hals Seltzer Lime
Hals Seltzer Lime
Hals Seltzer Lemon
Hals Seltzer Lemon
Hals Seltzer Black Cherry
Hals Seltzer Original
Hals Seltzer Original
Celsius Strawberry
Celsius Peach Vibe
Celsius Sparkling Fuji Apple Pear
Celsius Sparkling Fuji Apple Pear
Celsius Kiwi Guava
Celsius Sparkling Watermelon
Celsius Sparkling Watermelon
Celsius Sparkling Wild Berry (12oz)
Celsius Sparkling Wild Berry (12oz)
Celsius Sparkling Orange (12oz)
Celsius Sparkling Orange (12oz)
Soda - Dr Pepper (12oz)
Soda - Sunkist (12oz)
Soda - Root Beer (12oz)
Soda - Sprite (12oz)
Soda - Coke (12oz)
Water - Poland Springs (16.9oz)
Cakes & Pies
Mick-Wich 8" Ice Cream Sandwich (8-10 Servings)
Mick-Wich 8" Round Chocolate Chunk Ice Cream Sandwich With Your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor & Topping . Serves 8-10 Peoples
Cake Candle Numbers (All)
Celebrate With Cake Candles Number In 3" Height
Cake - 8" Round Ice Cream Cake (Serves 10-14)
Serve 10-14 Slices of Ice Cream Cake With Vanilla & Chocolate Ice Cream With A Fudge Crunchies Filling
Cake - 6" Round Ice Cream Cake (Serves 6-8)
Serves 6-8 slices of Ice Cream Cake With Vanilla & Chocolate Ice Cream With A Fudge Crunchies Filling
Non-Dairy (All)
Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert - 1 Scoop
Enjoy a Classic Cup with a Single Scoop of Our Non-Dairy Flavor with Toppings of Your Choice.
Pint - Non-Dairy Sorbet
A 16oz Resealable Pint Container of Water-Based Sorbet (based on availability).
Non-Dairy Shake (16oz)
A Classic 16oz Shake with Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert Blended With Almond Milk for a Refreshing Treat.
Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert (4 Scoop)
Enjoy a Classic Cup with Four Scoops of Our Non-Dairy Flavor with Toppings of Your Choice.
Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert (3 Scoops)
Enjoy a Classic Cup with Three Scoops of Our Non-Dairy Flavor with Toppings of Your Choice.
Non-Dairy Frozen Desserts - 2 Scoop
Enjoy a Classic Cup with Two Scoops of Our Non-Dairy Flavor with Toppings of Your Choice.
Pint - Non-Dairy Oat Based Flavors
A 16oz Resealable Pint Container of any Non-Dairy Oat-Based Frozen Dessert in the Specialty Flavor of your choice (based on availability).
Pint - Non-Dairy Chocolate
A 16oz Resealable Pint Container of Chocolate Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert (based on availability).
Pint - Non-Dairy Vanilla
A 16oz Resealable Pint Container of Vanilla Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert (based on availability).
Snack
Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar (1.55oz)
Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar (1.55oz)
12x Chocolate Chip Cookies Sleeve (No Pints)
Snack On 12x Delicious Chocolate Chip Cookies Sleeve (No Ice Cream Pints)
Chocolate Chip Cookies (2 pack)
Indulge With Our 2 Pack Of Our Delicious Chocolate Chip Cookies
Brownie - Fudge (Single)
Add a Fudge Brownie Square to Any Size Sundae Cup on Your Order.
Toppings
Topping- Cannoli Shell Pieces
Resealable 3oz Container with Lid of Cannoli Chips
Topping - M&Ms
Resealable 3oz Container with Lid of mini M&M's
Topping - Caramel
Resealable 3oz Container with Lid of Caramel
Topping - Hot Fudge
Resealable 3oz Container with Lid of Hot Fudge
Topping - Sour Pieces
Resealable 3oz Container with Lid of Sour Candies based on Availability
Topping - Gummy Bears
Resealable 3oz Container with Lid of Gummy Bears
Topping - Oreo Chunks
Resealable 3oz Container with Lid of Oreo Cookies Crushed
Topping - Chocolate Crunchies
Resealable 3oz Container with Lid of Chocolate Crunchies
Topping - Chocolate Sprinkles
Resealable 3oz Container with Lid of Chocolate Sprinkles
Topping - Rainbow Sprinkles
Resealable 3oz Container with Lid of Rainbow Sprinkles
Apparel
Hat - Mickeys Circle Logo (All)
Mickeys Ice Cream Kitchen Circle Logo On Snapback Mesh Trucker Hat
Short Sleeve - Mickeys Flag (carolina)
Photos
+20 photos
+19 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Best ice cream ever!! Mickeys makes the best milk shake and always has the best service. Max, one of the employees, always goes above and beyond. He makes us feel so welcomed every time we come in & remembers our order— it just brings a smile to our face. Cheers to more ice cream & for Max being the best!
September 2025
Mikey’s Ice Cream in St. James delivers the goods. Tons of flavors, creamy perfection, and my pretzel peanut butter scoop was a salty sweet masterpiece. Outdoor seating, parking in the back, and yeah it’s a bit pricier, but totally worth every lick.
August 2025
We have had two birthday parties at Mickeys and they were both excellent! They are easy to work with and have wonderful staff. Their ice cream is the best in the area and they host many great community events throughout the year. Highly recommend!!
July 2025
